Software
Houzz Logo Print
leannehouse

Which pendant lights do you like better?

6 years ago

I'm removing the hood in this kitchen and putting pendant lights over the island. Which ones do you like better? Wood or metal?



Metal
Wood

Comments (17)

  • 6 years ago

    (not a pro) I prefer the metal pendants, but besides that I'm worried about you removing the hood. How will you vent the cooktop? And won't the lights get grease etc. splattered on them (especially if you do 3)? It doesn't seem like a good idea to hang a pendant right over a cooktop. Hoping some of the pros chime in.

    Can you show a picture of the kitchen as it is now, with the hood?

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    I prefer the metal myself. Material matches the fridge, easier to clean when needed, and prefer using three for what appears to be a fairly long island. Also the metal shades have opaque glass bottom where the woven shades do not. The glass will prevent glare from direct view of the bulbs inside, especially important when one has glossly countertops (as it appears you do). I would certainly suggest the pendants go on a separate dimmer. Provide pictures upon completion so we can all see how it turns out. Cheers!

    leannehouse thanked Brilliant! Lighting & Design
  • 6 years ago

    I think two is a better fit here, mostly because I would not want a fixture over my cook top.

    If you have a photo straight on that might help us. For now A is your better choice but I would consider 2 over three. If you plan to hang them more "in front" of the island do three but smaller version of the one you like.

  • 6 years ago

    You're removing the hood, will you have any ventilation for your cooktop? That's a bigger concern.


    Of the two options you provided, I prefer the metal.

  • 6 years ago

    Definitely the metal, not just for looks but because you will be needing to clean them often of the aerosolized grease from the cooktop.

    Are you sure that you want to remove the hood? there are excellent reasons, that outweigh looks, for having one.

  • 6 years ago

    Thanks everyone for your comments. I'm putting in a new induction cooktop that has downdraft venting (see the link below - it looks really cool). I've read that induction does not need as much venting because there is no gas and less heat. I'm hoping it works. I really like the look of pendants but you're right - cleaning is a big issue. Two at the sides is probably better. Thanks!

    https://elica.com/CA-en/aspiration-cooktop


  • 6 years ago

    I actually like the wood. I think it warms up the space and gives some texture and visual interest. I think the metal lights "blend in" too much with your appliances and cabinets. The wood pendants give a pop of life.

  • 6 years ago

    Or bump them forward a bit, then you can still have three and it makes sense for them to be over the eating area anyway.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Honestly, not crazy for either. The "silvers" (fridge and lights) don't match, (lights are much lighter/warmer silver than the darker silver fridge, plus too much silver for my taste.) I'd lean towards the Wood as it breaks up the silver/white, but not sure about the color. It kinda clashes with the wood of the island cabinets. What about Black (it could help pick up the only black thing in the kitchen, the Ovens or Clear Glass (with either very little silver trim or black trim to wood the glass,) ?

    But what do I know? I'm super picky or this sort of stuff.

    If you HAVE to pick between these two, I vote for Wood.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Both are ok fixtures but I'm thinking you could shop around more to find fixtures with my appeal. Of course, I'm not having much luck this morning finding something to suggest.

    leannehouse thanked Norwood Architects
  • 6 years ago

    I'd also choose metal over wood for ease of cleaning. I no longer want anything textured in a light fixture, especially in a kitchen. (And I now make sure replacing bulbs is easy!) I'm not super fond of these two fixtures for your particular kitchen and I think it's mainly because of the shapes. Perhaps consider something not overly round (most of the elements in your kitchen are rectilinear) and in a colour that bridges all your elements. Matte white, black or charcoal makes sense to me. I think a glossy metallic pendant might catch the eye too much and detract from the space. I'm not a pro though and this is my impression from your pictures on my screen with your mockups.

    This is the type of shape I'd consider in your kitchen:

    Curved yet reads as linear. From Globe on Amazon.


    A conical shape might work as well:


    Sea gull Lighting on Build


    Found these pendants in this post articles on pendants under $100. I didn't check their sizes so they might not work for your installation. Shared them simply to share the idea of pendant shape. Good luck with your decision.


    leannehouse thanked tartanmeup
  • 6 years ago

    Keep in mind with solid black, you're going to be dealing with a lot of dust showing. This is the reason we decided against using black pendants in our business, because we didn't want to increase our labor costs to have them cleaned everyday. (My designer knows to only use black on smooth, flat surfaces that can be quickly cleaned to reduce costs.) But, if you're one of those people who enjoys cleaning, I think the black pendants are nice. I still think clear with a black frame to pick up the black in the oven and stove is how I would go.


  • 6 years ago

    @Norwood Architects LOL. Hey, at least people are reading what you wrote! I can't even get 1 reply to my request for advice yesterday.

  • 6 years ago

    Very good point about dust showing on black surfaces, Ja Doe.

  • 6 years ago

    Yes, black shows dust, but so does everything else. I have brass pendants above my island and they require a cleaning every couple of weeks. I'd rather see the dust as a reminder it needs to be wiped than for the dust to blend in and not get cleaned.

  • 6 years ago

    Hi @megs1030 Actually everything doesn't show dust. This is why I pay my designers tens of 1000s to find color and surfaces to help reduce the appearance of dust in my businesses. As I tell them, "You're entire raison d'être for me hiring you is to find me stylish furniture, surfaces, etc., that reduces my labor costs."

    Yes, everything has to be cleaned on a regular basis, but those solid black pendant in a kitchen setting are going to need to be cleaned a lot more than every few weeks. Especially the "curved" one which dust will settle on like crazy. Those will be need to be cleaned every few days.

    Just "my" 2 cents (that I paid a LOT of money for ;-)

    leannehouse thanked Ja Doe