Software
Houzz Logo Print
kameis

MCM Exterior Update

5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago

We are starting the process of replacing our roof and windows on a MCM California Ranch. We do not want to paint the cherokee red brick, but wish to update the exterior. We have considered black trim windows, charcoal paint and even cedar on the underside of the (nearly 4'!) soffit, but aren't sure if this will look right? We also need new garage doors at some point. I am desperate for suggestions to modernize the look of the house without ruining the MCM look. Any suggestions? Or photos of homes that that done this well? We can't find any in our area without the red brick/white trim look. Thank you for any suggestions you can offer!






Comments (12)

  • 5 years ago

    I think white on the windows looks good. You could do more modern garage doors and a vibrant color for the front door.

    Planks - Cedar · More Info


    Studio Collection · More Info


    Mid Century Modern - Revitalized · More Info


    kameis thanked houssaon
  • 5 years ago

    Navy is a beautiful compliment to the orange hued brick. and would modernize the overall appearance. I like SW Navel

    kameis thanked Lyn Nielson
  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Thank you! The front door is actually (dark) Navy in my current photo. Too dark? Would the navy accent color go on the windows and gutters? Or maybe just the underside of the soffit/overhang and leave the windows/garage/gutters white?

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    I do like the cedar color garage doors in your photo. It sounds like the white might need to stay, but we could punch it up on the garage and accent the soffit (underside) with some cedar?

  • 5 years ago

    I think the existing color reads a little dark Navel definitely reads blue navy. I would never paint gutters to stand out. they are utilitarian not meant to be an accent. The underside of the soffit should stay light... too dark and it will affect the interior rooms. although a very light blue would be refreshing, kind of a hint at the sky. If the house is South or west facing, I would not paint the trim and garage doors dark. the heat becomes too intense, and the paint will fade quickly. Do you have enough moulding/trim around your doors and windows to do both Navy and white for a fresh pop? I would leave the gutters as they are. at least they are a linear look, not alot of busy joining. ... If it were my house and the house was North or East facing, I would paint the trim and garage doors navy. good luck.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    your house is really awesome! the white trim around the windows look good. black would look great too. honestly, it's hard to decide.

    I also love the cedar garage doors posted above -- but only at a glance. in real life, many of these tend to look super fake (they are rarely offered in real wood, and faux wood grain pattern is pretty obvious). maybe it's possible there are some convincing ones out there, but all the ones I've seen IRL never look real to me.

    however that style of garage door would look awesome in any other color! they tend to come in a very limited palette, but many of these are paintable (be sure to ask). it could match your window trim, or your front door.



    you said you wanted to paint your soffits? what color are they now? if they're natural wood, I'd leave them.

    there are so many fun accessories you could add. modern house numbers, cool lamps, decorative fencing.



    or attach them to something curbside:






    kameis thanked User
  • PRO
    5 years ago

    The underside of the soffit is also white like the trim. I hadn't thought about a dark color making it dark in the house. We would definitely want to avoid that pitfall. Thank you all for your help. It sounds like keeping the white windows and trim might be best for preserving the look of the house. Our garage doors are original (heavy) solid wood, so I will have to think about whether we should just strip and repaint them or change them out entirely. We do have two street lamps that are in great condition much like the one you posted. We sit pretty far back from the street and I included a photo on a cloudy day. The brick definitely looks darker on these types of days, so black or dark on the windows, roof and garage doors might be a much more monochromatic look. Someday the basketball hoop will be gone! :)


  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    I would bite the bullet and start with the garage doors. IMO, that will make the most striking MCM statement/difference for the money. Not sure cedar will be the right compliment to your brick color.


    Winding Way 3 Exteriors · More Info


    Lower Gwynedd Garage · More Info


    Planks - Cedar · More Info


    kameis thanked decoenthusiaste
  • PRO
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Black or deep charcoal (less harsh) windows will bode well with the style of your home and deemphasize your window openings. A charcoal window will also make your windows appear larger. I think dark window frames, trim, and cedar soffits will look amazing with your home! Right now the white trim and windows feel a bit traditional and safe, taking away from the MCM style. Also, instead of dark garage doors, have you considered flat-panel wood doors, to coordinate with the soffit?


    kameis thanked User
  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    changing the garage really makes a huge difference in overall style when they're front facing like that. my house is posted above (the green one - please ignore the horrendous lawn). it wasn't very MCM looking from the outside, and the new door made a big impact. also, so much more light inside my garage!

    the style that I chose is a little different -- the windows are extra skinny (for some reason I can't find many examples of that online). if you're interested, the brand was Modern Tech style "BFL" (brochure here).

    but what you have now is not bad. you could paint them to match your front door for now and concentrate your efforts on other updates.

    also, regarding black soffits making the house darker: I read that too. exterior surfaces can make a surprising impact on how much natural light bounces into the home. it would be a pain in the butt, but you could temporarily tack up black paper above a few windows to see if it's really all that noticeable or not.

  • 5 years ago

    deb s - good ideas!

Sponsored
Wannemacher Interiors
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Customized Award-Winning Interior Design Solutions in Franklin Cnty OH