I like the style on the right, which would be lower on the door frame than the rounded option. Are they large enough? I think they should be significantly larger than your current lights.

The one on the right is 16 inches by 6 Inches. Do you think that is large enough?

Can't tell from a photo if the size will work. Tape out the size with painters tape on your brick, or compare it to your current light, and stand back at the street to see the full view of the house.

The door is 80 inches high, not counting trim above. I bought another light that is 20 inches and I’ll see if that height works better.

The one on the right is more modern and I am seeing a great deal of homes with them and each house looks great with them.

Do you know where the lights on left are from? I like them. Thank you.

Just replaced our front door lights last spring. Check to be sure you understand how bulbs can be replaced. Turned out you had to unscrew the whole front on ours. We were told you reach thru the hole on the bottom. But the hole was so small that only a five-year old could reach in there! Solution was to put in very long life bulbs. Plan on long-life LED bulbs regardless!

@hjf234 They are also from home depo, they are more expensive than your others but they are a lot more lantern.