We used equal amounts of Ipswich Pine and Puritan Pine mixed together in equal amounts to get the color that looked best on on new wide board pine floors. I would urge you to get several colors and try them on samples of your exact scraps and see how they look in your light. Sunlight in Florida is different than sunlight in Kansas and the surrounding landscape will change your perception also. We are in heavy woods but our other house was filled with sunlight.