Software
Houzz Logo Print
aspen75

Cabinet wood choice

5 years ago

Hi there,

I'm trying to pick wood type/color for my new kitchen. I, like many, love the look of a bright painted kitchen contrasted to the wood floor, BUT, we use our kitchen hard, and I want the wear of stained wood rather than someday-cracking/chipping paint. Also, wood is beautiful and paying more to paint over it with less longevity sways me toward going wood. I DO NOT want a dark den or the old fashioned wood kitchen look. I'm kind of in love with this look that keeps things modern with a farmhouse/rustic bent. Timeless, hopefully? Natural wood with white counters. What I wonder is if I switch the wood for a natural cherry tone, does that lose the look? Is the actual color of the wood important when trying to mimic this, or is white a neutral companion that would go with any natural wood?


Because I grew up in the era of the darker-stained, raised-panel plainsawn oak 80s kitchens, I am just hesitant about oak, even though the natural, quartersawn, shaker door shown above is obviously really different. I just love the grain and beauty of natural cherry, but am afraid the redness might change the look too much. Does cherry 'go' with white? When I see a picture like this, it is such a different look...



Of course, totally different lighting, styling, I know. So just curious if natural cherry and white work together. Wood floors, probably oak.

Comments (34)

  • 5 years ago

    White countertops will definitely work with cherry cabs. In the lower pic, Not sure about the extremely busy backsplash, however. Lots of inspiration pics online. https://www.google.ca/search?sxsrf=ALeKk013lZek3kM7sUoP8Q0ENeN8lnAkbQ:1613251270530&source=univ&tbm=isch&q=cherry+cabinets+with+white+countertops&hl=en-us&client=safari&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiN56an5efuAhWlNn0KHcFBCN4Q7Al6BAgFEEE&biw=1261&bih=1512

  • 5 years ago

    I like your first picture much, much better. The unstained look of wood with dark handles is classic. You won't tire of it. I always consider cherry as a more formal wood (like mahogany) but you can do a gorgeous casual kitchen like the first picture and it will be timeless.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    That isn’t standard oak. Inset cerused white oak like that is very labor intensive and one of the most expensive choices that you can make.

  • 5 years ago

    Celadon: Is there another wood that would look as good unstained as this one? Other than maple, which is pretty standard.

  • 5 years ago

    Looks like rift sawn oak perhaps, but not really cerused. I have an old art cabinet with oak veneer that looks pretty much like that.

  • 5 years ago

    So just curious if natural cherry and white work together. Wood floors, probably oak.

    Yep, they all work together beautifully.

  • 5 years ago

    Birch is very nice in its natural state. Birch cabs

    My cabs are birch, with a medium stain.


  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Keep in mind that natural wood will color shift over time.

    Scherr's has some information on this.

    https://www.scherrs.com/contents/en-us/d53_ColorShift.html




  • 5 years ago

    What don't you like about maple? I did it in a kitchen 25 years ago and it still looked great when we sold the place a few months ago.


    I love natural cherry, which I chose for my current kitchen. It is red, and darkens over time.


    Have you worked out your budget? As noted above, some wood gets very pricey, so it may be worth getting estimates before you fall in love with something too expensive.

  • 5 years ago

    I think latifolia is right to think about pricing, but also some of the pricing may be a surprise. Cherry, for instance, has come down in price recently. Natural cherry is often much lighter than what you showed in your original post, OP, and should work with the white you’re wanting.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Muriel Thompson, when I fall in love with cherry it tends to be in its pre-darkened coloring, so I'm just looking at redder pix guessing it will head that way (?). If it would stay lighter and browner I know I would love it. For instance, these photos, PERFECT:





    But this worries me...




    Do you think the first two photos I just posted are representative of the final state of cherry? I figure these photos might be taken during/soon after installation :}

    I also see plenty like my OP image and this below (labeled as natural cherry) that make me think I should be prepared for darker and redder:



    Latifolia, don't know why exactly...just consistently don't prefer maple. Not going for IKEA wood color I guess. The quartersawn oak has some appeal as the kitchen is going in a new addition to a 1940 home that is filled with quartersawn oak floors and paneled doors. But it's darker/ambered from oil-based finishes.

    Celadon, I did not think the first oak pic I posted looked cerused but I could be wrong of course. That would definitely be outside budget. Barker cabs does a quartersawn white oak we could afford, which is the only place I'm considering it and also why I'm leaning toward cherry which is more generally available. But red...

  • 5 years ago

    RedRyder, thank you, of course I prefer image 1 too :) Can I clarify what you meant though? Did you mean that going to cherry would move it more formal and it's *only* the 1st oak picture that you think will lend the timeless casual? I wasn't absolutely sure if you meant I could do it in cherry as the kitchen is styled in image 1 and like it as well, or if you were recommending against the cherry for my goals.

  • 5 years ago

    Unstained cherry will look nice, unless it darkens as it tends to do. I have 30 cherry furniture that never got red, but I wonder if the heat of a kitchen makes that evolution happen more quickly (?) My friends just redid their kitchen in a very “driftwood” looking wood that is more like your first photo. I will ask them what wood it actually is. They bought a soft ivory quartz countertop with very light black and caramel veining. It’s called Oxford and I never saw it before. I will try to get a photo from her too.

    aspen75 thanked RedRyder
  • 5 years ago

    darbuka, thanks for the rethink on birch. I was considering red birch (what we'd have a choice of) at one point, but then in the actual store saw the birch side by side of the cherry and just loved the cherry. But maybe I should reconsider as it won't darken/redden as much. Leftmost: red birch, middle: cherry, right: alder (out of the running for softness). This cherry sample I loved. But it didn't look very red. Maybe it has yet to darken or are different cherry choices from different companies going to vary much in color??.



    This shot of Barker cabinets in natural cherry (company we're considering along with Ultracraft above)...Orange/red eek!! You can see why this shot scares me. Can't be just lighting.


    Another concerning orange/red Barker cherry picture here...you can see why I'm lost between the top picture I like and these two I don't as much. All just clearcoat, no stain. Can it be lighting, or does one company use a different cherry variety than another potentially?



  • 5 years ago

    RedRyder, that would be amazing to get that info and a photo! I'd be obliged!! TY.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    You'll never get the look of the inspiration kitchen with cherry - you just won't. White looks great with cherry - I have it in my 25 year old kitchen that's getting ripped out. It darkens and turns orange over time. I'd never do it again.

    aspen75 thanked Design Girl
  • 5 years ago

    I asked my friends about their cabinets. They are cappuccino washed cherry. They are brighter than these photos show. On a bright day they have a soft “driftwood” appearance. I know they were not a very expensive cabinet. But they look amazing.

  • 5 years ago

    You can see their countertop is a white quartz but these photos don’t do it justice.

  • 5 years ago

    RedRyder, thank you! Interesting! I think I just saw that newly offered finish go by on a news release from Schuyler cabinets (sp?). Must be bleached somehow. Thanks for the info.

  • 5 years ago

    I just saw these at Lowe’s that I loved. Cherry with the cappuccino finish.


  • 5 years ago

    Yes, those are definitely similar to the ones in my friend’s house. In the right light, they look really soft and amazing.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    I'd be careful with those. The finish on that door looks uneven to me. Usually the sample is nice looking, so if this is the sample, I'd bet the ones you get would be worse.

  • 5 years ago

    They looked very nice in person, but they were pretty scratched up to be newer.

  • 5 years ago

    Thank you for posting this thread. We are looking to go with a similar look in our kitchen.

  • 5 years ago

    Cherry wood comes in deep red and shockingly white, all from the same tree. So cabinet doors can have a striped appearance unless the wood is carefully selected. You may have to go to high end doors to get a uniform appearance. And it all darkens over time.

  • 4 years ago

    That’s beautiful so I guess you don’t really have any input for me about my dilemma then ?

  • 4 years ago

    It’s beautiful. I hope you got the look you were aiming for.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    For me wood cabinets with wood flooring is simply too much of a good thing. Your kitchen looks good but would definitely suggested a non-wood floor - perhaps a hex tile or a classic white tile with black accents.

  • 4 years ago

    I agree. It was function over form. One of the things I knew wasn't ideal. There's a rug now, which helps a bit. It is a great room with a living room on the other side, but it didn't work well to tile one side and not the other because of the relatively wide and shallow shape of the great room. If it had been longer, there would have been the possibility of tile on the kitchen side only. We're happy enough, but I do agree! Caused me lots of angst worrying about the log cabin :}

  • 4 years ago

    Beautiful kitchen.

  • 4 years ago

    Very classic kitchen. I like the wood.

  • 4 years ago

    @aspen75 What cabinet company did you end up buying from? I'm considering ordering from Barker, Shaker style natural cherry similar to your kitchen, which I love! Thank you!

  • 4 years ago

    Paula Tucek...Ultracraft. Wide shaker, natural cherry. Full access euro style cabinets.