Software
Houzz Logo Print
danielle3013

Such a big decision....need help

6 years ago

We had a flood in our basement and now in the process of a reno. I have light grey floors upstairs and will be redoing the front entry with tile/slate (split entry) I'm so confused on what floors to do downstairs. I love the dark rustic brown but dont know if it will look alright and with covid19 I cant go anywhere to view samples... does anyone have any suggestions on color and if both grey and brown will tie in or just look funny...living near toronto ontario so flooring must be available in canada.

I added a few of the flooring colors I'm thinking of and the grey I have upstairs...if anyone has used something similar under $4/sqft please post apic with manufacturer and color. Thank you!!!!

Comments (13)

  • 6 years ago

    Lots of choices at HD and Lowes and these stores are still open. Purchase a box or 2, place it to see if you like the color and return later.

  • 6 years ago

    @ratherbesewing The stores are open for curb side pick up only. No one is allowed in the stores.

  • 6 years ago

    Of the samples you posted, i like the last one the best. The first is a bit dark for a basement, the “rustic” is too trendy and looks fake.


    Perhaps you can order a few samples for delivery or pickup as ratherbesewing suggested. Otherwise, can you wait to make a selection?

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Have you used really dark smooth floors before? People complain that they show every spec of dirt and dust.

    Medium tones without a strong grain or pattern are usually the safest choice. The last one looks pretty good to me. You really need a sample so you can see how it looks in your basement lighting.

  • 6 years ago

    Why can’t you match what you did on the main floor?

  • 6 years ago

    Perhaps more important than your upstairs floor is to match the tile/slate in the entry. Do you have pics of what you will use there? And how much of the basement floors are able to be seen from the entry?

  • 6 years ago

    I caution people to work a little LIGHTER than they anticipate. The reason: darker floors in a darker space (basements in T.O. can be long narrow and POORLY lit) will DARKEN the space even more.


    I'm sorry to hear about the flooding. Hopefully you will have found the source and dealt with it. I would work with the LIGHTEST option you can stomach. Once it is in place it will DARKEN the space SOOOOO much that it will 'look' like the darkest sample. I kid you not.


    The easiest way to test this theory is to take a sample of any form of wood (2"x4" = fine) and place it in the DARKEST corner of your basement. I mean the deepest darkest recess of your basement. Now turn the lights OFF. And wait for the sun to set. Now assess the colour. Notice how it no longer looks 'blonde'?


    Right. that's the effect a dark(er) floor will have on your space in full daylight. It will look DARKER than what it really is.


    Your first photo would look 'black' in most basements (almost no colour variation between planks...no glint of wood tones...nothing but dark plank). The second photo will look as dark as the floor in your first photo. All the lovely variations will vanish leaving a floor with a hint of life...but nothing more.


    Do not make a purchase without seeing a sample board in your space. Remember to place it in the DARKEST corner, in the evening light with the lights OFF. Now assess the 'colour' or the look of the wood. If you like it when the basement is 'almost' dark...then you will LOVE it when the sun is up.


    If you have to, start ordering single boxes of flooring from HD, Lowe's or Rona. Each box will be almost $100 but so be it. It is the cost of doing your research properly. Do not get 'panic purchase'. It never works out.

  • 6 years ago

    Lowe's and Home Depot are open in Virginia. Curbside pickup is available, also, but the stores are open. Some with reduced hours.

  • 6 years ago

    She's in Canada, as she said, so Virginia rules don't apply.


  • 6 years ago

    thanks everyone. our house is an elevated split entry bungalow so lots of light in the basement as windows are big and above ground. when entering you can see basement floor and stairs but can not see upstairs floor. No design upstairs as of yet but it will all be redone in the near future so flow is actually starting from the basement up. I really like the floors upstairs and can run them throughout I just really like the brown floors and was hoping to incorporate them together....I attached a better pic of the grey floors.

    I agree with the dark floor looking too dark. I have ordered a few samples from a manufacturer today and am going to try the wood in the darkest spot theory when the samples arrive.

  • 6 years ago

    I think even if they can't be seen at the same time, using the same flooring throughout gives a better flow to the house. If you really like the flooring you have, you know you'll like it in the lower floor. Adding something new will be a risk, not only for a lack of flow but for how it actually looks in the rooms.

  • 6 years ago

    She's in Canada, as she said, so Virginia rules don't apply.


    I apologize. Obviously I just looked at the pictures, not the words. ;>)

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio