Software
Houzz Logo Print
jaime_cathey

Need help with flooring dilemma

6 years ago

Help! My husband and I just purchased a home and discovered basically unblemished beautiful oak hardwood floors throughout basically the entire home. Except the dining room. The dining room had newer engineered hardwood laid down, and when we pulled it up we discovered a very ugly, outdated, and in-laid black tile, where the kitchen must have originally been. In the current kitchen, there is white ceramic tile with black grout. We are considering LVT in the dining room and kitchen as a contrast to the oak in the living room, but my dilemma is that the tile in the kitchen is currently about 1/2” higher than the dining room flooring. Can I put the same LVT down in both rooms with a threshold? Or will it look strange to have the same flooring at two different heights? Thanks in advance from a new homeowner!!

Comments (5)

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    ONE FLOOR as much as possible. There is no need for "contrast" , that's what paint is for. . Ditch the current kitchen and dining flooring to the sub floor, and to ONE as the rest of the home. The oak.

    A single floor visually enlarges and unifies space. Oak has been used in kitchen for centuries. If there is a reason this is not a good selection in your kitchen? Show us the kitchen : )

  • 6 years ago

    thanks for your input. We’ve already decided on what type of flooring we’ll use and it’ll be the LVT, I just need to know about laying it in two rooms side by side that are different heights. It would take too much time and $$ to remove the ceramic tile in the kitchen right now. So it either has to stay or be covered.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Since you did not want an opinion talk to your flooring installer since I agree with Jan and I actully have no visual that says what your particular issue is.

  • 6 years ago

    Sorry for the misunderstanding about this site. I thought this was a place people could come to ask questions and get feedback from experienced homeowners.

  • 6 years ago

    The cost of removing the tile will be (roughly) $2/sf. That's it. It takes an extra 1-3 days (that's MAYBE....a smaller space like a kitchen/dining room can be more like 1 - 1.5 days) to jack out the tile and clean up.


    An LVP needs FLAT and LEVEL for installation to be good enough to cover warranty. The cost to cover the grout with cementatious material = $1.50 - $2/sf. Sigh. Either way you are going to have to 'deal' with the tile.


    Personally I would jack out the tile (once it is gone it is gone FOREVER....if you leave it you will ALWAYS have to work around it...and 'work arounds' cost money).


    While some of our pros on here are a bit terse in their responses it is because they have answered this question (both on Houzz and in their professional lives) SOOO many times (how many times is that SJ?) that they could just spit! I'm one of them.


    I know it is tempting to leave things where they are, but if you HAVE to spend $2/sf on the tile (either to jack them out or to cover them in cement) you might as well get rid of them.


    Tiles traditionally sit 3/4" high. If you jack them out you will find the floor now sits about 1/4" (6mm) LOWER. And a good LVP will be (roughly) 6mm - 8mm in height. Tah Dah! Everything is level and you didn't even have to try!


    It is your house. It is your budget. I understand that $2/sf is still money out the door...but you will have to spend it EITHER WAY. Either you get rid of the tile = $2/sf or you COVER UP the grout lines = $1.50-$2/sf. One option ELIMINATES your floor height variance...the other ADDS to the floor height issues.


    It's your call.