Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_743415050

Countertop cutout template too large

6 years ago

Looking for some advice from countertop installers.

We recently installed a new kitchen. The countertop installers came to measure and picked up a sink cutout template from the sink box without measuring it. Turns out the template is too large and now the cutout in the countertop is as well. The sink is 16" by 18" and the cutout is 16-1/4" by 18-3/4".

The countertop installer is claiming it is not his fault as the template is wrong. The sink fabricator is saying that the template should always be checked and that it is common practice for the countertop installer to measure and take sink with them when doing cutouts.

What is the standard practice? Are we unreasonable to expect the countertop installers to fix the problem at their cost?


Comments (19)

  • 6 years ago

    They are both kind of right. This is typically where the GC would be involved coordinating the trades and being certain the right info is passed along. If you took the role of the GC this kind of becomes on you.

    HU-743415050 thanked millworkman
  • 6 years ago

    Thanks for the reply! We did have a GC who was there when the countertops were measured and the sink template picked up. He basically is saying it is no one's fault and sh&* happens. He is also saying that this has never happened before and he has used the same countertop installers in previous renos. However, the plumber and the kitchen cabinet installer are saying that it is extremely unusual that the actual sink was not measured.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I would push back on your GC. Tell him "Yeah, shlt happens, but I am not paying for it." Of course it is someone's fault. It is his job to oversee the job. Let him figure out who should eat the cost.

    HU-743415050 thanked anna_682
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Not that it would resolve the problem, but I wonder how the sink manufacturer would respond when informed that their template was inaccurate. Really poor quality control.

    HU-743415050 thanked flopsycat1
  • 6 years ago

    Oh their response is that template measurements must always be double checked and not taken as is. They claim it is standard practice to measure the sink against the template due to different installation options (ie- flush, positive, negative). Basically they are saying it is the installer's responsibility.

  • 6 years ago

    "He basically is saying it is no one's fault and sh&* happens."


    That's what he earns his money for honestly. Did he furnish the cabinets? Did he hire and pay the fabricator? Or did you purchase these yourself? If he made money on those items or charged you a fee to babysit those items it is on him.

  • 6 years ago

    Every time your GC gives you an excuse, repeat "Yeah, I want it fixed and I am not paying for it." I have done it and it works. Refuse to get into an argument or worse, an agreement as to who is at fault. Let him deal with it.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    I've never seen a counter installer even LOOK at the template, they always take the actual sink...

  • 6 years ago

    I have always sent the actual sink with the templaters. They're laser-measuring every bend in my walls, but I'm just hoping a cardboard sketch is close enough??

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    It is unfortunate that the GC isn't being more proactive. When I first read that it was 1/4" too wide I was going to say to move on but 3/4" front to back is ridiculous.


    Would there be an option of a larger sink? I wonder if the counter company would prefer to upgrade you to something larger versus buying a whole new top (obviously not disparaging the sink you have, but if brand X had one 3/4" larger...)



  • PRO
    6 years ago

    I am a fabricator. It is typical for the sink cutout template to provide a reveal. If the customer wants a custom cutout (smaller reveal or even an overhang) they need to ask for it. When we measure we always discuss the cutout details to avoid this exact issue as many customers don't know to ask. If it's anyones fault it would be whoever did the measure and did not discuss the cutout to sink relationship with the customer. The fabricator cannot be blamed for making the cutout to the size of the supplied template.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    "The sink is 16" by 18" and the cutout is 16-1/4" by 18-3/4"."


    oldryder:


    How is a 1/8" front and rear reveal and 3/8" side reveals on the same sink ever acceptable?

  • 6 years ago

    Thank you all for responses. Prior to this experience I was not even aware that a cutout template existed. We hired a GC because I did not want to be dealing with this, yet here we are.

    We were not present when the countertop was measured. The sink was in the kitchen when they measured. They never asked any questions. GC was communicating with them but they were poor at getting back to him and he asked for me to contact them too as the homeowner. Now he is pretty much out of the picture and I am dealing with the countertop place - which I did not want to do in the first place.

    Horrible experience all around.

    I am leaning towards withholding payment and getting someone else to properly install a countertop or asking them to fix it at their cost.

    I find it hard to stomach that we have to pay for another stone slab. There are no sinks that I could find that would fit the cutout hole of 16-1/4 x 18-3/4.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    HU:


    Recutting, profiling, and polishing a new sink cutout on site without mess is not a big deal. No new slab necessary. I do this all the time. They'll have to eat 8 hours and the cost of the sink, but I'll bet that's the lease expensive way to go.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    can you use a slightly larger sink? even if they had to make the hole larger, it would be ok.

    as for the GC, did he just walk off and leave you?

    As the homeowner, you aren't responsible for eating anything. it's either the GC, or the fabricator. The fabricator should have had your sink on hand to double check it against the template.

    the fabricator would pay you for the new sink. better than buying a new slab.


    I wouldn't pay anyone until this is resolved. where's the GC?

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    "How is a 1/8" front and rear reveal and 3/8" side reveals on the same sink ever acceptable?" I would not argue thats acceptable. My point was based on the original post one party did the measure and install and a different party did the fabricating. If the fabricator made the cutout to the supplied template he can hardly be blamed for the misfit when he didn't do the measure.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    It was the same person that did the measuring and the cutting and installing. The sink was in the kitchen when they came in to measure, they elected to not take the sink and only picked up the template from the box without checking.

    I will offer him the new sink solution, but I have a feeling he will expect me to pay for the sink. His attitude thus far has been that it is not his fault the template was incorrect and he is not at fault at all.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    It was the same person that did the measuring and the cutting and installing.

    they elected to not take the sink and only picked up the template from the box without checking.

    Well then there ya go. that's who is ultimately responsible. Tell them they need to fix it. either a new slab, or a new sink.

    (and I sure hope they haven't been paid yet)

    HU-743415050 thanked Beth H. :