I'd keep looking as neither really compliment each other. And not knowing where your navy comes into play, an all black fixture may not be the way to go. Bringing in brass light fixtures will marry well with the hardware.

Not knowing size you need but came across these 2. Boho and modern.

For island

Metal Pendant Lamp w/ Gold Finish – BURKE DECOR · More Info

for sink

Trade Winds Lisa Metal Pendant Light in Natural Brass - LightsOnline.com · More Info

Like the smooth black w texture of wickeR. Good contrast yet they harmonize. Can one be picked in a much smaller size?

what about some of these combos... (you can see the black industrial pendant over the sink)

I love this one

or this woven pendant w/these chairs

maybe one of these over the sink

I'm assuming you have a good task lighting plan already.

@herbflavor No, no smaller. Black diameter: 7 inches.

Basket dimensions: Depth:16"
Width: 16"
Height: 8"

@Beth H. :Thanks for finding the example photo of the wicker with the industrial!! I'll take a look at some more of these, thanks so much

@dan1888 Yep, recessed lighting throughout the kitchen.