I am not able to figure out the best color option based on cabinet color and the flooring color.

Since the floor is already white I don't think white counter top is good Idea. Will beige look good? I have doubts because of cabinet colors.

If you don’t want white, which I think could look good, then another option is a steel gray as kelleg suggests.

The three choices, for lack of a better word, are awful for your kitchen.

When doing a new counter don’t use that 4 inch if you are planning to tile.

Its either one or the other.

Thanks eld6161

White would be the best choice - SOLID white - no veining or anything. Just plain white.

It’s not worth the cost . Leave the really quite acceptable counter on the perimeter. Is that an island? Put some butcher block there. Then get some hardware on the cabinets/ a new faucet and you’ll be just fine .

i totally agree with herb flavor! its not worth the cost. you have a lot going on with the floor and b/s. adding another element with 'movement' is just not the right way to go.

and to frank, those choices are just wrong

if u must replace, go with a SOLID. no creams, browns etc... white or dark gray to match your floor.

and FWIW, i would clear off the tops of the cabinets of all the greenery... lighten the feel of your kitchen.