Software
Houzz Logo Print
marianna17

solar shade color for black window frames?

6 years ago

I am renovating my contemporary house. Wall colors will be varying shades of white. Windows are black frames interior and exterior with drywall return. I am looking for roller/solar shades primarily to block sun, privacy is not really a concern. I am wondering if I should go with more of a black shade color to match the black window trim, or a lighter color that would complement the wall paint color (which will be some shade of white). For the most part, the shades will be up, which is why I wanted to go with roller shades. When they are down, they would primarily be down to block out some sunlight.

Comments (39)

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Black to match the trim

    marianna17 thanked Home Interiors with Ease
  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Which do you think looks better?




    marianna17 thanked Design Interior South
  • PRO
    6 years ago

    The black looks amazing! Nice photos

  • 5 years ago

    Hi Marianna17! Which shade did you go with? I’m having same dilemma!

    marianna17 thanked Terri Jackson
  • 5 years ago

    Hi there! Which did you go with ~black or white?

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Hi Terri, I wound up going with "Miami" 5% black solar shade from Blinds To Go. It was between that and an identical fabric shade from 3 Day Blinds. The 3 Day Blinds version was about $2k more and I just couldn't justify it when I know the fabric is the same. I still would pick what I got, but I think the 3 Day Blinds version would probably have a nicer finish. The issue with the 3 Day Blinds one is these are black shades. the top valance is black, and the shade is black, but the bottom piece that holds the blind at the bottom is white. It's covered with the black fabric, BUT a tiny piece of white shows on the end. And when the blind is down, the other side (closer to the window) is white which I think is ridiculous. So if you are looking in from outside, you see this white bar at the bottom. This is the difference when you don't pay as much. I've lived in my house 16 years and probably put the shades down 3 times so I am not stressing about it, but I suspect the 3 Day Blinds version would have been all black at the bottom. I will post some pictures.

  • 5 years ago



  • 5 years ago



  • 5 years ago

    Oh wow! I’m thinking black as well. They won’t be down much in the back of house except in morning. We live in a lake and don’t want to hide the view. At first I was trying to find a company that does a white shade with black header/cassette do that when up, all you see is black header. But I bet you would still see white. I know that probably bugs you to see that white. I am so glad I saw this post. I think I’m going with black. Plus I think black would look better across front from outside too. I ordered 3 shades from blinds.com for garage (street facing) snd they look ridiculously white from street. 🤷🏻‍♀️. Great I can’t wAit to see pics. Thank you for sharing snd responding! ~ Terri Jackson

  • 5 years ago

    Looks great!!!

  • 5 years ago

    Did you use varying degrees of “openness”. 1%. 3% 5%?

  • 5 years ago

    Live on* not in. 😉

  • 5 years ago

    My windows were black frames so I definitely think in that case 100% go with black I think anything else would not blend in as seamlessly. If your window frames are not black you have more options. I am very happy with the black, most people cannot even tell there is a shade there when they are up the valance looks like part of the top of the window. The little bit of white on the edge at the bottom is annoying but it was the difference between $3800 for 14 windows or about $6000 for 12 windows and since 99.9% of the time they are not down, I didn't want to pay more. Also, keep in mind with these solar shades that if you have a window screen on your window, it will distort how the shade looks. It's not very noticeable and doesn't bother me, just something to keep in mind with solar shades that are see through.

  • 5 years ago

    Disregard I see that you used 5%. Thanks!!

  • 5 years ago

    Yes I picked 5% and I would recommend 5%. And I would do the same percentage for everything or at least everything within eyesight of each other because otherwise it's not going to look the same. I did some research and it seems like 5% was the most popular percentage of openness. I saw a 1% and 3% and wasn't crazy about it, and 10% seemed too sheer. Probably why 5% is the most popular go figure. It's a really nice look you can definitely see through and still see the view but it cuts down on the harshness of the sun and gives some privacy at night. And the fact that when the shades are up with a black window frame you can't even really tell anything is there is great.

  • 5 years ago

    If you have any lights on there will be no privacy element at nite...

  • 5 years ago

    @marianna17 they might be white on the side facing the window to reflect light, since black shades would otherwise absorb the heat. that's actually a great feature if the exterior facing look isn't a concern.

  • 5 years ago

    The actual shade material is black on both sides, interior and side that faces outside. For some reason, they did not wrap the strip at the bottom (the "bar") that holds the shade at the bottom with the fabric on the side that faces the exterior. I think this is a design flaw it should be black material. When you are outside the house, you see a white strip at the bottom. But this is the tradeoff for not paying more at a different company I suppose. I complained and after several months I was offered about $300 off my purchase price which I accepted.

  • 4 years ago

    Thank you for the awesome comments about figuring out what is best, white or black shades with dark frame windows. I am definitely going with charcoal 5% material.

  • 4 years ago

    Looks great and great discussion! Would you go with black shades for the bedrooms as well? I have the same setup and doing black in the living room and common areas, but the bedroom I’m unsure of; I feel like I should bring in some more warmth. Thoughts anyone? Thanks!

  • 4 years ago

    I decided to do this color all over the house, and we are so happy we did this color. It looks amazing!! I am glad I didn’t do black anywhere, because I wanted to look modern and clean look.

  • 4 years ago

    Thanks! Does it look ok against the black windows? What color is it?

  • 4 years ago

    … color name and mfr?

  • 4 years ago

    Blinds.com
    Best price, and I did in the most common areas with a remote control, and I love it!
    Mia was my lady, if that will help. Wait for labor day to get a better price

  • 4 years ago

    I did the black influence

  • 4 years ago

    Amalia, are you able to see, somewhat, the view ouside with the "black influence" blinds?

  • last year

    Hi, I am considering getting black solar shades 1%, did your plack shades make the room look dark? I face south and get a lot of light, but I don’t want to feel like I am in a cave.

  • last year

    I wound up doing 5% solar shades, there is a picture of what they look like at hte top of this post. They are pretty sheer, my windows also face south and it is not dark at all you can see through them and they still let light in and I can see the outline shape of what is outside.

  • last year

    I ended up choosing the one that matches the wall… while the black look great during the day, the lighter color reflects the light better at night with the lights on vs seeing large dark squares in the wall. If you have large windows , I would recommend staying with lighter color

  • last year

    Thank you! I have a light color now and it gets so bright I have to turn away from my windows—the effect is like looking at a light box. And thank you Marianne, it is great to hear that you feel like you get enough light.

  • last year

    Your interior lights must be very bright

  • last year

    It’s all the sun. I don’t have any trees or buildings blocking the light. It’s especially bad this time of year because the sun is low in the sky.





    The photo is not as bright as real life. Anyway, there are definitely worse problems than too much light.😂

  • last year

    I chose the brown influence many years ago…because the material looks more natural than the plastic…never regretted the choice

  • last year

    Also offers a nice sun/heat deterrent …as we have literally a wall of windows across the front of our home

  • last year

    You can ..however …still see thru them dimly…from inside …when closed….since we have beautiful mountain/forest views we love being able to enjoy them thru the shades …when they are closed

  • last year

    In your case some pretty curtains could add an extra layer of shade …to be closed as needed

  • last year

    Thanks for the info and suggestions. I would love to have curtains, but I can’t hang anything from the ceiling due to asbestos.

  • last year

    What deters you from hanging curtains from the walls?