Software
Houzz Logo Print
a1an

Dormant Winter Pruning down to 2' and 5 Canes

5 years ago

I asked this last year......revisiting this. Still have a few roses that have yet to establish and still remain thin. For the established ones, how hard to prune back on the 1st post winter dormant prune before the 1st spring flush.


There is a video of Ben@Heirloom where he recommends to take her down to 16-24 inches and roughly depending on framework/age of canes, to 5-7 canes..


What's your routine

Comments (9)

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Sorry but without knowing the condition of your roses or what types of roses you have, I'm not sure we'll be able to help. Do you have more info to give?


    Try looking through here. But some types of roses absolutely detest pruning and without knowing what you have, I don't know how to advise you.


    https://www.houzz.com/discussions/3772241/is-this-cane-dead-a-visual-guide-for-cold-zone-spring-pruning#n=52

  • 5 years ago

    -shrub roses-. I know it's too generalized of a question but in the video I reference, he literally has knocked the whole thing down....and just pruned it down to a foot and a half, got rid of some older canes and basically left it with a -handful- (less than 7) canes .


    Granted, I get open framework, but isn't more leaves (aka, higher canes) = more leaves, more sunlight, more food.


    In the same/similar thread I posted last year, most/some of the majority said prune it down to 5 bud eyes as a general height reference.

  • 5 years ago

    Sure, more leaves allows for more photosynthesis, but thats only if they're all actually receiving sunlight. If things are getting crowded in the middle of the plant, not all the leaves are able to get good sun anyway, and crowding also prevents air circulation which is important for your plants' health. I personally would just remove inward facing branches, any obviously dead, broken, diseased canes, and I wouldn't worry about a certain number of canes to take it down to. If they're healthy and productive and in a good position, I'd leave them.

  • 5 years ago

    Heh. Re. On the thread linked, cold zone spring pruning. Roses are fine except for maybe 2 or 3 that I know had longer canes that I did not get to and is splayed/broken under the snow load


    On the latter woody shrubs (hydrangea), still under snow, and took a stake and just poked around the snow. I know I'm not going to like what I see once the snow melts. Some of the stronger canes have remained VERT even with the snow. But I'm expecting either lotsa splayed stems broken on the base or lotsa splay stems broken midway, etc

  • 5 years ago

    Sounds like somebody's pruning Austins. That isn't really how to prune most shrub roses, but the usual Austins are often pruned like floribundas. It's a higher/less drastic form of HT pruning.



  • 5 years ago

    Now is the time to experiment. Half the roses pruned aggressively; half lightly. Which get which treatment should be assigned randomly.

    Dr. Scott, the paleontologist from Dinosaur Train, advises to ‘get outside, make your observations, and record them in your journal‘. Or words very close to this.

    You can take before and after (pruning) photos, and a third set mid June. Results can be posted here. A follow up report consisting of late September photos can be appended at that time.

    All aboard for Dinosaur Train!

  • 5 years ago

    Uh oh, Dinosaur Train themesong is now lodged in my brain for the day. Thanks a lot 😉


    He says "get outside, get into nature, and make your own discoveries." Ask me how many times I've had to watch that show haha.

  • 5 years ago

    I will say this....one some of these where I pruned them short last year (they were in 1st full year hitting year 2), they still grew 6 feet up , even after deadheading

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    u had me for a chuckle there rifis.


    I stopped watching the 'toons with the lil ones @ bubble guppies, paw patrol, team umizoomi and then the last was pj masks. well, there was big hero 6. My favorite was still the super simple songs@the tube. My lil ones were never into dinosaur train but they like that older toon - umizoomi

    I don't know any of the -slang- afterwards. Heh.

    I still have like 2 more shrubs that are thin on the canes...that's for another thead on whether some roses are just -wispy- or not.