Software
Houzz Logo Print
jolly_lin

Need advice and feedback for new kitchen layout

6 years ago

I have been on Houzz for a while but this is my first posting. I have been playing around with a couple of layout variations for my kitchen remodel and have a tough time deciding. I hope to get some perspectives for the helpful people of Houzz.


My kitchen is long and narrow, 9.5 ft x 19 ft. The current layout is a U with sink and dishwasher in the peninsula; cooktop at the end of the U; frig, oven, and pantry centered on the long leg of the U. There is just enough space on the west end for an eat-in nook. I'm the main cook in the family. In the current layout, I end up doing most of the cooking and prepping cramped in the corner between the sink and stove. This is not a kitchen for multiple cooks. I'm thinking of changing the peninsula to an island and move the sink to the perimeter. The island should give me more uninterrupted prep space and allow others to help me in the kitchen at the same time. It also seems to be a better flow.


One of my struggles is whether to keep a separate dining table or do seating at the island. We are a family of 4. This is our main eating and activity area. We have a separate dining room on the other side of the kitchen wall for entertaining. What I like about the current dining table is be able to have face to face conversations at daily family meals. What I don't like is it's a tight area and have difficulty to access cabinets and storage in that area of the kitchen. Island seating seems to be a more efficient use of space but sitting side by side is just not our style. I love to hear if there are any other ideas to better fit 4 ppl seating in the space.


Current kitchen








New Layout #1: separate dining table




New Layout #2: seating at the island




Comments (11)

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Question? Can the stove be moved?? Personally I think I would try putting all the tall stuff over there and have a nice big run of cabinets and counters for the rest. I also like the island.

    Have you seen a 3d perspective of thee plans?? Looking at a floor plan doesn't give you the best "feel" of the space...

  • 6 years ago

    I don't think you have space for the table and the island. Have you thought about a corner banquet? The bench seats could also be used for storage:

  • 6 years ago

    Yes, the gas stove can be moved if needed. I want to minimize moving things due to budget. At the current position, I can see people coming and going which I like.


    I don't have a 3D perspective of plans. Will take some time, but I think I can create the 2 new layouts in Ikea Planner.

  • 6 years ago

    Here is Debbi Washburn's idea. I like it, except that the DW would then be in the primary prep space between the sink and range. If the plumbing could be moved, the sink and range could be switched.


  • 6 years ago

    I would do the bigger island with the seating but I suggest putting the sink in the island either way.

  • 6 years ago

    @mama goose, I thought about a banquet. Not sure it will fit. That corner space is only 3 ft 6 in. The window is low, only 20” off the ground.

  • 6 years ago

    If the stove is moved, how would you place the island and seating?

    I know it’s common and popular to have sink in the island. I don’t think it’s for us. 1) Sink would chop up the counter. I need more uninterrupted space for prepping. 2) We use dish drying rack all the time. That don’t look nice on the island and is more tolerable on the perimeter.

  • 6 years ago

    Banquet bench would need to be only about 18" tall. How tall are the seats of your dining chairs?

    Island/seating issues aside, your last post gave me another idea--you could put the sink and DW on the short wall on the left. The wall would hide the dish mess, and the range would be in a more protected spot--no one would need to walk by it in the narrow aisle, to access the sink. DW would be outside the prep path, making it easier for helpers to unload it, or gather dishes to set the table, without interfering in your prep tasks.

  • 6 years ago

    @jolly_lin in our last house we had a sink on the perimeter with no window above it. I hated it and would not ever choose that option. I'd either want to look up and out into the open space or out a window while at the sink. In our renovation we moved the sink to the island. In our current house it is on the perimeter under a window and we have a large island with nothing but countertop. I do love having a big island for prep (and LOVE my sink under the window) but honestly I only use half of the island for prep so having a sink in it on one side wouldn't be an issue. It actually would be easier prepping next to a sink to just push all the scraps over into the sink (disposal) or garbage that would inevitably be next to the sink.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    The plumbing is moving off the peninsula anyway, so where you put it on the back wall doesn't necessarily matter... Looking at your existing space - I just dislike all those tall pieces in the middle of the run and breaking up the countertop.

    I strongly urge you to find a kd who can show you 3d. It really will give you a better sense of what you might like better plus you can view the space from all different angles..