Software
Houzz Logo Print
suej6542

Do you love or hate your white kitchen counters?

6 years ago

We're getting close to starting a kitchen reno, and I'm trying to make a final decision on countertops. One is almost all white and I'm not sure i'm going to like it showing every last crumb. So curious how others who have white counter feel after living with them for a while.


I have light hickory cabinets around the perimeter and will be adding a large island with white cabinets. Going for more of a modern farmhouse look.

I've narrowed down the counter choices to Cambria

Colton or Hanstone Aura. Figuring on a solid white tile back splash.


This is kind of the look I'm going for. Just not sure how I'll like white counters.



I love my white counters, I'd do it again!
I hate my white counters, never again!

Comments (26)

  • 6 years ago

    Thanks for the input. I really wasn't expecting that kind of answer. Nice to hear that your happy with them.

  • 6 years ago

    Yes I do. We just installed a Calcutta Gold in our Florida home. In the north I have Giallo granite.

    I like them both for different reasons. You can’t really see the crumbs etc on the Giallo. That is sometimes nice!

    With the white you see them quicker and it is easier to clean.

    Kitchen during reno.

    suej6542 thanked eld6161
  • 6 years ago

    In your case, I would go with the white to get close to your inspiration picture. Your other choice has too much gray in my opinion.

  • 6 years ago

    I still have white Formica counters that we installed in the early 90s when we got rid of our 70s avocado. I have never been disappointed, and when we redo our kitchen this winter, I will go for a white quartz. I raised 2 kids and worked full time, and the white never looked dirty. we also have white in our very busy lakefront summer home with no problems. I say go for it!

  • 6 years ago

    following. in my experience, if you have absolutely no pattern, then it shows every crumb and flaw no matter what color you choose. but I wonder if anyone who has the really subtle veining also has that problem, or if the subtle veins are enough to hide minor stuff?

  • 6 years ago

    Although my white Caesarstone has gotten a couple tiny stains over the years (only I would notice), I love being able to see crumbs and dirt and know that it’s time to clean. We rented a house this summer with a busy granite in the kitchen and I could never tell whether it was clean. I also love the clean look.

    suej6542 thanked Val B
  • 6 years ago

    ILoveMod, That exactly what I'm wondering. I really love both choices, and both work well with my wall color. I love the brightness of the white, but the movement of the grey. When I ask people's opinion, that see them in person they seems to be drawn more to the grey, (I think because of the movement) which is surprising me as well.

  • 6 years ago

    Connie Stackhouse wow! Thanks for the input!


  • 6 years ago

    Val B, I do worry about staining. My husband is notorious for not wiping up after himself. But I know what you mean about not seeing the dirt. In a previous house I had a busy pattern which hid everything. Sometimes great, but then when you looked in a certain light, it was OMG it's filthy!

  • 6 years ago

    We’ve had a few kitchens with pure white counters. Our current house has typical 1999 brown granite with lots of movement. I hate the brown and miss the white. We cook a lot and neither husband nor I are big “scrub down the kitchen after every meal” people. The end result is that I’m aware our current brown cabs have tons of dried on food and crumbs at any given time, but I can’t see them so I don’t know to clean it (and as said, I’m not doing a full counter scrub/wipe after every meal). Conversely, with white counters, you could see every drop of red pasta sauce and knew exactly where to wipe without having to do the whole thing. Super easy to keep it spotlessly clean.

  • 6 years ago

    H202, I'm definitely not a fan of the brown granites either. Thanks for the insight. Any issues with staining?

  • 6 years ago

    I’ve had caesarstone arctic white and Corian pure white (I think those were the names but I may be forgetting- but basically the whitest in either brand) and never had problems staining. I used soft scrub with bleach and everything came out. My mom has a creamy solid Corian in her house, and a pure white in her second home and both are twenty years old. The color is probably not as crisp as when first installed and i think has some minor staining. But nothing that would deter me from getting it again.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Really depends on individual clients needs and preferences.

  • 6 years ago

    A subtle pattern and a matte surface help hide minor dust or imperfections.

  • 6 years ago

    I have light quartzite counters at home and white quartz vin our vacation house. I feel like I can see crumbs a little better on light counters. Just be careful with staining on light natural stone, you're safer with quartz.

  • 6 years ago

    suej6542 that darker grey definitely will hide a lot, so if you like it, it's your easiest choice. personally, I prefer the lighter, subtler look and would gravitate to the sample on the left. it sounds like the light veining will hide imperfections at least a little bit.

    for the other readers who are wondering "why on earth would you want to hide crumbs, that's gross, just clean it...." perhaps you don't live with people who drift into the kitchen 20x a day to graze. people who half ass wipe the counter. I am totally happy to let a just a few crumbs rest until the big cleanup after dinner. until then, I want the counters to appear somewhat clean-- for my sanity.

  • 6 years ago

    For me, it's not about wanting to see small crumbs on the white surface so i can tidy them. It's about wanting to know where the massive caked on tomato sauce glob is, or the dried on egg yolk. With my current brown granite, I literally cannot see those things on a daily basis. The only way to find them is to wipe a cloth across the counter. Which gets back to my whole issue - that i don't want to have to wipe down the whole counter after every meal. I can live with some minor crumbs on my white or brown counters. I hate knowing there is major kitchen refuse though.

  • 6 years ago

    I have white counters (Corian Glacier White) and I love them. I never had white before, and I wondered if it would drive me nuts to be able to see every crumb, but I put it in because it was the look I wanted. I do wipe my counters multiple times a day (2 kids) but I don't mind it. I love the bright and clean look, and I like being able to see where there is a mess, like something sticky that didn't get cleaned properly. And with white Corian, I don't have to worry about staining. I did look at white quartz, but I was able to stain the caesarstone I had a sample of, so Corian made the most sense for me.

  • 6 years ago

    Since you have the stained wood cabinetry in there, and that white sample lower left in your first photo isn't entirely white - I think this would be a lovely idea for your kitchen. The combo you show is quite pleasing to my eye.

  • 6 years ago

    We have subtle veining on white counters. On the perimeter counters you can't really see crumbs/dust/etc. However, our island gets a great deal of direct sunlight, particularly in one corner. We can see everything in that corner. Due to the reflection of the light, I think we'd see imperfections even on a darker countertop, but I can't be sure.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    H202 yes, the high contrast countertops are bad for that! we have brown granite in our bath, and I seriously misplace hair ties all the time. I also don't see spilled powder, hair, or the random nail clipping that got away. it's bad enough that I think that granite is ugly, but this other stuff? gag.

    I can't wait to get rid of that monstrosity. I'll probably split the difference by choosing a light pattern where at I can see the really bad stuff that needs to be addressed.

  • 6 years ago

    Thank to everyone for all the input. At least now I'm not petrified of getting a white counter. ILoveMod & H202 We're completely on the same page. It's not about hiding the dirt, it's just about not feeling like I have to wipe it down every time I walk by. Maybe the white will get the Hubs to use a plate for his toast in the morning! lol Thanks again to all. Getting a price on the white tomorrow. If it's not a crazy amount more I think I'll go for it!

  • 5 years ago

    Sue - did you get the Colton? Are you happy with it?

    suej6542 thanked mariagrazia
  • 5 years ago

    mariagrazia, The reno just started today! I did not go with the Colton, but strictly due to $$$. As much as I liked it I just couldn't justify $3K more, when I like the other one as well. I was really shocked by the price difference. But I'm so excited to be underway! Just having the wall down make such a huge difference! Tape on the floor will be my island.




  • 5 years ago

    I know - the prices are crazy. Looks like you've got a great start - hope you love it!