Software
Houzz Logo Print
carnivore

Street tree under power lines

6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago

I'm in northern New Jersey, in the NYC metro area, zone 7. It's a residential street with single-family colonial style houses on lots about 30 ft. wide. There's a place for one tree on the strip of lawn between the sidewalk and the curb in front of our house. There are also utility poles along that strip supporting overhead power lines.


Originally we had a Bradford Pear tree which we really liked in spite of its bad reputation. It was a good size providing lots of shade and great curb appeal. The branches got up into the power lines but the lines ran safely through them and the power company didn't trim it. Unfortunately it came down in a storm.


We replaced it with a Sugar Tyme crabapple tree which was lovely but didn't last long enough to reach the power lines. It got a fungal infection and fell down from root rot. It was attractive, and the winter berries attracted feral monk parakeets which was fun, but it remained a little too small.


Any thoughts on what to try next? We'll dig out the crabapple roots and start over again in the same spot. I've thought about Japanese Tree Lilac, Trident Maple or Paperbark Maple but I'm wondering if they'd all grow too slowly and/or stay a little too small like the crabapple. I've also considered Cleveland Pear as a stronger alternative to the Bradford Pear we lost but I'm not sure if the shape looks as nice.




Comments (5)

  • 6 years ago

    As a former utility attorney, I have issues with the idea that electric lines can run safely through a tree. The only way this happens is if the line is insulated - most aren’t!!! - or if there is no way any part of the tree can ever touch an uninsulated, energized line. A large tree that can touch an uninsulated, energized line in a populated area next to a sidewalk is a safety hazard. The fact that the utility did not trim the previous tree doesn’t necessarily mean the line is insulated or that the old tree was 100% safe from electrocution hazard under all conditions/circumstances. Wood can transfer electricity to ground - it is not an insulator. Don’t touch or climb trees that are touching electric lines and don’t stand next or even close to them in the rain to keep from getting wet.

  • 6 years ago

    you should check your easement.. and see if you actually own that 2 foot wide strip ...


    and then check with the city and see if you are allowed to plant there ... and not just based on ... everyone else has done it ....


    ken

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Alright let me address these.


    1. It's very common to see power lines to run through tree branches in this region, and there are many large trees right on our street with lines through them. I want to go with something smaller because i think that's the sensible thing to do and I'd prefer not to end up with a 'V' cut into our tree years from now. But the utility company trims whatever trees are there on a regular basis as they deem necessary.


    2, The strip is on our property. Service lines have been marked out which is how we know where we can plant the tree.


    3. The town encourages tree planting on these strips and will even come plant one for us on request. However they won't guarantee what kind. "Whatever is in stock," is what they say. We see them plant a lot of Eastern Redbuds which aren't our favorite. I'd rather pay for one we like.


    4. There's no bylaw against planting a tree in that place, there's no height restriction and there's no list of "approved" trees given by the town that we need to choose from. However I'd like to choose one that's a good fit.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    One of my local universities (in Utah) has a great agriculture program, so I often like to reference information they provide when it comes to choosing plants.

    https://forestry.usu.edu/files/small-trees-planting-near-powerlines.pdf

    They state "Tree experts and utility companies suggest that people plant trees with a mature height of 25 feet or less near power lines, with taller trees kept farther away. "

    From that page, here are a couple that caught my eye. I haven't planted any of these, but their heights are listed well under 25ft.

    • Globe Norway Maple
    • California Redbud
    • Star Magnolia

    At least from what I'm reading, the Bradford Pear is expected to grow 30-50ft high which is too large to plant adjacent to power lines. I would not want to risk planting a tree where the lines would run through.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Some sort of small buckeye