Software
Houzz Logo Print
mtashillco

Help with stain on red oak

5 years ago

Need to make a decision on stain for the entire floor of my home. I’m wanting to contrast my cherry cabinets. Please choose:



A (50% Provincial 50% Natural)

B (25% Walnut 75% Weathered Oak)

Comments (12)

  • 5 years ago

    Neither. I prefer a very light floor with a medium cherry cabinet. Remember you need: MORE RED (closer to brick red/brown) to get it to work with cherry.


    And you NEED to go 3 steps LIGHTER (aka. natural in a colourless water based poly) or you need to go 3 steps darker...and that gets you awfully close to a super dark floor.


    What's your counter top?

    mtashillco thanked SJ McCarthy
  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    @SJ McCarthy Will be taj mahal quartzite

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    you could just do a Bona Natural finish and let the natural red oak color compliment the cherry.

    i like this one. Bona Nordic Seal








    Of your choices, the left one has more red, while the right side more brown, on the ashy side.

  • 5 years ago

    @Beth H. :my flooring contractor uses Duraseal products.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    here's a pic of cherry cabs (river white granite) and a more natural oak floor.


    I would not go dark. and I wouldn't try to match the red stain of the cabs either.

    SJ has it correct. Go many shades lighter

    i'm sure DuraSeal has a comparable finish to Bona

    this is Dura Seal Silvered Gray


    LEFT SWATCH – Duraseal Fruitwood mixed with Country White Stain / RIGHT SWATCH – Duraseal Silvered Gray

    I believe she ended up w/the silvered gray.

    the wall color is BM Calm. I'm actually doing this color in my living room. would look nice w/your cherry

  • 5 years ago

    @Beth H. :

    Natural is what I have and do not like! Ready to move on from orange. I’m not liking my ashy brown choice with my cabinets.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    orange is not natural! what's happened over the years is your top coat has ambered, and when amber is mixed w/the red/pink tones of the wood, you get orange!

    this is a natrual finish. now how is this orange??


    this looks way better


    up to you though. pick the one you like best. again, you're only showing us a little snippet.

    The lighter one on the left you've tested is going to turn out similar to what you already have (minus the overall orange glow)

    the darker one on the right is too dark and too ashy

    and we can't see what your Taj looks lke. some are gray, some are warmer toned.

  • 5 years ago

    @Beth H. :dont have counter yet. Wanted to get flooring first

  • 5 years ago

    you didn't take a pic of your slab? some slabs have more golden tones. some more gray


    golden tones




    grayer tones:




  • 5 years ago

    @Beth H. :I haven’t chosen it yet, I wanted to take wood color to slab yard to assist in selection. I will be looking for creamy tones, not gray. I’m not a fan of the natural looking wood floor. I want a timeless traditional look for my 65 yr old southern home.

  • 5 years ago

    Taj can be very very warm (can look strong gold in some lighting situations). Which means you will have a yellowy/gold slab on reddish-brown cabs over a 'reddish' floor of some sort (assuming you are going with stained floors). You will have huge amounts of warm + warm + warm. And it is possible you will get a dark kitchen. Dark cabinets on dark(er) wood floors + a medium-light slab has the *potential of getting dark in a hurry.


    I prefer to have a crisp or bluish tone as a slab on cherry/red/brown based cabinets. That way you can have your COLOUR contrast on your counters (small amount of square feet) and the floors can then be a compliment to your cabinets (very light if you wish).


    You do not have to go 'yellow' or 'orange' (like the oil based finish you have). You can have a wheat coloured floor with NO YELLOWING (water based finishes...are colourless and never turn yellow like what you have right now).


    Be VERY careful with Taj Mahal stones. They can be very yellow and they can look very yellow in a dark kitchen (dark cabs over dark floors).

    mtashillco thanked SJ McCarthy