Software
Houzz Logo Print
maackia

The Fragrance Factor

5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago

To all the garden designers out there, how much importance do you put on fragrance in the garden? Does it have any role when designing a garden?

Comments (14)

  • 5 years ago

    None. My fragrance detecting unit is defective so that doesn't help, but the plants form, size, texture, hardiness and bloom all come first. Fragrance is just a bonus.

  • 5 years ago

    It is a focus only if the client requests it. Otherwise, several of the plants I use routinely in my designs are fragrant so some involvement but not a primary one.

  • 5 years ago

    I appreciate you sharing your perspective. I figured it would be down the list, but disappointed to learn it is of no real influence. What are the top factors, besides culture?

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    I'm a fan of fragrance in the landscape, especially if we can work it into areas where it adds some magic. I love planting fragrant plants below a deck, or near enough to a patio or bedroom window that they'll catch the occasional whiff but far enough it doesn't become gross or cloying. So lilacs, juddii viburnum, clethra, stuff like that. There's an added benefit to designing in rural VA, because some of the fragrant plants evoke scent memories from staying at grandma's farm in the summer, stuff like that. I wouldn't say that I've ever design *around* fragrance over other priorities like size, shape, form, or color; but we do consider it.


    I also consider scent when it comes to negative stuff as well. I planted a cultivar of viburnum dentatum right outside my back door. I now know not to do that unless the client is SUPER into the aroma of wet dog during bloom season.

    maackia thanked Revolutionary Gardens
  • 5 years ago

    A big reason why fragrance is so far down on the list is because scents of all kinds are ubiquitous to the plant world. Fragrance connotates a sweet perfume smell to me as in rose, jasmine or tropical gingers. Herbs like lavender, rosemary, alliums and mints are highly aromatic, but do you plant them for the fragrance? Pine trees and Wax Myrtle - Myrica have a distinct smell. A freshly mowed lawn has its own unique aroma. I had a client remove all the junipers because they smelled like cat pee to him. I had to stop and inhale to smell what he was talking about. We all know the rumors about the odor of Bradford pears which I can't detect. Scents are just a given in the plant world. I have been crawling around in the bushes for so long is probably why I don't notice them all that much. It's like all the bugs and spider webs and sticky seeds that cover me.

    In landscape design form has to come first. Is the plant going to fit in this space followed by will it grow in these conditions. After that texture which includes evergreen or deciduous, leaf color and flower can follow. Even if you start with a want of flower or fragrance, a plant has to pass the form and will it grow here test first.

    maackia thanked Christopher CNC
  • 5 years ago

    Since I design almost entirely to client specs, I would say the overriding factor in my design consideration is low maintenance. That is usually at the top of the list of client demands :-) Layout, hardscaping and all the picayune considerations of plant selection flow off of that premise.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    The stone cold realism of low maintenance. I do understand that, and I’m probably naive, but my wish is more clients would be sold on a fragrant element. I can’t help but feel an important part of the garden experience is lost without it.

    Revolutionary Gardens, I hope you’re on to something with your approach. A touch of fragrance in the designed garden? It seems doable. :)

  • 5 years ago

    If it makes you feel any better my grandmother's garden was named Heaven Scent. Fragrance in the garden is not a foreign concept, it is just rarely a primary design focus, more of a 'I'd like some of that too'.

  • 5 years ago

    It does make me feel better. :)

  • 5 years ago

    Good question. I am not a garden designer but I do have some input. I’ve been focusing on native plants lately. I am getting a roof built over my deck, along with putting some nice outdoor furniture and a tv under it. It will be a good spot to entertain since the inside of the house is small. I plant on putting a couple native fringe trees on the outside of the deck. I think they are beautiful and underused. I am also hoping that the couple weeks of scent will have people curious as to what the plant is. I think scent is sometimes a good way to get a person who isn’t super interested in plants somewhat interested. This is all a theory so I’ll check back in a few years when the trees get bigger. But it would all be worth it to get someone to put a native fringe tree in their yard who usually wouldn’t consider one. Or any other scented plant of shrub at that.

  • 5 years ago

    Looks awesome ! I recently posted about fringe tree and you were one of my responses. You have also commented on some of my other posts, I always appreciate your input. I have also thought about scent along the a bed near the street where people walk by in the neighborhood. Anything to strike a convo to hopefully get someone into the great hobby of gardening. I see people stop and look and my garden and they will say it looks great to me in passing. But they never ask the good questions like what is it, what conditions does it like or do you do anything special. So maybe a sense like smell will get them to ask the good questions, you never know !

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    I can pick out boxwood and junipers instantly because they smell like cat pee. I try to avoid walking by our local Panera because there are so many junipers planted there, soooo stinky!!

    And yes, Bradford Pears reek, I hate it when they bloom by my work.

    I'm not a garden designer but an avid gardener. I have certain plants because I, and the pollinators, like them and as a bonus they're scented. I do consider scent in the garden and will choose something with a pleasant fragrance over one without if they both work in the area I'm considering.

    The main issue I encounter is that a scent someone else likes I may find distasteful. So if I can, I try to smell the variety I'm considering before I purchase it (especially something large like a witch hazel).

  • 5 years ago

    I will select plants that smell good over plants that don't. I've even come to this forum with a photo asking "what is this plant that smells good?" and then planted it.



    I'm not a designer either. I did have a designer that suggested gardenias by the kitchen window for the fragrance but they all died. :)






    Fragrance is one of the many reasons citrus trees/shrubs are all over my yard. Yeah, they're pretty and the bees like them and they make food and they're low-maintenance, but they can really smell. And with enough varieties, you can get it almost year 'round.