Software
Houzz Logo Print
kayla_marie8769

Vent A Hood & 'equivalent' CFM

5 years ago

Vent A Hood markets their products with a CFM rating and an 'equivalent' CFM rating.


Based on my research, most hood vent manufacturers produce their CFM ratings by taking a measurement directly off of the blower unit. Apparently, Vent A Hood takes capacity measurements at the end of a 12' section of pipe. Their 'equivalent' rating is supposed to equate to the measurement number that would be produced if they took the rating directly off of the blower unit, like other manufacturers. (Whether or not this scenario is true, I can't say, but it's what I've seen based on my research.)


Some appliance stores have told me that I would be ok purchasing a Vent A Hood unit based on the equivalent CFM rating, and others have said that I should purchase based on their standard, listed CFM rating.


So, Vent A Hood owners, how did you make your purchase decision, and are you satisfied with it?

Comments (5)

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Equivalent CFM is mostly pure marketing. Instead of a baffle to remove grease from the air stream VAH do this with centrifugal force on their blower. This works somewhat well when the blower is new and perfectly clean. As soon as just a little bit of grease builds up on the blower the effectiveness drops dramatically.

    More: https://www.gardenweb.com/discussions/5161173/hood-faq

    Two things to keep in mind:

    1 - CFM's are actually not that important. Far more important is containment volume which is something that most consumer hoods lack (interestingly, VAH is one of the best). CFM's make for great mine is bigger than yours marketing material though.

    2 - Some energy auditors I know will always measure range hoods when they do an audit of a home. Something like 98% do not achieve any more than half the CFM's they are marketed as and most are closer to 30% of marketing fluff.

    VAH is one of the loudest exhaust hoods you can purchase and a key reason that people do use the hoods installed in their kitchens is noise.

    Commercial hoods often run at lower CFM's than consumer hoods (chef's don't care about marketing fluff but only how well something performs), are much quieter and more effective.

    More: https://www.houzz.com/discussions/5745986/commercial-range-hood-install

    If you want to support their marketing dept then buy VAH.

    If you want a reasonably good and inexpensive system then buy a Wolf or similar hood w/ a remote blower & silencer.

    If you want the quietest hood with the best effectiveness then buy a commercial hood from Accurex or similar.

    Whatever you buy do not neglect a proper make up air system.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    We have a Vent A Hood, going on 6 years. It is highly efficient at containing all effluents...and even on high, we can have a comfortable conversation at our nearby kitchen table. Because of its unique design, the CFM requirement is lower than other ventilation systems. We are more than satisfied with our selection. Click to enlarge.


  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    All blowers behave in a similar manner to the illustration below. As back pressure (or for that matter front negative pressure) increases, the flow rate drops. The goal with a given hood configuration is to choose a blower that at the pressure loss of going from outside into the house, plus past the hood baffles, if any, plus the ducting, back to the outside, the point on the curve where that pressure loss intersects (horizontal line) provides the CFM that the capture and containment function of that particular hood needs.



    Typical actual fan curve



    With this in mind, it is possible to have a blower rated at 1200 CFM mounted in a hood system and have the actual flow rate be only 2/3rds of that, i.e., 800 CFM. Because (as noted above) VaH use a different grease particle collection system, they try to compete by using a value that makes up for the (not necessarily what they assume) pressure loss of the baffles and hood transitions of an conventional hood.

    What is missing from the VaH claims, but now somewhat available on their web site, is the flow rate vs. the additional pressure loss. What are these missing factors? In the VaH case, these are the pressure loss of the make-up air system and the pressure loss of whatever ducting VaH didn't count. Of particular note is that the VaH fan curves are flatter at the higher pressure-loss region, making them less suitable in cases where either the ducting is long, angled, or the MUA is restrictive. The CFM can be rapidly degraded in that region.

    But all this is secondary to determining the actual required flow rate from first principles. In the case of residential hoods with low volume below the baffles, the flow rate needed is that which assures containment by the baffles of the cooking plumes that have entered the hood. I suggest 90 CFM per square foot of entry aperture. Commercial hoods can stand less when some plume averaging is achieved in the hood reservoir below the baffles, depending on what is being cooked.

    So the suggested approach is to take the value 90, multiply by the hood entry aperture (which should overlap the cooking zones) to find required CFM. Then multiply by 1.5 to account for all the pressure losses that are not known. Then select a blower that has that rated CFM. Note that rated CFM is measured in free air and is called the zero static pressure flow rate.

    P.S. If VaH is your cup of tea, be sure that it is being operated under the conditions for which it is specified. That includes perfect (no pressure loss) MUA.

  • 5 years ago

    “VAH is one of the loudest exhaust hoods you can purchase and a key reason that people do use the hoods installed in their kitchens is noise.”

    I do not agree. I think it’s About average as what you‘d find in most hoods.

    Setting aside the good advice in the posts above, the pivotal point to me about the VAH is that they are much harder to clean than baffle-filter exhaust hoods. You have several parts to a VAH hood that need to be taken down and cleaned separately. First there is the blower shield. Second to come off is the blower housing, which is a rectangular box with lots of sharp edges. Then there is the blower wheel which can only be detached with a hex wrench - and don’t listen to the salesperson who says you won’t need to detach the wheel to clean it. You will. Then after cleaning you need to put that all back. This is as opposed to a baffle filter hood where you just take the baffle filter panels out, put them in the dishwasher and pop them back on, done.

  • 5 years ago

    Measured w/ a meter it is indeed one of the loudest.

Sponsored
Trish Takacs Design
Average rating: 4.9 out of 5 stars36 Reviews
Award Winning & Highly Skilled Kitchen & Bath Designer in Columbus