Software
Houzz Logo Print
detailaddict

Matching vs. contrasting window trim with casing/siding

6 years ago

This is perhaps a different issue from what most people face with this question...I am selecting exterior paint colors for our new build, and part of the problem is that I'm constrained (depending on how you look at it) by the window colors we've already selected. My husband wanted exterior-clad windows for ease of maintenance, and because of this we had to choose exterior sash and frame colors before we even knew what color(s) the house would be. The house will be a 2-story with different siding on the upper and lower levels, and I wanted to have a different paint color on each. To tie them together I decided to order neutral green sashes for both and terra cotta frames to coordinate with orange-spectrum paint on the upper level and dark brown frames to go with brown paint on the lower. I also chose (near-) neutral green roof shingles, so that the idea was to have a green roof, green roof rakes and pops of green in the windows and doors. I'd planned to paint the window trim accordingly, to go with the orange or brown window frames and siding, respectively (see the attached, slightly crooked coloring page). However someone with our architecture firm (who has a very good sense of color) is recommending that I paint all of the trim green. We've found a color that ties the roof and sash colors together nicely, but I'm concerned that too many color transitions around the windows will make the house look clownish.





In the second pic I've test-painted the right and center sections of trim green and the left orange. The green picks up the sash color and has a nice cooling effect on the warm orange tones, but on the other a simple green-to-orange transition from sash to frame to trim to siding looks "tidier", imo. In addition, as the upper windows are all bordered beneath by a sill datum that divides the two types of siding (also painted green in the pic), this will need to be painted the same color as the window trim, whether green or orange.




As for the lower level, we've selected a dark taupey brown (left of window in pic #3 and bottom left in #2) to contrast with the bright oranges and "ground" the overall color scheme. But if I don't use green on the window trim, I'll need to use this shade of brown for the trim and a lighter color on the siding to maintain a darker-to-lighter color sequence from frame to trim to siding - which won't provide the same contrast and grounding effect on the siding. So...should I go with my original, intended color scheme or follow the professional advice and do something maybe more daring with the window trim? And if I stick to my original scheme, how do I paint the lower level?

Comments (11)

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Hi, detailaddict,


    There's a big difference between the color of the window frame and the siding. I would go with the green for a little transition, plus, it ties in the color of the roof and fits in with the earthy tones in the rest of the design.


    - Ariana

    detailaddict thanked Brennan Enterprises
  • 6 years ago

    Hi folks...In researching how to paint windows I read that the casement/frame and sash needed to be different colors (for definition - a woman's eyeliner was the analogy used), and as I said I'd planned to paint the trim (i.e, the exterior siding around the window) the same color or a similar one to the frame (the box that the sash rests in). So my planned color scheme was tidier than it may appear from all the paint samples! Ariana's comments are similar to what my "consultant" has said, but I'm worried about the repeated contrasts from orange to green and back again - which is what makes this advice so mind-boggling for me. As for the orange colors, the trim wasn't supposed to "match" the frame per se, just "go". The terra cotta color of the frames is too intense (and this was the only shade of orange offered) to carry over the whole house on the siding, thus a dark orange outline around the sashes and then less intense colors going outward is the idea - and with the brown frames as well.

  • 6 years ago

    The frame should be the same color as the trim. I would absolutely not have he frame yet a third color. I would skip the orange on the board and batten and paint all of it the trim color. I’m hard pressed to think of any house that benefits from more than 3 colors: siding, trim and sash. Perhaps certain Victorian styles.

  • 6 years ago

    Perhaps we need some more clarification...the trim is the siding to be painted next to the window, but the color of the aluminum-clad frames cannot be changed, short of ordering new windows. As long as the overall scheme includes green, orange and brown we still have just 3 colors. If we were to forego the orange board and batten and paint it green(?) as nexp suggests, then the orange frames wouldn't match anything, and the upper level would be the same color as the roof (which as I understand is supposed to contrast the siding color). The question here is not whether to change up the entire color scheme, but whether to paint the window trim green or orange.

  • 5 years ago

    Your window frame and exterior sash colors should all be the same color. All window and door openings regarding of location should match in type and color. This is the crux of the problem which is a challenge to resolve since there seems to be two different color schemes dependent upon first or second story location of windows. It is a rather expensive problem to resolve. You either repaint all the exterior window frames and sashes ( and doors) for continuity or live with the original error. The consultant who did not steer the color selection more appropriately is at fault.

  • 5 years ago

    Aluminum clad can be repainted in the field. The finish will probably not be as good as factory applied. If you consider this action make sure you hire a professional painter who will do the necessary prep to ensure the paint does not delaminates earlier than expected. See what the window manufacturer recommends for repainting of the cladding. You might consider a matte paint so that imperfections of field applied paint is not as noticeable. Best wishes.

  • 5 years ago

    I decided to go with green trim for everything - the roof rakes, window trim, door trim, doors and horizontal datum between the upper and lower sidings. I suppose I could change it later on if it ends up looking ridiculous but at least I will have followed the advice of 3 architects. The one who designed the house was excited when I told him I was using different colors for the upper and lower frames, as he'd always wanted to try this (and in her defense my color consultant was not brought in until later). In retrospect I might have switched the frame and sash colors as the frames and trim would both have been green, but I don't think I would have wanted orange sashes on the upper level. But from what I've read the frame and sash need to be different colors in order to make the windows pop (https://www.oldhouseguy.com/painting-windows/). I would post a pic of the new color scheme but it's a .pdf and won't upload (and I can't seem to convert it).

  • 5 years ago

    The original architect is at fault as they should not attempt new design concepts on Aluminum-clad frames that are powdered-coated paint application. The other two architects are attempting to appease and make the best of the situation. Eventually you will normalize to the color scheme and not see it.

  • 5 years ago

    Your house is not old nor a reproduction of that era. Again the architect was not savvy as to how to manage owners expectations.

  • 5 years ago

    Again to be clear, I was the one who made the window and color scheme selections early-on as I had to choose a whole-house scheme in order to settle on frame/sash colors so that we could order windows. The "third" architect was/is an assistant to the one who designed our house and was my primary consultant in finalizing the siding and trim colors (and hence the original dilemma and possible rescue of the color scheme). I had no expectations of this house looking historic and would have considered a structure of this size and simple architecture to be boring and monolithic were it all the same color. Perhaps I should have asked for help at an earlier point than I did but I do not transfer "blame" (if the word even applies) to anyone else for however the color scheme turns out. If nothing else I can always return to my original plan of having different trim colors on the upper and lower levels, which I didn't think looked that bad. Here is a screenshot I was able to save of the front elevation with all-green trim: