Software
Houzz Logo Print
betsytlm

Tankless electric water heater special considerations

5 years ago

I have read discussions here about this topic. But here's my situation: brand new build, not yet started, solar power, (8K panels in full sun now, will need to add more we expect) not always enough in winter but ties into grid, central Calif, 3600', occasional light snow, guesthouse not main dwelling, no gas. This place will be used a few days a month, or perhaps for a whole month occasionally. So why have a tank heater keeping water warm all the time? Or turn it off when nobody there, then heat up 30-40 gallons for a few days? Or have tankless heater ready to go anytime. We will have electric heated concrete floors, so may or may not turn those off/on (separate issue), but plan a "smart panel" so can turn off circuits remotely separately. Unclear now if laundry for main house will be out there or not, otherwise unused if no occupants.

So what's best? What are the tradeoffs besides how often this will be occupied? Guesthouse is "studio" so mostly no more than 2 occupants at one time.

Comments (6)

  • 5 years ago

    My last house had an earlier version of that Rheem hybrid heat pump water heater and solar power, and it worked great for the 6 years I owned it. In Los Angeles, heat pump only mode worked great even in "winter". Only used hybrid mode one time when I had several house guests over Christmas (lots of showers, laundry, dishes) and then I put it in hybrid mode (and wow what a spike in energy that was). I would certainly recommend it, but your occasional usage of the space is a consideration. I tend to agree that it's odd to store so much water for such occasional use.

    betsytlm thanked Ryan B
  • 5 years ago

    Just to keep this all in perspective:


    The Energy Guide sticker on this water heater based on $0.12 kwh and "normal" usage (not guest house) is $104 a year. If it were never set to vacation mode between uses, it would still be something significantly less than that amount, because of the low usage (let's say $60). If you set it on vacation mode between uses, it would be even less.


    I think it's splitting hairs to worry about the cost of storing water for occasional use when the cost is ~$60 a year - even without turning it to vacation mode.


  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Except that PG&E has not charged 12 cents/kwh in a long long time. Our bill in coastal CA (same provider as most of CA's Central Valley/OP) for the month ending 15Mar2021 was 32 cent/kwh.

    I think the lowest I've seen it in the past year was 22 cents/kwh - and PG&E has already announced a 5% increase in rates starting April 2021.

    The general consensus is that with PG&E's bankruptcy - it exited proceedings in July 2020 with $39 BILLION in debt - the higher cost to access debt markets will result in continuing to increase rates to cover its capital needs.

    IOW, expect PG&E rates to continue to rise. In recent years we have seen not just one but two or more price increases annually go before the CPUC, which regulates rates.

    betsytlm thanked jakkom
  • 5 years ago

    Yes, you're right re rates. Because of the solar power there (see original post), we expect costs to be lower, at least in summer when credits can be banked for winter. As soon as @#$%!! PG&E sets that up. Thanks for your information.

  • 5 years ago

    Well, I'm sorry you have crazy rates. I'm a little above 0.11 per kwh... cheap coal, acid rain, toxic heavy metals and coal ash ponds are a thing here. But we have cheap electricity.


    That doesn't really change my answer though. The hybrid unit is the cheapest way to go and is the best match for Solar.