Software
Houzz Logo Print
sarab2314

Thoughts on house plan

6 years ago

Hello, all!

This will be our first time building a home and it is extremely difficult choosing a plan when you can’t see how the inside actually looks. Are there any tips you have for this? I was wondering if I could get some opinions on this plan from Architectural Designs - Plan 510143WDY.

We aren’t looking for a completely open plan concept. We like a more intimate feeling in each room. I thought the fireplace would be a good divider between kitchen and living room.

Do you think the small windows will allow enough natural light?

I appreciate your time So much!


https://www.architecturaldesigns.com/house-plans/exclusive-2-story-acadian-house-plan-with-2-sided-fireplace-510143wdy

Comments (40)

  • 6 years ago

    Of course, we don’t know who will be living in the house, where you are located, or what the site is like.

    But the first thing that jumps out at me is, the bathroom is bigger than the kitchen! Bigger than the bedroom!

    And yes, it will be dark, in large part because of the sunroom. It keeps the sun out of the living room and keeping room.

  • 6 years ago

    what the heck is a "keeping room"?

  • 6 years ago

    The best plan for you and your family is the one your architect designs based on all your and your family's inputs, wants and desires, and that will be fully integrated inside and out with your lot and its geographical orientation. Best wishes on your new project.

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    One of the most important things in a home's design is how it relates to its site. It should function with site circulation, emerge from the topography, capture the desired views, block the undesired views, and just plain fit. Selecting a pre-conceived design and plopping on a site is a poor way build a home or live a life. Jazz Easy is right.

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    A "keeping room" is space for food to cool, keeping it from staying warm, while being transported from a kitchen to a dining room. My thoughts on the house design are not positive.

  • 6 years ago

    Are there any tips you have for this?

    Yes!

    Firstly, of course, hiring a licensed architect definitely has its advantages. :-) Fee structures vary wildly between them, so don't assume they're outside the budget before talking with a few of them. <3

    Secondly, if you ultimately decide not to hire an architect, one of the quickest ways to evaluate floor plans is to count how many rooms deep the house is. To maximize sunshine reaching interior spaces, look for a plan that is 1-2 rooms deep, including attached garages and covered porches. The plan you posted is 3-5 rooms deep, which will severely limit/virtually eliminate natural light in the rooms without windows. Some folks are okay with this; others would be miserable.

    A skinny house can also have the advantage of a simpler roof, which can save tons of money in building, maintenance, and repairs. Not to mention less roof is often more aesthetically pleasing. ;-)

    Thirdly, if you live in the northern hemisphere, southern-facing shared spaces are ideal for most folks. Generally speaking, western-facing spaces can get horribly hot and suffer from harsh glare, regardless of which hemisphere you're in. Something else to consider.

    There are tons of things to think about, but these are my top priorities. Hope this helps!

    sarab2314 thanked One Devoted Dame
  • 6 years ago

    I really like that plan in general, but that master bathroom is ridiculous lol.


    There are a lot of things you could easily eliminated in this plan. Not going to get into that.


    More importantly, need info about the site, your needs, neighborhood, etc first

    sarab2314 thanked sprink1es
  • 6 years ago

    Do you need that many rooms? A living room/keeping room dining room, dining room and breakfast room).


    I understand you like separation, but this seems a very bulky place and the living room and keeping room will most likely be very dark.


    The dining room seems fairly far from the kitchen. Look at all the rooms you need to go through when taking dished between the two rooms.


    As others have said, the bathroom is huge compared to the master bedroom. I am not sure why you need a full bathroom next to the study (except if it is a 7th bedroom). Is there really two toilets in the master?



    sarab2314 thanked Ig222
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    The breakfast nook is almost as far from the kitchen as the dining room. I foresee a table in the keeping room, and a “my spot” in the breakfast nook. You know, for reading, internet use, talking on the phone.

    With the addition of doors, the dining room, wet bar, and bedroom 2 would make a nice in-law suite, the wet bar could be a kitchenette.

    There‘s no guest closet in the foyer, so I’m guessing you are building in, say, the Tucson area? (I know, that’s a leap, I’m just wondering if you need a guest closet?)

    sarab2314 thanked bpath
  • PRO
    6 years ago

    From the exterior, it looks like four different, unrelated designs as one looks at each elevation of the house. Not good!


    In the interior, the master bath/closet is ridiculously oversized; the dining room is a week away from the kitchen; and the second story window on the right of the front elevation is a fake.


    It's possible to do much better with a local architect.

  • 6 years ago

    But Virgil, the picture shows a tv on in there. That‘s pretty funny!

  • 6 years ago

    You lovely people,

    I posted this not knowing if I would get a response at all. I am truly so grateful for all the input!

    Our lot is on a completely flat piece of land with no focal point and also no eye sore we would want to eliminate from view. I do understand that hiring an architect would be most ideal - We just thought if we could find a plan that is close to our dream and then adjust to fit us personally from there, we could cut the cost down a great deal.

    Your comments on the bathroom are making me laugh - those were my first thoughts exactly. We wondered about making the Study bigger to eliminate most of that space (an extra toilet to clean - no thanks). Also, a bath in the study isn’t necessary.

    We also only desire 4 bedrooms, so we thought about getting rid of a bedroom/bathroom upstairs and making one big room.

    The wet bar would become a coat closet and the sunroom may be left off completely.

    Honestly, the kitchen to living room area is what keeps me stuck on this plan. As well as liking the Acadian/French look of the home. The keeping room, breakfast nook, fireplace, pantry, kitchen, utility, mud room.. I haven’t been able to find a plan like it. We also would like a study/library, master, and 1 bedroom on the first floor.

    Are there any books/articles you recommend that help a great deal when building/picking out a plan?

    Again.. THANK YOU for all the helpful thoughts. You are appreciated!

  • 6 years ago

    Wow -I looked at the first picture and found the house to be rather charming. I should have stopped there!


    I can see how you could find it attractive from that pic and the garage is around side / back which is nice.


    And then I saw all the other things - the other elevations (sad...), the interesting spaces and relationships, ALL THE TOILETS - it's home designed for the Tidy Bowl Man, I think! (and the poor guest who has to traverse to the "powder room" - "hey, you mind moving my whites from the washer to the dryer while you're going that way?")


    Anyway - if this plan is in budget, get an architect - I am pretty sure you can do better. ;-)

    sarab2314 thanked just_janni
  • PRO
    6 years ago

    "Are there any books/articles you recommend that help a great deal when building/picking out a plan?"

    A local architect, list of your needs and wants, and a site survey.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    The best part of that house is the exterior front elevation. Bring that and all of the above to your architect.

    sarab2314 thanked Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
  • 6 years ago

    The kitchen-keeping room-living room does look charming. There are issues with the surrounding space, though.

    With the master bedroom door right in the middle of the LR, there is less wall space for tv, books, piano if you have one, art.

    I like the Friends entrance. Tbh, it’s probably what most people will use, since the driveway leads right up to it. But when you come in from garage or friends entrance, to get to your or the kids bedrooms, it‘s a convoluted route around furniture and fireplaces.

    It‘s also a convoluted route to the outdoor kitchen. Imagine walking all that way with a platter of hamburger patties, etc. and the only door is through the living room. You might want it closer, as well as another entry point, say, from the laundry or breakfast nook (which I don’t think will hold a table anyway).

    Also with the friends entrance, will the front door be used any time other than Halloween? I imagine you would have a walkway across the front to the driveway, but still, don’t you think most people will use the friends entrance?

    Looking at plans is so fun, until you looking for YOUR plan. It isn’t in the books. There have been books recommended here for what to consider in a plan (I can’t remember, can someone share?) But your plan is awaiting an architect to draw it out, so to speak.

    sarab2314 thanked bpath
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Wow! That master bath/closet are larger than any single room in the house. Larger than the living room, master bedroom or the keeping room. I personally would never give up so much space where I'm not spending the majority of my day!

    And yes the house will be very dark.

    A keeping room where I assume you'll have island seating, a breakfast room which means more seating and a dining room which is quite a hike from the kitchen for even more seating?

    Your living room once in include the pathways will be allow 12' x 12' for seating.

    3 doors in the study's bathroom? Why?

    How do you plan to bring furniture into the study and the master bedroom with those too narrow alcoves?

    How do you plan to view the corner fireplace in the master?

    Why the double doors into the bathroom? Is it that special?

    Anyone needing the powder room needs to walk through the middle of the keeping room?

    Mudroom is too narrow for more than one person at a time in there. Now think kids, groceries, backpacks, outerwear, etc

    Do you really want to shlep clothing through the whole house to get to the laundry room? Personally I love having mine right next to MY master bedroom.

    Kitchen is very poorly designed unless you prefer preparing using roller skates.

    Outdoor kitchen is quite a hike from indoor kitchen. Make sure you never forget something indoors.

    Pantry is across the kitchen and furthest away from fridge which means hauling stuff back and forth when unloading groceries.

    Breakfast nook is too small for anything larger than a small round bistro table.

    Where do guests, etc hang coats, put wet umbrellas, etc?

    Clothes in closets can't turn corners so those so called WIC's are not and wasted space.

    What ODD mentioned also is good because houses only 1-2 rooms deep allow for windows on 2 or more walls in all public rooms and all bedrooms. Great for cross ventilation and natural light.

    Where in all the upstairs bedrooms will you put the beds?

    I see no broom closet, linen closets or even a mechanical room for your HVAC.

    I'm very unimpressed.

    Have you considered instead of wasting time looking at floor plans, working with a person of design talent?

  • 6 years ago

    Would you all recommend seeking an architect that seems to design the specific style of house we are thinking of, even if they are located out of our state?

  • 6 years ago

    I haven’t been able to find a plan like it. We also would like a study/library, master, and 1 bedroom on the first floor.

    You're getting enthralled with the few pretties. Find an architect to create YOUR vision and not some generic designer's vision. By the time your done "fixing" this plan with a draftsman, you could have had exactly what you want for I'm guessing the same price.

    sarab2314 thanked cpartist
  • 6 years ago

    You all have been very helpful and honest. This will be our “forever home”, so I think you‘re right. The square footage was bigger than we were looking for, so if we have it designed to our needs, the money we would save in square footage could cover the cost for an architect.

  • 6 years ago

    Also, these details you are noticing are opening my eyes to what to look for in the future. For example, narrow hallways/entrances to rooms that won’t allow furniture to get through.

  • 6 years ago

    And looking at how many rooms deep a house is. 👍🏼 I love these experienced insights.

  • 6 years ago

    ^^^ it does make you critic now, doesn't it? :-)

  • 6 years ago

    Miss Sara, your thread has been fun and encouraging for me! So many times, we see folks post floor plans, and then react strongly (and negatively) to the feedback given. You are such a doll. <3

    Would you all recommend seeking an architect that seems to design the specific style of house we are thinking of, even if they are located out of our state?

    I'd keep it as local as possible. I'm in a big state, though, lol, so "out of state" is like a 9 hour drive. If you're up in the Northeast, where 5 states could comfortably fit inside Texas, then I would absolutely consider out-of-state candidates.

    For me, the most important aspect of the whole architect thing was finding a sole practitioner. I just didn't want to deal with a firm; I'm a one-on-one kind of person. After narrowing things down to the folks who flew solo, I searched their websites for evidence of creativity. I have several architectural styles I like, and the guy I ended up with had my favorite style featured on his site. Unfortunately, I'm not getting that style (there are 3 other adults involved in my project, and none of them want a Storybook house, lol), but I looooved the creativity and detail expressed in that house. He's been in business for over 40 years, and has experience with my style (Spanish Colonial), so I'm happy. He's down to earth, straightforward, and showed up to our interview at my house in steel toed boots, jeans, and a polo, fresh off the jobsite. Perfect!

    All of that to say, it's about personality compatibility, too, not just architectural style. <3

    sarab2314 thanked One Devoted Dame
  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Sometimes even the architect is surprised on how nice it turned out.

  • 6 years ago

    Are there any books/articles you recommend that help a great deal when building/picking out a plan?


    Here's a thread with some book suggestions. https://www.houzz.com/discussions/3281434/book-suggestions Spend a little time on what makes for a good house. It's mostly intangible things.

    sarab2314 thanked Architectrunnerguy
  • 6 years ago

    Ditto what the Dame said! From her first paragraph on!

    sarab2314 thanked bpath
  • 6 years ago

    Yes! You’re right. We want this to be a reflection of our family and our lifestyle... so, if we can make a way for an architect to fit in the budget then it only makes sense to take that road. It’ll be exciting watching it come together. We are in the NE and have some searching to do it sounds like. Any red flags we should watch out for? THANK YOU ALL!

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Architectrunnerguy and RES, architect are both located in the north eastern United States. Check them out. Just to be clear, they are NOT red flags.

    sarab2314 thanked Mark Bischak, Architect
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Any red flags we should watch out for?

    Things that I avoided:

    • Unlicensed with my state's architectural board (AIA membership not considered a plus or a minus)
    • History of lawsuits (I checked courthouse records by county, based on his resume)
    • Portfolio with house designs that exceeded 2 rooms deep
    • Portfolio with house designs that were "trendy" -- overuse of shiplap, gray, "modern farmhouse" style, too many different window types, unidentifiable style, etc.
    • Services that excluded Site Supervision during construction (or a reluctance to do it)
    • Lack of networking (I wanted someone that would recommend a solid, trustworthy builder)
    • Showy or salesman-like
    • Failure to share at least a few *very basic* ideas/guidance for my project during the interview (I didn't expect any free floorplans or anything; but I did appreciate information like how many acres he recommended for what I needed, discussions of solar power and rainwater collection, and areas to avoid buying land due to terrible soil conditions)
    • Failure to give a good answer to my question, "What was your favorite project?" A response along the lines of, "I've had too many to pick a favorite," and not describing at least one of those favorites, doesn't cut it, lol


    Things that I embraced:

    • Gray hair or no hair (my architect has been in business for over 40 years)
    • Intense interest in my project
    • Willingness to come to my home for an interview (I have several children with special needs); this was well before all of the corona craziness, so an exception would be made now
    • Note-taking during our interview (the guy I picked was the only one who did this, for more than just a few minutes, to confirm my name and project type)
    • A fee structure based on "percentage of budget," because then I knew exactly how much his services would be -- I disliked fees based on square footage, because I'm flexible with size, and felt that there wouldn't be an incentive to keep square footage down (I may have 7 kids, but I don't want a 4,000+ square foot house, lol) or explore more than one or two concepts; and I disliked hourly fees, because even though I'm decisive and careful not to waste people's time, I don't want my architect to get too excited, running away with a ton of different, incompatible ideas and then charge me for it ;-) (I got this distinct impression from one guy I interviewed who, although obviously creative and full of ideas, seemed to be way more idealistic than pragmatic; he specifically mentioned that he charged hourly because he often "come(s) up with exciting ideas in the middle of the night that I just can't get out of my head" -- it was charming, in a way, but I'm thinking, "Yeaaaah, no, that's got 'runaway train' written all over it" lol)


    I'm certainly no expert, though, and have only done this once, so if any of my red flags (or green flags) are irrational or sophomoric, well, then, I guess my inexperience will afford me character building opportunities. :-D

    sarab2314 thanked One Devoted Dame
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I can't work up any enthusiasm for this house. Specific thoughts:

    - It's 4326 square feet. That's almost double the size of the average American house, and you say it's bigger than you need /bigger than you set out to find. Even if you ignore the cost of building, consider the cost (and the time!) of maintenance, taxes, heating and cooling.

    - The perimeter is full of jigs-and-jogs that'll drive up the price -- without adding anything to the comfort of the house.

    - Yes, the master bath jumps out as oversized /bloated. The vanity space is as large as a small kitchen -- how would you use all that? One toilet-in-a-closet is a pain to clean -- you want to clean two? I like the large shower and closet, but they can be had in a more efficient space.

    - The other bathrooms throughout the house are all "divided" into pieces, which is inefficient and is an obstacle to easy cleaning. And so many bathrooms to clean.

    - Consider bringing larger furniture through the 90-degree turn into the master bedroom. I'd fix this problem by adding a door directly to the porch. This would also make your house more fire-safe, which will be important since you say this is your "forever house" -- one day you'll be elderly in this house.

    - Again, one day you'll be elderly in this house -- it'd be nice if the laundry room were closer to your master closet. Fewer steps between, you know.

    - The bedrooms are all quite large and boast walk-in closets -- and, in comparison, the living space is small. Do you value bedrooms above family gathering space?

    - The kitchen and pantry are huge, but they're not particularly well laid-out. As other people have said, the tables would be placed far from the kitchen, making meals more difficult. I think -- in reality -- you'd end up placing your everyday table between the fireplace and the island because it'd be so much more convenient.

    - The outdoor kitchen is as far as possible from the kitchen, meaning you'd have a long way to carry trays of food for the grill. Inefficient.

    - I hate a friends' entrance. You're planning and spending on a nice foyer for the house ... then having people come through the family entrance? Makes no sense. Consider where guests would park /provide an obvious place that'd lead them through your "real entrance".

    - You ask about natural light. This house doesn't provide enough, especially in the living room, which is probably going to be your main living space/main gathering space. Note that the huge master bathroom features only a single window, and most of the other bathrooms have no natural light. Even the sunroom, being recessed into the house, won't have a whopping-big amount of light. The only rooms that will have nice natural light will be the kitchen and the master bedroom.

    Really, you can do better than this.

    sarab2314 thanked Mrs Pete
  • 6 years ago

    Mrs. Pete - I had the same thoughts about the cleaning / size, but then realized that usually those who can afford houses that size aren’t cleaning it themselves anyway, lol

  • 6 years ago

    One Devoted Dame, this will be written down for future reference. We have so much to learn and it’s very beneficial to hear from someone who has been through the process. These are excellent points! I cannot tell you how much I appreciate the input I’m getting here.

    Mrs. Pete, I hear you! It was a good decision posting this plan because not only did it save us from it 😉 But I have a better eye to critic and new insights to build from. I agree with your thoughts about the friend’s entrance - You’re right, I don’t want people never entering through the front door.

    I was assuming too much trouble/cost/time with an architect. I think the goal is just to find the right one and it will be more than worth it.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    those who can afford houses that size aren’t cleaning it themselves anyway, lol

    I suspect some do, some don't -- but regardless of who's up-close-and-personal with the toilets, fewer bathrooms /simpler bathrooms = a lower price paid to the cleaning person.

    But I have a better eye to critic and new insights to build from.

    That's the goal -- good for you! Keep reading and don't hurry into anything.

    sarab2314 thanked Mrs Pete
  • 6 years ago

    Wiscokid, I realize I would have created an entire day‘s job for myself. 🙈

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Another important factor when designing a home is to create a furniture layout before construction. In every addition and home build I've ever done we knew exactly where the furniture would be placed for the best enjoyment of the space!

  • 6 years ago

    Wiscokid, I realize I would have created an entire day‘s job for myself.

    :-O

    I only took a quick glance at the plan (it failed my Two Rooms Deep rule, so I moved on, sorry, lol), and when I went back to count toilets, after everyone commented on them, I was like, "Dang. I have 2 now, wish I had 3, not looking forward to 4 [if needed; depending on layout], and would permanently lock the doors on any bathrooms after that."

    I've got my own little special army over here, which keeps me plenty busy... I cannot imagine keeping up with 7 toilets, 12 sinks, and 5-6 tubs/showers. I know my limits. Mostly. :-D

  • 6 years ago

    Diana - Noted! I’m going to be more mindful of spaces I go into now. If someone’s living room feels comfortable and inviting thinking “How big is this - floor space, ceiling height” and how the furniture is arranged.

  • 6 years ago

    sarab, now that you've listened to some experienced opinions, and absorbed some of the features that make a house a dream vs. a nightmare, you can no doubt understand why we so often recommend that folks like you hire an architect!

    You don't know what you don't know. Trying to tweak an existing plan to suit your lot, your family, and your lifestyle is rarely going to result in a home that gives you joy every day. Few laypeople recognize that a little tweak here has impacts throughout the house, and few of us are accustomed to seeing house plans in 3 dimensions.

    Good luck with your project! Your willingness to listen to advice here bodes well for your relationship with an architect - you will probably listen to and embrace new ideas and concepts.

    sarab2314 thanked AnnKH