Software
Houzz Logo Print
april_thomas19

New Exterior Paint Second Thoughts

6 years ago

I just had the exterior of my home painted and I’m not sure it looks good. Something seems off to me, but I’m not sure if it’s just me or if there is a simple fix. The main color was supposed to be a dark gray but it looks more brown, but that isn’t necessarily the problem. The red also seems VERY red. There is so much contrast that it looks busy to me. Am I just adjusting to the change or are my fears founded? (It’s the front with the stone I’m concerned about. We had to pick paint colors that also matched the mostly brown and red brick on the side and mostly siding in the back. Those areas look good.)


Comments (20)

  • 6 years ago

    You have a beautiful home.

    The red picks up the red in your bricks.

    The one thing that seems a tiny bit off is the shutter design. There are two large X's in each shutter that add too much detail (too busy) IMO. I'm not a pro so maybe it is supposed to be that way. I hope the pro's weigh in soon.


    April Thomas thanked Denita
  • 6 years ago

    I like it. I don't think you'd want the darker shade any more "grey" in tone. It appears to be just right against that roof.

    I also like the red. It might just be the shock of the change. Give it a bit of time and see if you don't start to enjoy the new color.

    April Thomas thanked Holly Stockley
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    The paint color looks good with the brick and roof. I find the "X" shutters to be a bit too barn-like for the style of the house; I would change the style for something simpler. Consider staining the reddish bricks above the window to better match the stone. Try using a blue for new shutters. Maybe a robin's egg blue or a grey/blue. Removing the hedges that are blocking the view of the porch and look to be crowding the Japanese maple would be first on my list.


    Arcadia English Remodel · More Info


    Lebaron Farm · More Info


    April Thomas thanked decoenthusiaste
  • 6 years ago

    I agree the X's look too busy. The garage door would be nice with some windows across the top. The main color looks nice with the roof and stone.

    I also agree with deco regarding the hedges. The porch and pretty JM need more focus.


    April Thomas thanked chloebud
  • 6 years ago

    I really like the colors..you did a really good job working with your brick....and I think the shutters are fine....but long term, I would choose to remove the hedges.

    April Thomas thanked fissfiss
  • PRO
    6 years ago

    It works. But agree with some of the other commenters regarding the shutters. If you have the budget, replace them with a simpler style.

    April Thomas thanked Sabrina Alfin Interiors
  • 6 years ago

    You might be able to rework the shutters by removing the "X" parts, sanding down, priming and re-painting.

    April Thomas thanked decoenthusiaste
  • 6 years ago

    Thank you all! Any suggestions on what to put in place of the hedges? I’ve never liked them either and have been planning to remove them at some point. They were literally the only landscaping I left from the previous homeowner. I’ve attached a picture of the house when we bought it. You couldn’t actually see much of the house. We recently replaced all of the windows and a couple doors as well.


  • 6 years ago

    Put out some pretty annuals for color this summer and get some dwarf shrubs to put in next fall. if you do blue shutters, blue hydrangeas in a dwarf variety would be pretty, but they'll lose their leaves. Depends on whether or not you could live with bare branches in the winter.

    April Thomas thanked decoenthusiaste
  • 6 years ago

    I searched Japanese Maples on Houzz, and it came up with a ton of pretty pictures...all depends on your climate and exposure.

    April Thomas thanked fissfiss
  • 6 years ago

    I think the colors look great. I even like the shutters.

    You might be able to hand prune the bushes that are getting too big.

    Lovely and unusual home.

    April Thomas thanked houssaon
  • 6 years ago

    Do you think I could apply some kind of glaze to tone down the red?

  • 6 years ago

    The house looks nice.

    I'd remove everything in front of the porch and plant ground cover instead.

    Hiding the porch makes the house seem unfriendly. I'd also remove the shutters from the middle window.


    April Thomas thanked emmarene9
  • 6 years ago

    I think your home is lovely, I would take out hedge, it hides too much of your entrance. I wouldn’t worry re the red shutters etc, it will tone down somewhat with the weather in time

    April Thomas thanked Irene Morresey
  • 6 years ago

    If it was my house I would paint shutters the same color as garage. Keep the red door.

    April Thomas thanked keith Dcil
  • 6 years ago

    I agree with the comments to take off the shutters for the porch windows and paint the left shutters the same as the garage. Let the red door draw your attention to the entrance. Right now the red shutters on the left overwhelm attention. The entrance gets lost. The shrubs in front of the porch need to be removed since they block the porch view, Besides, the sheared shrubs are high maintenance to keep trimmed. Depending on your location, you should be able to find some dwarf shrubs that max out around 2' and don't need trimming into "boxes". Your house is lovely--just a few tweaks to get it to its maximum beauty.

    April Thomas thanked Barbara
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    IMO....Yes, what Barbara said. The house looks unbalanced because the right side is all brown and the left is mostly red. The two sides don't relate to one another at all. Like 2 different houses. Remove the X part of the big shutters and paint them the same brown as the garage and gable. Remove the porch shutters and hedges blocking the porch. I wish someone would mock that up for you. I think it would look amazing. Beautiful house!

    April Thomas thanked mick50
  • 6 years ago


    I really loved the red shutters but I admit it is better this way.

    April Thomas thanked emmarene9
  • 6 years ago

    emmarene9, I agree. This looks much better. Can you take off the shutters off on the left? The window are slightly rounded while the shutters are square. Shutters should look as if they could be closed over the windows. In this case, the shutters doesn't match the house. Also, in my opinion, the dark garage door with so much roof makes the house look "heavy". Without an expensive fix of changing the paint color, the elimination of the shutters may help lighten up the look and look more balanced.

    April Thomas thanked Barbara