how about painting it black and do grey for the stonework

I'm with Particia Colwell Consulting - would remove the stone especially since you have a granite hearth. There are a whole lot of differing materials present in the photo - tile floors, wood floors, granite hearth, stone surround and wood mantle. I'd aim for simplifying as much as possible. Good luck!

OK so you did not ask if you should remove the stone....lol

I think try whitewashing stone first, see how you like it. I would paint the mantle white.

You may end up painting the stone as well but try the whitewash first

Lots going on, so it’s tough. I think the most important update would be to change the hearth if possible, then whitewash and decide on color of mantle last and also take into account your room‘s style

Awesome ideas. Thank you so much! Yes, there is lots going on, which is why I'm a bit stuck. So I really appreciate the comments.