Software
Houzz Logo Print
tracy_kristensen

refinishing oak issue

5 years ago

I just had my red oak floors refinished with no stain and a water based finish. This area in front of the steps looks yellow and discolored. It looks to me like it wasn’t sanded enough. I’ve showed it to them and they are acting like it will be hard to fix more than 2 boards out from steps.... to me it needs to be fixed about 5 boards out. I used a satin finish. Any thoughts...

Comments (33)

  • 5 years ago

    Here is another closer up photo

  • 5 years ago

    And one more

  • 5 years ago

    And one more

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    I don't see it. Forget about it and move on.

  • 5 years ago

    I can’t see a thing - might you be nitpicking?

  • 5 years ago

    Its wood, not all wood will take the finish exactly the same. I see nothing that sticks out as incorrect in your pictures.

  • 5 years ago

    Not seeing it here either.

  • 5 years ago

    Even with no stain and water based finish??. One of the reasons I went with no stain is because they said it was much easier to fix floor issues down the road. Sigh.....Also if this changes anything, It was just done last week.

  • 5 years ago

    Each time you pull a finish out of a can (even if it is the same can) you run the risk of having a different gloss. Why? Because the applicator will be different (even the same one that was washed = different texture). And the humidity = different. And the temperature = different.


    We've seen this botched over and over and over again. If it is SUPER bothersome, then get it fixed. BUYER BEWARE: The 'cure' can be worse than the 'disease'.


    Your BEST BET is to have the 'section' of floor refinished (at your expense). The Refinisher is going to give you a DISCOUNT to do this...but most of it will fall on you. What do I mean by 'section'?


    A 'section' of flooring is a continuous segment of flooring like a hallway (as I can see here) that TERMINATES at a doorway. If this wood continues down a hallway, then have the entire hallway recoated. Yep. Another coat added to the finish already down = LONGER TIME for curing. You will need another 7 - 10 days before that section will be ready.


    If you do this (and we are COUNSELING AGAINST IT) then here is what will happen:

    1. The Refinisher will use an edging tool to sand down the finish where the yellow is (what we believe to be a bit of the old finish). S/he will continue until they hit raw wood FOR SURE.

    2. With a BIGGER MACHINE the Refinisher will then abrade the ENTIRE HALLWAY....taking PAINS to feather to edges of the finish-raw wood interface (tricky this bit).

    3. Then the raw area = 2 coats of finish (feathering the edges = tricky)

    4. The entire hallway = a continuous coat

    5. 7 days for curing the entire area


    There it is.


    The refinisher will 'pay' for the hand sanding the yellow area + 3 coats of finish. The abrading of the hallways and the recoat = your costs.


    If you don't like the idea of paying more then allow the patch and hope for the best.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    It looks natural to me. Over time the floors have scars from use, it just gives it character. There is only so much the sander can take of the top before destroying the floor so small imperfections are unavoidable. Applying a darker stain would be the only way to cover those imperfections a bit more, but I think your choice to stay true to the natural wood was better for matching to everything else in the house. Concentrate on what is right(many things!! like a new completed project:) and move on. Start making new floor scars!! Haha. LOVE your runner btw🤗

  • 5 years ago

    It’s more obvious this time of day

  • 5 years ago

    Might help to see from a distance

  • PRO
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Are you referring to the darkish line? I know this is not what you wanted to hear but unfortunately there is not much you can do about that. It looks like it was a water or oil stain from previous use. Those run deep into the wood grain. And no matter how much you sand they will be there...You are lucky if you only have it here. If that is the only spot to fix and you absolutely want to do it, there are probably ways to deal with it. But in all fairness, anytime you refinish floors there will be these instances that don't in any way reflect on the contractors job. Agreed, they could have done a better job at warning you that these stains may be there visible after refinishing. You should ask your contractor if they can sand manually just that portion, sand off the finish then apply a LIGHTER stain then varnish again...You have to be aware that this would not be considered part of the job and would be done at your risk, as this is not a standard process... In general it is understood and accepted that when you refinish an older wood floor imperfections will be part of the mix.

    Tracy Kristensen thanked LilDesignWorks
  • 5 years ago

    Ask yourself: "How mad (at myself) will I be if the refinisher CANNOT do this properly?"


    We can warn you until the cows come home...(PS...they don't come home...that's why cowboys exist)...only YOU know your TOLERANCE of 'mistakes'.


    This is one of the 'easiest' to live with mistakes. You have a HUGE possibility that your floor dude is going to mess this up MORE than it appears already. You have to decide what you can handle. As things go...this is a pretty easy thing to 'overlook' in the grand scheme of things.


    Take the money and buy yourself a nice dinner.

    Tracy Kristensen thanked SJ McCarthy
  • 5 years ago

    I know that it may be disappointing to you right now, but to me it actually looks great. I love the color of your floors.

    Tracy Kristensen thanked chinacatpeekin
  • 5 years ago

    In the latest pictures I can see a slightly yellowish spot at the piece of tape furthest from the steps. Unless it stands out more on site, it would be foolish to attempt a fix. It's likely to be worse once it's mucked with. I'm more disturbed by the mineral streak but that's part of the wood.

    Tracy Kristensen thanked Timothy Winzell
  • 5 years ago

    I still don't see anything wrong. It looks like wood.

    Tracy Kristensen thanked H202
  • 5 years ago

    Yes the whole area butting up the steps looks discolored to me (splotchy) with more "yellowish/orange" hue (previous color) than anywhere else in the house. They told me they could resand the two boards closest to the steps and I probably wouldn't be able to tell (hope they are right). I guess I just didn't realize I would have some splotchy areas from the previous oil based finish. Honestly this is the only area I see that in which lead me to believe that they didn't sand it thorough enough. I am not trying to be difficult but it costs a lot of money and was a huge ordeal to move out and do this and I just wanted it done right. I wish they had communicated that a bit more what to expect and I may not have gone the lighter route. I do appreciate all for your help and your tips!

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Good luck:) enjoy your floors for many more years! They are beautiful:)

  • 5 years ago

    Here is another question for you pros. So I had my floor guys back to fix some issues. Along with the "splotchiness" I had in the foyer, I also had some smaller issues such as clumps of finish here and there that needed sanded down. Also, near my cabinetry they did not get close enough and there was a significant darker edge from the previous stain. It was very obvious and thus had to be fixed. The head of the company came to look at everything and said all that was easily fixable and even said the splotches in the foyer that were drawing my eye could be fairly easily fixed as well. Well they were here the week before last and "fixed" everything and I now I have some differing gloss levels in those areas primarily evident in artificial light. To my surprise, the foyer is actually not too bad but around one of the cabinets it looks sort of glossy then flat then glossy again. As a reminder, I requested the satin loba 2k finish for the job. I will attach a picture in below of the area near one of the cabinets.


    I have notified them and they say they will come back out to fix this again but here is where my concern really is.....While the floor guy was out fixing my house, he mentioned that in the past they have forgotten to put the hardener in the loba 2k and that can cause some sheen differences. He assured me it was not at my house but since he said that I can't stop worrying that maybe that did happen at my house? If that is the case how would I ever know? What would loba 2k look like without a hardener?

  • 5 years ago

    Here are pics of sheen difference near cabinets.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Did they use the wrong sheen? Did they shake the heck out of the bottle? Did they use a new clean brush?

  • 5 years ago

    I have no clue. I know initially he put down the wrong sheen for the first coat. Then he said he was doing the satin for 2nd and 3rd.

  • 5 years ago

    And he hand sanded in between

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    The Loba 2K products carry the sheen in the HARDENER. When mixing SMALL BATCHES (ie. not a full litre or gallon) it is almost IMPOSSIBLE to match the gloss levels. Why? Because each time you mix 2 cups of the stuff, you have to have accuracy to MEASURE/weigh the hardener to 0.01 ml. That level of accuracy is IMPOSSIBLE on the job site. If you add even 0.1 ml of hardener too much or too little you will get a different sheen.

    The HARDENER determines the GLOSS level. That's where things have gone sideways. To get the identical sheen they really need to do a recoat on the kitchen area - and mix an entire gallon of the product at that time.

  • 5 years ago

    So without the gardener it’s matte?

  • 5 years ago

    Hardener. 😝

  • 5 years ago

    Yep...That's what I'm saying.

  • 5 years ago

    What causes the finish in areas to look like this?

  • 5 years ago

    That stippling comes from a roller with a nap that is TOO LONG. Nothing else is wrong with it. This is precisely why it is 'best practice' to refinish the floor all at once instead of spot fix areas with the 2K products like Bona or Loba.


    Either live with it...or polish it down. A car polishing machine (those big hand held machines that weight 15 lbs with the big SHAMOISE on it...yah...one of those) can help with the gloss.


    Remember: it's a floor. It will look like 'it is always under foot' in about 2 years. And that's the way it should be. If it ain't broke...don't fix it. The finish is in perfect health. The 'look' is what you are bothered by.

  • 5 years ago

    Thanks SJ- you are very helpful

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    The finish issue can be caused by insufficient coverage. The finisher applied too thin of a coat. If, it is wide spread, I would have them apply another coat at their cost. How many gallons was used per coat?