Software
Houzz Logo Print
forever_now

What counts as "working" hours for electrician billing?

5 years ago

We recently had the master breaker box and switch to our old house replaced. It had been wired completely wrong with four 100amp or less wires going into a 200amp breaker, so of course none of them would ever trip it and one of the legs fried. Its only surprising it hadn't happened sooner, we'd never had trouble before, and I'm still surprised the house inspector when we bought didn't bring it to our attention, he did bring up other electrical stuff which we got fixed. I had a heck of a time finding an electrician that would even call me back. The one we got originally said it would take 2-4 hours depending on what they had to do to make the new box fit, we also asked them to rewire our AC which we suspected caused the problem (and it did turn out to be all wrong. This house has a lot of wiring issues and we've been correcting them as we find them).


They ended up being here all day, for both the main breaker box and the AC (which went quick). We just received the invoice and were billed for 8 hours of labor. The thing is they were only here from 9:15a-4:15p total. That is 7 hours. They also left for an hour and ten minutes at one point. I caught them leaving and they told me they hadn't bothered to come tell me they were leaving because "they were only going to be gone 10 minutes to get some wires." There was also at least an hour waiting for the inspector to come, in which they had lunch. Now I can see paying for the waiting time, they couldn't really go anywhere else during that time, but I'm less sure about that hour they were gone? A 10 minute supply run, sure, but an hour plus when they said 10 minutes? Also, should I be billed for 8 hours when even not counting the missing hour, but just when they got here to leave time it was 7hrs? On one hand, it was their whole day, they probably didn't go off to other jobs, but if I'm being billed hourly and not for a "day", then I would only pay for the hours they are here right? I need to call and talk to them and I just want to make sure that what I'm asking for is fair. I appreciate that they came out when no one else would even respond, but as it was I had to go a full week without water (we're on a well, pump doesn't work without electricity) until they had time to do the job. It was an expensive job and a $100 here or there adds up.


Appreciate any thought. TIA!

Comments (17)

  • 5 years ago

    Well, did they include a "trip charge" in the total bill? If so then they should only bill for the 7 hours.

    I'm betting their "10 min trip to get wire" was between 12 noon and 1.00pm. Convenient, given that most electrical supply houses close for an hour for lunch!

  • 5 years ago

    Did they say they would bill you only for their time on-site? Their day may have started earlier than their arrival at your home -- loading the vehicle with tools and supplies, stopping on the way to pick up materials, etc. If it was 2-3 hours I'd probably question the invoice, but for one hour I'd let it go. But that's just how I roll.

  • 5 years ago

    Einportlander, I was only told I'd be billed for the hours initially and no trip charge was Included on the invoice.


    Sktn77a, it was 10:40-11:50. When I talked to him I was told that it was because of my distance to the supply house. I know exactly which one they must have went to, its 15 minutes away (20 if there is "traffic" - its a small town.) So there was probably a slight amount of lolli-gagging/Snack getting but not enough for it to be worth arguing. (we have a Kirby's only 5 minutes away which is where I'd originally assumed they went.)


    I spoke with him and he took off $100 for the extra hour. So I was happy with that. I want to be fair, but I don't want to be overcharged either.

  • 5 years ago

    What was the total bill for the work? My experience with estimates for replacing a complete electrical panel is they will do it for a fixed price of about $1800-$2500. This price includes the permit, inspection, parts, etc. However, they may charge additional if they have to purchase more than a few new breakers (estimate usually has a number in it). The rewiring of your A/C would be a separate job, and may be charged by the hour instead of by the job (not sure).

    Bruce

  • 5 years ago

    If they have to be on site waiting for an inspector (unless it was there fault that he wasn't there), then they deserve to be paid. They're not being paid by the calorie, they're being paid by the time they have to be on your job and not working somewhere else.

  • 5 years ago

    You keep saying "they" - I assume that is a single person... ? Other times you say "him".

  • 5 years ago

    Dennisgli - I spoke with the electrician "him" who owns the company, he sent a crew of two "they" to do the actual job.


    Bruce, it was bid by the hour, I was told a range, it went over that range, but that's ok. I mainly wasn't wanting to pay for hours they weren't there since I want given a fixed price. I was ok with the supply run once he explained where they went, we have a place much closer so when they told me they'd be gone 10 minutes and were gone over an hour I questioned it.


    Its all good. We worked it out, he took off the extra hour so I was only billed for the 7 they were on the job, which includes the supply run and waiting for inspector.

  • 5 years ago

    Ah - that's why I asked - if two people worked for 7 hours and you were only billed for 8 hours of labor that sounds like a pretty reasonable charge to me.

  • 5 years ago

    Sounds like a 10 hour day x2. Or, a $2500 project.

  • 5 years ago

    It was a 7 hour day. I was charged for 8hrs x 2 (men). He reduced it to the 7 hours (x2).

  • 4 years ago

    People like this are the worst to work for. you need to remember youre paying us for more than the 7 hours were there. we have to go and get parts, we take lunch, which we are legally owed working an eight hour day.


    theres also usualy a $150 service charge fee just to go out there. if we work a full day for someone we will sometimes wave that too.

  • 4 years ago

    youre (sic)

    were (sic)

    "legally owed lunch"? lol

    Caps key broken?

    theres (sic)

    usualy (sic)

    wave (sic)


  • PRO
    4 years ago

    People like this are the worst to work for. you need to remember youre paying us for more than the 7 hours were there. we have to go and get parts, we take lunch, which we are legally owed working an eight hour day.

    theres also usualy a $150 service charge fee just to go out there. if we work a full day for someone we will sometimes wave that too.


    That's why time and material billing is a dino that is mostly extinct. It just creates something to argue about. Plus you get better at your craft and you make less? Or you get accused of riding the clock.


    It just doesn't work -- flat rate may get you less jobs, but then you're not spending time squabbling. You can focus more on your work. Just a suggestion, Dave. ;-)


    You will still come in contact with people who do not know the value of a buck and how far it currently goes, but don't let that stop you.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I work for a company. its not up to me personally.

    we do all T&M for service work. not sure what roxk you live under to call it extinct.

    No need to speak to me as though ive been doing this for a week.

    offering my opinion. last i checked this is an open forum with all opinions welcome.

  • 4 years ago

    The iPhone app works fine for READING this site, but I always go to my desktop to enter anything.

  • 4 years ago

    I agree reading is fine. trying to type is another story. its the worst forum for mobile. i dont use a desktop often.