Probably not what you want to hear but neither door would work with your traditional home and landscaping (which are lovely, by the way).

Thank you for being honest. I wonder if there is any way to replace my door with something more modern

What about a fabulous light fixture instead and cutting back the large tree? Both would brighten your entryway.

I was looking for a way to modernized the entry. I guess it is not duable.

If you are intent on switching to a door that is more modern than the traditional style of the home, I would suggest going with your second option in the same color as the shutters since the window size and shape better complement the panes in the front window.

The ones you have chosen are too contemporary. Have you looked at iron doors- it’s a classic material but can look really fresh especially on traditional architecture. I just pulled these off Instagram...

Thank you, I really like the first one. I will take at look at the ones you suggested