Software
Houzz Logo Print
craftsman1412

Support Beams for New Bathroom

6 years ago

Hi Everyone, I'm hoping to gain any additional insight into our issue and what options we have if any.


We are trying to build a dormer in the attic for a second bathroom. The engineer said we'll need 10.5" beams to support the weight. The issue is our floor joists up there are only 5.5", so it'll protrude down into the main level by 5 inches. They go right across the two bedrooms on the main level, so we'd then have to lower the main level ceilings in the two bedrooms by 5". Current ceiling height is about 8'6", so it'll be 8' if we lower them. We are trying to avoid lowering the ceiling heights on the main level.


Engineer said LVL won't make a difference in size, and steel beams may save 2". Do you think there is anything else we can look into that would fit within the 5.5"? Does it require such large beams because it's a bathroom? We aren't going to have a bathtub - we opted for a walk in shower - will that matter? We already have one bedroom dormer up there that was original and it's on 5.5" beams. Or what about raising the attic floors? Obviously I'm not an engineer but just amazed we'll need such large beams.


Thanks for any advice!






Comments (19)

  • 6 years ago

    Move. You’re not willing to do or spend what it takes.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    So you hired a trained professional to give you an answer and you do not like the answer they gave you. Now you are asking total strangers that have no idea of the site conditions to give you free advice. Either challenge their calculation and come up with your own, or accept it and do what they recommend.

  • 6 years ago

    I don't understand the snarkiness. This forum is for sharing new ideas and getting feedback.

  • 6 years ago

    Those supports are needed because you've created bearing walls due to the gabled dormer. If you change to a shed dormer I believe you won't need the beams. What roof slope were you ending up with? Less than 4:12? You're going to need special attention to roofing material either way.

  • 6 years ago

    "Pros" with an attitude. Must get them lots of work.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Sometimes the engineering needs to drive the design.

    Instead of having your design engineered, ask the engineer and the designer to come up with a solution together.

  • 6 years ago

    Thank you Seabornman!! Maybe shed dormer roof is the answer! Didn’t even think about that.

  • 6 years ago

    There is nothing wrong with an 8’ ceiling.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    There is often a conspicuous gap between the math provided by an engineer and the application of that math in the real world. Engineers don't execute, general contractors do. Find a GC that's gotten this job past inspection previously please.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Make sure the GC's insurance is up to date.

  • 6 years ago

    Find a GC that's gotten this job past inspection previously please.

    Slipping a marginal job past overburdened and /or under trained inspectors. What a concept!

    (Maybe a few bottles of Chivas Regal or a more fungible appreciation, as well, to smooth the path.)

  • 6 years ago

    There is often a conspicuous gap between the math provided by an engineer and the application of that math in the real world. Engineers don't execute, general contractors do. Find a GC that's gotten this job past inspection previously please.


    Of course, that GC might cut down a supporting beam because "it wasn't holding up that much anyways."

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Are the proposed beams parallel with the floor joists or perpendicular.\?

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    The shed dormer Seabornman mentioned may be the solution. Still have a structural engineer take a look, or get a GC that is willing to take on the liability (wear a hardhat for the first year after completion).

  • 6 years ago

    A shed dormer would require a long ridge beam between the posts and would lower the pitch of the roof. If that works it would not need beams in the floor unless the original design was needed to reinforce the floor but that’s not clear. Need a section and details.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    There's a reason why states issue different licenses to different disciplines. Like it or not, where life safety is concerned, a structural PE's design expertise trumps anyone's "real world" experience.

    Is there a reason the new beams can't be placed in the wall vs. the floor system to avoid penetrating the ceiling below?

  • 6 years ago

    The mystery is how 2x6’s spanning 10’-9” could support the floor of the bathroom. Perhaps adding 5.5” LVLs at each joist would work but I’m not at my office computer so I can’t say for sure.
    Supporting the dormer without putting beams in the ceiling below is simple but requires a shed dormer and an LVL beam at the ridge supported by the same posts.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    With an existing gable dormer on the right side, I'm not sure the addition of a shed dormer would be the right look and feel for this home. We'd need to have a look at the existing elevations or a photo.

  • 6 years ago

    That’s true but I suspect the gable version isn’t going to look much different. Difficult to design with so little information.