Software
Houzz Logo Print
tkerri

Granite vs quartz countertops

6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago

Im debating on whether I should keep my current granite countertops or change to quartz. I really like the Misterio Pompeii quartz. I just wanted to refresh and update our kitchen. Any feedback or tips?


Comments (25)

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Lighter and brightr comes form lighting not counters so start by changing every light bulb to LED 4000K . Add some under cabinet lighting and IMO granite is a much better product than fake stone everytime. The kitchen could stand a redo but right now I would just do the lighting and keep the granite until you really want to upgrade the cabinets . Take as much as possible off the counters too.

    tkerri thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
  • PRO
    6 years ago

    I don't see that quartz color blending well with the existing floor and cabinet color. How much of an update do you want to invest in?

  • 6 years ago

    We’ll be changing our floors but waiting to decide if we will change our countertops. Trying to give the kitchen a more modern feel.

  • 6 years ago

    Glenda your kitchen looks beautiful! It’s like a completely different kitchen. Which quartzite did you use? I love quartzite but it’s a lot more expensive. I also love your floors. What type of flooring do you have?

  • 6 years ago

    Thank you! I will check on the name of the quartzite and the floor when I get home in a few days. It is more expensive and that’s part of why I encouraged you to think about what you really want permanently. I think your granite is nice and will be fine until you come up with your entire game plan. I had your same cabinet layout, similar tile, and granite in my last house. At first, I thought about changing my countertops too. When I started looking at it what bugged me the most was how my lower cabinet U shape made my kitchen look and feel smaller. I just had a small dining/eating area behind it which made it difficult to have more than two people sit at. You couldn’t really see it so either. I didn’t have an island and I love them. I ended up removing just the part of the lower cabinet that “chopped” the kitchen up and reusing the doors. Fortunately, I found a person who was not a big time cabinet maker willing to do the small job. He even cut the granite off the part I removed so I could reuse it. Yes it had a seam but that was miner in the big picture. I was also replacing my floors. I took out the tile myself! I painted all my cabinets myself too. I did it the right way and I will share that with you if you would like. A lot of sweat equity but gave me the money to do the rest. Send me a a picture of the other side of your kitchen and I’ll share my thoughts with you if you would like. Answering the questions I asked will help as well. Your kitchen reminds me so much of my last house and mine now. A few changes, some sweat equity if needed for the budget and I think you will be really happy. I did have a lot of light already which is key to light to a bright kitchen. Sorry I can give you the name today but I promise to get it for you within 2 days.

    tkerri thanked Glenda Miller-Clark
  • 6 years ago

    Thanks Glenda for the tips. I would love to see the kitchen at your last house. I guess I never thought about about changing the layout. It seems extensive. I figure changing the countertops and flooring would be easy fixes to update the kitchen. Here’s a pic of the other side of my kitchen.


  • 6 years ago

    I think your granite is nice. If you lighten up the floors. If your kitchen is not boxed in like mine, I really think changing the floor is the first thing I would do. It will bring out the white in your granite. Don’t get me wrong, I love my quartzite. Do you really not like it? I think I’ve even seen it in newly built homes. The house I have now had pink with little black specs and golden oak cabinets. Does your granite have mostly grey, white and black? If so, think about this...your granite and floor are “are” competing with each other. One is more yellowish/orange/beige and the other is not. Man, I feel like I am throwing you a curve ball. I wouldn’t have mentioned your floors if I didn’t remember you saying you were going to change them. Regarding the floor in my current house... It is engineered hardwood. But it’s high grade. Of course, I did a ton of research and talked extensively with local flooring experts. We have horses and the reality is my husband is not always going to take his boots off. With all the advancement in them, they are so durable. I don’t regret getting engineered hardwood one bit! Also, it blends well with my cabinets. I used it on my entire first floor. I don’t have high ceilings. I considered this in everything I did. I decided having one continuous flooring on the main level would also make it flow better and feel more open. I’m remodeling the exterior now so I’ve been on here and other sites a lot lately. If I’m not overwhelming you, I’ll send you some pictures of some kitchens I’ve seen while researching my exterior. Also, remember that I’m not an expert, pro or designer so I hope I’m not leading you down the wrong path. Yikes! Hope some of them give you advice too. If I’m not overwhelming you, let me know about the colors in your granite and I’ll send you some ideas.

  • 6 years ago

    I agree to just changing the floor. If I were to change anything else, it would be the pulls/knobs, but the current ones are okay in my eyes.

  • 6 years ago

    Changing pulls and knobs are an instant update. Great suggestion.

  • 6 years ago

    No replacement for the natural variation of real stone vs quartz. In our area, they are just about price parity right now. We went with granite. Your counters look amazing. As pp said, more lighting will brighten things up.

  • 6 years ago

    Thank you guys so much for the input! It’s helped me tremendously. So I’ll focus on the floors right now. Should I go with a light color floor or medium color. I’m assuming dark will close in my kitchen? What type of pulls/knobs would you guys recommend?

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    i was also going to mention floors, but see you've already agreed to it! (I actually like your granite)

    Agree about updating your lightbulbs and under counter lighting.

    The 12x12 tiles have to go. What other material are you considering?

    Can you show us what this tile butts up to?

    Do you have wood flooring elsewhere?

    Since your upper cabinets are so tall, I think doing a handle would look better proportioned than a knob. you could prob do a 6" handle and be good.

    Since you have knobs, drilling another hole in the doors to accommodate the handles won't be a big deal. just make sure you decide on the span of the handles. A 6" handle could have a 4" hole spread.

    You see how the handles look better on the doors? .




    (have you thought about doing a few glass inserts for the doors?)


    I'm also like the gold hardware. I think w/your cabinet color and your granite, it might be nice addition. you could always get a few to try them out and see how you like it.

    Or, maybe you want something like a black nickel? might look cool w/the granite




    BTW, Glenda, beautiful kitchen redo. love the island color w/the white cabs. Is that sea pearl quartzite or something else? hard to tell.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    @Glenda Miller-Clark Your kitchen looks beautiful! I know what you mean about posting and getting comments telling you how need to change everything and not even addressing the original question. Everyone is a critic I guess. Luckily some people are helpful. A handful of helpful responses keeps me coming back.

  • 6 years ago

    I agree that you should change the floors and then add undercabinet lighting. Your floor tile is very similar to mine. Your kitchen is very nice and just needs minor updates.

  • 6 years ago

    Thank you guys so much! Great feedback!

  • 6 years ago

    I looked at your pictures again. I love your granite! You’ve got some great suggestions from everyone. Keep the granite and do a few of the other things. It’s going to be beautiful.

  • 6 years ago

    And you don’t need to change the layout either! Go have fun!!

  • 6 years ago

    I think a new, gigantic, single-bowl, apron-front sink and kick-ass faucet would make you feel like you had an instantly updated kitchen!

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Sammy is correct and you don't have to pull your tops to undermount a gigantic, single bowl, kick-ass sink either.

  • 5 years ago

    Tkerri- I love your granite. Is it Bianco Antico?

  • 5 years ago

    Hi Kathy,

    I'm not sure of the exact name. I believe it’s Gold Star?

  • 5 years ago

    The big element which must be considered is the floor tile. Any new counter should coordinate somewhat with the flooring (your current counter goes well enough with the floor). Secondarily, any new counters should coordinate with the white cabinets. Your current counter goes well with your cabinets. IMO, you will not “refresh” your kitchen with quartz. If this was my kitchen, I would just change the floor tile and eliminate the beige.

  • 5 years ago

    Agree with others that the countertops aren’t bad and minor fixes like floor, hardware, and lighting would make a nice kitchen even better. But if you are looking to optimize function, some things to consider: change over cooktop microwave to a hood, change lowers from cabs to drawers, and re-examine work triangle. Best wishes on your project.

  • 5 years ago

    Hi Felixlady,

    We were considering luxary viny. What color tone do you think would wrk best? We don’t have high ceilings and our kitchen is kind of in a corner. So we’re thinking of a lighter oak color?