Software
Houzz Logo Print
bpath

Inlay gutters.

5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago

I didn’t want to hijack a current thread on gutters, but I wanted to ask the pros’ and homeowners’ opinions on inlay gutters. What are the pros, the cons, etc. on efficiency and maintenance? I love the look, or shall I say, the non-look because the gutters are essentially unseen. And what about the downspouts, coming behind the fascia?

I’m not building, but facing a maintenance issue on a property.

Comments (16)

  • 5 years ago

    Thanks, Mark. That looks like it.

  • PRO
    bpath thanked Joseph Corlett, LLC
  • 5 years ago

    Thanks, Joseph, you posted those on the other thread and they really look cool. But, the inlay gutters are already on the house that I am talking about, and I’m not planning on changing them. I wonder what anyone who knows about them has to say, to see whether I need an attitude adjustment.

  • 5 years ago

    @bpath our gutters are in the fascia. The house is 1910 and that’s where they have always been. We just finished our restoration and left all the original guttering in place inside the fascia because my contractor and my metal roofing guy who has 50 + yrs experience said it and the fascia were in perfect condition. No rot anywhere. If you expand the first pic you can see the edge of the snow guard on the front porch roof. It’s a few inches back from the edge and the rain from behind it runs toward the downspouts. We have replaced the gutters that aren’t in the fascia further back on the sides of the house with 1/2 round and it all drains into buried pipe and flows way away from the house. If you need more pics can do tomorrow.



    1/2 round not installed yet at rear of house but you can see fascia gutter

    bpath thanked User
  • 5 years ago

    Thanks, Trailrunner! I’m glad to hear you are happy with them. Does it freeze where you are? The seams have not split, or other breaks occured, that might allow water into the fascia below the gutter? What are your gutters made of?

  • 5 years ago

    My previous house had gutters similar to those shown. Beautiful look because the pitch is only in the liner and hidden from view. Very difficult to fix leaks decades down the line when the copper is worn through in spots. I imagine they would be enormously expensive to install, even if done in aluminum rather than copper.

    bpath thanked Lyndee Lee
  • 5 years ago

    There hasn't ever been a leak and we do get severe cold here in Lexington VA. We will get snow Wed and sleet and then low 20's for several days. Then it will go back into the 40's. My roofing guy ran a large amount of water through all the original hidden gutter to make sure it was intact. It isn't copper. All galvanized steel.


    My contractor says that every winter at some point someone calls him with an ice dam. This house so far hasn't had that problem as I said the fascia when they removed all the old siding was in amazing condition and only needed sanding and priming and painting.


    The original gutters are/were galvanized steel. The exposed g,s, gutters and downspouts had splits in them and were rusty. They have all been replaced. The g.s. inside the fascia are still perfect and we left them alone. All of the new downspouts and the new exposed 1/2 round on the back of the house and the porch addition is aluminum. It looks beautiful. Everything goes so well with the style of the house. The original crown mold is now restored and exposed and looks so beautiful.


    I guess time will tell if we get an ice dam ! I sure hope not .

    bpath thanked User
  • 5 years ago

    Thanks, Trailrunner. The ones I’m dealing with are copper, beautiful. We’ve been soldering some seams (well, having it done). Waiting for another good rain, but no freeze, to see how things go.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Good maintenance makes stuff last. We are trying to install products that minimize as most people won't do maintenance until damage occurs.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Exactly, Jeffrey. Good maintenance is key. That’s what I’m trying to do. What is your experience with or opinion of inlay/built-in gutters In general?

  • 5 years ago

    My view is that all gutters eventually develop a leak somewhere. With inlay gutters this may not be apparent for quite a while until there is considerable damage to the structure. My previous house had some gutters that were essentially hidden like this, and I ended up spending quite a bit of time and money rebuilding a wall where a slight bit of regular leakage was occurring and had turned the 2X6's into mush. The only thing holding up the wall was the siding. If you are opting for this kind of gutter, you have to be up on a ladder regularly monitoring for leaks and overflows. After my experience I decided that the gain in aesthetics was not worth the pain of having to rebuild part of my house.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    All gutters should be cleaned and checked for leaks at least annually.


    Looking at the detail, I realized my father built an inlay gutter into our new ranch styled home circa 1976. It definitely was an upscale detail. 4/12 pitched wood shake and the gutters followed the pitch while capping over an oversized facia. The front edge, like the details shown by @Mark Bischak, Architect are lower than the edge meeting the roof, acting as a secondary overflow when the downspout holes (with chains) were overwhelmed or clogged. The home was surrounded by Oak trees and the shape allowed the wind to do most of the gutter cleaning work. Occasionally there were leaks that had to be repaired, mostly due to long runs and seams that weren't designed to be flexible. Saw similar gutter design on MCM homes they built in the 60s with very low pitched roofs. We just restored a 1950 flat top home with the inlay gutters built into a TPO (thermoplastic) roof. Lots of rot at long neglected edges and downspout areas.


    Once you start concealing downspouts, it may be time for a plumber instead of "Mr. downspout."

  • 5 years ago

    Thank you, kudzu. These gutters are are the end of deep eaves, 4’ in a couple of places, so I’m pretty sure walls wouldn’t be affected by any leaks, but of course the would around the eaves themselves should be watched.

    Jeffrey, some years ago I visited a neighbor’s home, he had been a student of FLW and designed his own house. The gutters were somehow integrated with the roof, absolutely gorgeous, and the downspouts were art. I wish I’d asked more about them.

  • 5 years ago

    It would be helpful to see a photo of the real gutter. What is the question you had about them?

  • 5 years ago

    RES, I’m overseeing maintenance on a property before it goes on the market, and I don’t know much about Inlay gutters, so I just want to understand a little more. I‘m not sure if I should appreciate them and the gutter maintenance guy, or if I should roll my eyes at the gutters (but not at the gutter guy!)

    I think it’s a beautiful look, that’s for sure. (And unlike on the other thread, they definitely have to be taken into account when the structure is being designed.)