Software
Houzz Logo Print
sburns1217

What to do with fireplace?

5 years ago

Hello everyone! I'm anxious for any and all opinions. I'm redoing the main level of our tri-level home built in 1958. The wall to the left is coming down and it will be an open concept space from the front door - living room, dining room and kitchen. We are doing flat front wood cabinets, earthy green vintage square backsplash, culcutta gold quartz countertop and gold finishes. We are also painting our island green (potentially juniper green by BM).


I have a camel colored soft leather couch for the family room, and lots of plants. Midcentury table with wood chairs and two green accent chairs. My overall feel borders somewhere between bohemian and MCM. More bohemian/earthy while trying to do the age of the house justice.




I think I've decided on BM soft chamois for the paint color in this entire space. My question is what to do with the (already painted, sigh) white fireplace? It's giving me a country feel I don't love, and it's so stark. I would've loved to have it white washed or not painted at all, however this is what I've got. Do I do a matte version of soft chamois on it? Something different all together? I really value any ideas people have. I attached a picture of my soon to be kitchen too just to give you an idea of what the rest of the space will look like.

Comments (15)

  • 5 years ago

    I should say, the kitchen demo is happening in the next week, which is why the space is so empty. I'm currently shopping for rugs and furniture also

  • 5 years ago

    Beautiful tile. Your ideas sound really good and I think your house will look great.

  • 5 years ago

    Maybe remove some of the paint on the fireplace for a more whitewashed look and add a wood mantle.

  • 5 years ago

    I would love the fireplace to have a more whitewashed look, and I have debated doing just that. However, I spent weeks taking paint off the brick wall in my sunroom and I don’t know if I can do it again. It turned out beautifully but the mess and the chemicals 😫

  • 5 years ago

    My sunroom wall, beautiful but can I do that again?

  • 5 years ago

    @Shannon Burns, Your brick wall is beautiful! Can you give any details on what type of paint you had to remove, and the method and products you used?

  • 5 years ago

    I’m not sure of the type of paint, but I’m pretty sure there were two layers involved. I tried heating and scraping and that didn’t work, at all. Then I tried using soy gel and a wire brush and that didn’t work. The best process (the best of the worst) was putting soy gel on the wall in sections and then covering the sections with plastic wrap. Let it sit for 12+ hours. Then I would take it off a section at a time, and scrape it off with a scraper. I think I did that 3 times. Then after it dried I went over it with a wire bristle brush to get any clump off. It was really pretty horrible. But I love the wall so much I would do it all over again 🤦‍♀️

  • 5 years ago

    That sounds like a huge project but if you love your wall so much it may be worth it. You have great style. Do you mind sharing the name of your backsplash tile?

  • 5 years ago

    I love the wall, and it just might be worth all the time it will take to do the fireplace too. I dislike when people paint a solid color, like that, they look almost like plastic.

  • 5 years ago

    That’s exactly my thought, it’s so thick and glossy it looks plastic. That’s why I’m wondering about maybe toning it down if I can’t stomach the chemicals and mess again that stripping it would entail. If I’m painting BM soft chamois in flat, maybe painting the fireplace in Swiss coffee in matte would help just tone it down?

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Soy Gel is a paint stripper made from soybeans. no harsh chemicals. no odor. i've used it on tons of projects. the best part? it cleans up w/water. after letting it sit, remove w/a pail of water and a scrubby brush should tone down the gloss and remove a lot of the paint.

    look into Romabio if you want a lime washed look

  • 5 years ago

    You have AWESOME STYLE. love love love what you’ve done so far. You totally answered your own question. You said you love the brick wall and would do it all over again. So go for it. The FP will look soooo much better with some of that thick plastic looking paint off.

  • 5 years ago

    I would pull the green from the kitchen




  • 5 years ago

    Thank you so much for the feedback and style comments. This house has been a lot of fun for me. I was wondering about pulling in some color....maybe I’ll look at some gray/greens and see what I think.
    I’ve used the soy gel before, and I’m sure it has to have chemicals to strip paint from brick. It also ate through my plastic gloves in about 3 minutes. 😳
    My other question on stripping the paint is in regards to the style of the fireplace. It’s got this super funky MCM black pole detail on the side that I love. If I distress the paint, will I be putting the styles up against each other?

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    honestly? i'd leave it. you can go over it w/matte paint if you want to decrease the sheen.

    I'd top it w/a piece of soapstone or black granite or black slate, and do a mantle like this


    leave the pole or paint it white. doesn't matter











    leave the brick, but maybe try something like this on either side


    want a total makeover? reface it like this one