I usually like shutters, but not in your case. Your window on the bump out isn't centered, and the windows on the right side of the house don't have room for shutters. The dark shutters highlight both those problems. I would remove all the shutters, and paint your trim around the windows a soft color so you have some contrast to the white siding, but not a heavy contrast that highlights the asymmetry. You could try keeping the shutters around just the door to see what you think, or consider adding sidelights there instead if possible.

I tend to agree with calidesign regarding no shutters and adding contrasting trim.

Your house will look more modern and sophisticated if you remove them

The only place I would keep shutters is by the door. But get raised panel ones. Paint them black and the front door a vibrant yellow in semi-gloss.

Miller's Meadow Farm · More Info

Keeping the shutters by the door is a good idea

Thanks everyone!!

I think it's imperative to center the window under the gable. I would consider painting the second floor a contrasting color to compensate for taking away the shutters.

Your lanterns on either side of the door should be much larger in size Here is a Garrison Colonial to use as inspiration.