Software
Houzz Logo Print
pete_franetovich

Mystery w AC Unit

6 years ago

Our upstairs AC unit is a Trane. The unit in the attic quit working two weeks ago. My HVAC contractor replace the motor and that made sense because the motor was bad. The motor would not turn at all. The AC unit still wouldn’t work. My contractor determined that it was the control panel. He replaced the control panel. But the AC unit still does not work. My contractor checked the electrical wiring harness. And the harness is fine. Any ideas what could be causing the AC unit to not work? My contractor did testing to confirm that the thermostat works well and the outside equipment works well. The problem is in the attic. Any ideas???

Comments (12)

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    This sounds like the problem is the HVAC contractor. He doesn't know how to do a proper diagnosis so he keeps changing parts to see if a wild guess will fix the problem.

    Call someone else.


  • 6 years ago

    ^^^^^ What he said!

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Hard to stop a Trane, even harder to find someone who knows how to fix one... when it derails. (Tranes don't stop - they derail.)

    Seriously you need a new HVAC contractor.

  • 6 years ago

    Are you paying for all these failed repair attempts?

    Pete Franetovich thanked mike_home
  • 6 years ago

    Would definitely recommend contacting a new HVAC contractor. Other factors that you might want to take into account is how old your system is and how often you get it checked out.

  • 6 years ago

    Mike_home, u misunderstood the question, I didn’t ask about paymental to this guy? I can handle that question all by myself. I was asking what’s wrong with my AC. :) My guess is none of u have technical expertise cuz most of the responses avoided the question and suggested ditching the guy. :) In the meantime my guy came back today determined that the new out-of-the-box module is the culprit. He took the new module/motor unit back to the supply warehouse and will bring another new one back tomorrow. If any ya’ll have technical knowledge I’m all ears, but I can determine who to pay and how much. :)

  • 6 years ago

    Ok u r right, folks on this board can’t guess about technical solutions. So it seems if the technical solution is not obvious, or if it exists among “50 different reasons”, then this board is happy to make a guess and fire the contractor. Sounds lazy to me. I was hoping ya’ll would at least give a brief mention of some possible technical solutions (motor module). Ya’ll are in much better position to provide technical advice from a distance than ya are to judge a contractors performance from a distance. Sorry if u r pissed off, I just expected nothing more than some brainstorming on tech advice. :)

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Not pissed off.

    Motor module? what kind of 'motor module'. What kind of 'motor'. There are many kinds of motors, they aren't one size fits all.

    No model #, no serial # of the unit in question... yeah we're supposed to know that too huh? You sent it telepathically I suppose?

    If you can't give specifics, of which you likely don't know yourself... how then could we estimate a guess that is likely to help.

    Just blame it on the 'boomers'. No wisdom here.

    We just like to keep things real here... you know the opposite of 'fake'.

  • 6 years ago

    "... my guy came back today determined that the new out-of-the-box module is the culprit. He took the new module/motor unit back to the supply warehouse and will bring another new one back tomorrow."


    Hi Pete,

    I am very happy to hear your guy determined the module/motor unit was defective. Will he also be returning the control panel? No need to replace an expensive control panel if the original problem was module/motor unit.


    If swapping the module/motor unit does not resolve the problem, then could you provide the Trane model number and a few photos? This information is needed if you want others to remotely diagnose the problem.

  • 6 years ago

    mike_home, thank you, that has been the only productive comment in the thread, I’ll come back to u with Trane model # if the newly unstalled motor module does not work, thank you.

  • 6 years ago

    mike-home, turns out it was a case of the new motor / module being defective. He installed the second motor / module today and the entire system works fine.