Software
Houzz Logo Print
cbundy3740

Save or remove hardwood flooring?

6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago

Our living room in our 1970's ranch is 2 1/4 in. red oak. It's not in great shape, but it's never been refinished. (It's been mostly covered with a rug.) It opens up to the dining room/kitchen/hallway. We want to remove the vinyl in the other areas to make it all the same. We were going with glued down engineered hardwood but we didn't realize that would involve tearing out all the vinyl and red oak. (We were hoping to eliminate the mess and inconvenience of refinishing/matching, and the guy who measured said they could just install the flooring on top.) Now we're wondering if we should just refinish the red oak and install/match the rest of the flooring. Any insight? I HATE to ruin original floors for an inferior product, but I'm not sure I want solid hardwood in my kitchen. And I love the wider plank look. Is it more or less expensive to refinish and then match other rooms to the original flooring? How important is saving original floors? We're so confused.

Comments (18)

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    I'm all for saving original solid oak floors, and if yours are from the 1970s then they should last another 60 years. Mine are from the 1920s and still look great. It's amazing how beautiful they are when refinished. Here's a photo of them in the living room, refinished in 1983:


    IMG_1026.MOV · More Info

    And here's one of the transition from the dining room (above the saddle-1920s floor refinished in 2000) into the kitchen (below the saddle-2014 newly installed):


    Flooring · More Info

    The hardwood in the kitchen has worked out better than any other flooring I've had. Better than sheet vinyl or laminate, both of which were awful. Clean it with Bona hardwood cleaner and you're done. Refinish it when needed and it will look like new.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    @Diana Bier Interiors, LLC Thanks for your insight, Diana! Is your newly installed wood the same width as your old? (In the picture it looks like you maybe have some varied widths?) Is it a satin finish?

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    You're welcome! You are correct--the new floor is two widths--3" and 5" randomly laid. We live in the northeast with widely varying humidity so were advised not to go wider than 5". The finish is one coat special walnut stain, one coat high gloss poly, and top coat satin poly. My flooring guy said the high gloss is more durable, and doesn't affect the final coat of satin. Can't say how much I love this floor!

    cbundy3740 thanked Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
  • PRO
    6 years ago

    I am confused . Why not solid hardwood everywhere and the new and old can easily be made to match?

    cbundy3740 thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
  • 6 years ago

    @Patricia Colwell Consulting Originally we were hoping to save the mess/inconvenience of moving everything and being out of the home several days. But now we are thinking that's the best option since we will need to move everything out anyway. Are ALL old hardwoods worth saving? Ours has dark spots from water? (Christmas tree maybe?) It's always been covered with a rug so I really don't know it's condition. We would match it in with the rest.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Refinish your floors please. They are superior to the alternative.

    cbundy3740 thanked Joseph Corlett, LLC
  • 6 years ago

    Refinish what you have.

    cbundy3740 thanked cpartist
  • 6 years ago

    Refinish. The flooring refinished can tell you if those dark spots will come out with the sanding process. And, if they won't come completely out, they will be a whole lot less visible when there is a nice new finish on the floors.

    cbundy3740 thanked julieste
  • 6 years ago

    Your professional hardwood flooring installer can tell you the species (there are many different types of oak) and can match the cut, the plank width, the grade and the thickness. S/he can then lace in (if needed) the new wood, then sand/refinish all of it all at once.


    A typical hardwood floor finish lasts about 25-30 years and then it needs to be refinished. If yours are from the 70's, then they are roughly the same ages as I am (I'm 49). it means they should be closer to their SECOND sand/refinish then their first. Meaning? You are LUCKY to have wood floors that are almost 50 years old but are in their original shape/thickness.


    That means you have won the flooring lottery! You have a super cheap option for flooring! A full sand/refinish of an old hardwood is roughly $5-$6/sf. Now compare that to all the work that would have to be done to get in the $10/sf wide plank product you want.


    The tear out = $2-$3/sf. The install labour for a glue down wood = $3/sf. The cost of the glue = $2-$3/sf. Just the labour to get stuff out is HALF the price of a sand/refinish. I'm not kidding.

    cbundy3740 thanked SJ McCarthy
  • 6 years ago

    @SJ McCarthy Thanks for that cost comparison. I'm going to have a flooring installer come and give us a recommendation and quote this week!

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Another vote for refinish. When I moved into my home, the previous owners had first done a 1980s pickling on the oak floors (except they did it in the 2000s), and then trashed the floors with I guess running a tractor over it? Jk, but I have no idea how they got the floors to be in such sad shape. Anyway, the floors looked so bad that I had a flooring guy in to talk about replacement. But he took out a small sander, and sanded a little square to show me how nice the natural red oak was underneath. So we sanded, put 3 coats of finish on it, and it looks really great. I left the finish natural because it shows no dirt or wear and goes with everything so I have no dilemmas about choosing upholstery, rugs and wall paint that will go with the floors.

    As mentioned earlier, what you get today is not going to be as nice as the older wood you currently have. Even if the wood is just 20 years old, it will be nicer than what is available now, and if it is older than that, it's even nicer.

    I have engineered wood in my ground floor den because it is a bit below-grade and local Code does not allow wood below grade. You can see the inferiority mostly because the real hardwood is just one floor up, but you can also feel it when you walk on it. Having said that, the engineered wood is fine, but if you have real wood already in your home, keep it and refinish it.

    cbundy3740 thanked Shannon_WI
  • 6 years ago

    @Shannon_WI Thanks for commenting. Would you be willing to share a photo of the floors with the natural finish? I would definitely like a lighter shade which I know can be hard to achieve with red oak.

  • 6 years ago

    could you post a picture of these wood floors from the 70's? lets see what they look like.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    @Beth H. Just pulled up a corner off the carpet. Worth saving?


  • 6 years ago

    Here are my 1969 red oak 2 1/4 inch floors. In the WIP picture, on the right are the original floors, on the left, the new flooring that was added but not yet finished. . Below that is the photo of the finished product.

    I love them. You can make your floors look great, don't take out the hardwood.





    cbundy3740 thanked tozmo1
  • 6 years ago

    @Beth H. Wow, that's beautiful! I suppose we need to yank that carpet up and see what's under there! :)

  • 6 years ago

    @tozmo1 Your floors are absolutely gorgeous!