Software
Houzz Logo Print
katie_wassink

What would you recommend for this space?

5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago

This kitchen will soon be ours. I would like to get around having to resurface or repaint the cabinets if possible. Budget would allow one or the other - refinish cabinets or replace granite. Walls will likely be in Repose Gray. Floors will be replaced and shown below. pendant lighting changed, hardware replaced and bscksplash installed and dual oven replaced to match stainless set. I think bulking up the island is in order and then painting to make focal point and showcase. It is substantial size with the granite top measuring 88x40


The cabinets are excellent quality but dated finish.


Comments (31)

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Wood cabinetry is ’in’ plus is classic Grey is more dated, as far as wall color, at this point.

    I used tile overall in these visuals:







    White backsplash to the ceiling in cabinet areas. I would only use grey paint on walls without cabinets. I like a black and white floor tile.

    https://www.tilebar.com/bella-mori-8x8-porcelain-tile.html

    Change of pendants. Would definitely bring in undercabinet lighting if it is not there, plus new cabinet hardware.

    Or have cabinets professionally painted or refaced. With that, probably a darker wood or wood look LVP for the floor, to balance with the black granite.

    Katie Wassink thanked freedomplace1
  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    @Beth H. : some excellent observstions and suggestions. Thank you! For the floors, I really like the one pictured here. I share your sentiments on the refacing and painting. i was hoping to get around it but like you said, i have to live with it. Maybe i start by bulking up the island and painting it in a white for two tone contrast against the cabinets. A slow ease into likely doing them all. Something like this:





  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Thank you, @freedomplace1! What a great visualizer! What a difference replacing the pendants and neutralizing the wall color makes. If I do find i cant live with these cabinets color, i would probably have resurfaced and painted white. Keep the black granite. Bulk up and refresh the island with paneling. Here are the floors i am considering. I also thoight about maybe painting the island in a contrasting two tone color to make it more the focal point, likely white if i did this.


  • 5 years ago

    To the OP, we didn't get much info about the new replacements going in. But for kitchens my opinion is that lighter is better, especially if you cook. If you want a more modern look and you have the money, I would suggest new cabinet fronts that have a flat surface. If you don't want to go there, have them all stripped and painted some very light gray or white. And replace all the hardware on the cabinets too. All that woodwork is really depressing, IMO. You might want to include a bright accent color to counter balance all the gray. Coral, turquoise, green......just in a few small spots.

    Katie Wassink thanked Lyone Fein
  • 5 years ago

    Tough ask. I too think the MOST offensive thing are the counters, not the paint, floor or door profiles of the cupboards. This post is EXACTLY what I was referring to on another thread about change/waste/filling landfills all in the name of "updated". The wood is just sooo much richer than white or shaker flat fronts. All the before and after pics posted on this site show crisp, new WHITE kitchens and they show cold, impersonal and flat to me. Nothing inviting or cozy about them. Part of it is the newest door profiles. They are sooo industrial and utilitarian looking, feeling. sigh. But if you are in the gotta have graaaaayyyy camp then I would suggest you look through some pics, gather a story board of ideas then return. More information is needed to steer you to where you will be happiest.

    Katie Wassink thanked arcy_gw
  • 5 years ago

    Not one size fits all - best advice I can give is pick out a good classic wood floor finish and have the floors done before move in and then live with the rest for a year. What bugs you initially may end up being low on the priority list and things you never dreamed would bug you may rear their ugly head and ‘need’ to be dealt with.

    Katie Wassink thanked thinkdesignlive
  • 5 years ago

    What do you mean by “bulk up” the island? Doesn’t look like there is room to make it bigger, other than having the cabinetry fit exactly under the countertop. Love the idea of painting it! Is this your forever home? I would not tile the entire opposite wall - it’s a great place for art, family photos, maybe some shallow shelving. I don’t mind the wood, but would like it better with light countertops, a different tile floor, a tile backsplash, and a painted island.

  • 5 years ago

    I would not tile it either. I was just trying to show the white backsplash to the ceiling and Tile Bar tool tiled that opposite wall, also. It shows grey there instead of white - so I left it - to show OP how some grey might work on that wall. It was easier for me to do it that way. That wall would be painted. Not tiled.

  • 5 years ago

    The floor is nice. I would leave it.

  • 5 years ago

    If the cabinets are in good condition, then I would just refinish them and update the backsplash and lighting. Sending these Houzz photos as inspiration.

  • 5 years ago

    I would not use the floor color you chose. It’s very limiting. Get a real wood floor in either a soft, light color, or a rich walnut. Then you have room to either upgrade your current wood cabinets with new counter/hardware/backsplash or with a darker floor you can paint it to white cabinets with new hardware/backsplash and keep your current granite for another day. Engineered wood floors are not that expensive but look richer than the color you chose.
    Your island and overhang are the right proportion. Don’t spend money redesigning it.
    I inherited an oak kitchen I hated. I got a lot of flack about changing it but I didn’t care. Like @Beth H I refaced it and think it’s fantastic. I wanted a white kitchen so I got it.
    Painting a kitchen is expensive when done right and you would want new doors anyway, so I would save my money and go for a refacing job. Lighting, hardware and new countertops are also worth saving for. Don’t do anything until you have lived there a year because if that layout isn’t working for you, then you need a bigger budget for a full remodeling job.
    Here are my before and after.

  • 5 years ago

    You have an excellent foundation to start with in my opinion. I would paint the island a warm white, add a backsplash and change the cabinet Harvard to maybe something like aged brass. I would paint the walls a deeper shade of warm white so the island would pop. Good luck!

  • 5 years ago

    Best wishes on you soon to be kitchen. Nice layout. A handful of thoughts for you. Slow down - take a while to see what you really need vs changing floor, cabinet, double oven etc. Work with what you have - which is lovely. And then take your time {and save} to get it done the way you want after living with it for awhile. Also, unclear what your intent is to bulk up the island, it appears fine. The repose gray may not be the right color for the room. Two-tone cabinets will be dated in 5 -7 years, IMO. Would consider new pendant lights - that will update the space and be easy/budget friendly. There may be other parts of your new home that need more immediate attention because of unexpected surprises. Exciting times.

  • PRO
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    I am not sure all work together





  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Although I can appreciate looking at a nice white kitchen, I personally would never want to live in one. I share some of the opinions of @arcy_gw in that regard, except I think the dark counters could work. I am a fan of wood, although in some of the wood kitchen pictures posted on the forum it is sometimes hard to see what condition they are in which could impact what direction is taken. I also think gray looks ghastly with wood tones, unless it is very dark, almost charcoal. If anyone wants to bring out the orange in wood, put it next to gray.

  • 5 years ago

    This picture was posted on another thread where someone was wondering what to do with wood and black counters. I think the black subway looks amazing. Just food for thought…haters of dark countertops will likely hate this too but I think it looks amazing. The only thing i do not like is the granite is a little busy. The OP on this thread does not have that problem.




    Katie Wassink thanked Nancy K
  • 5 years ago

    The wisest advice on Houzz when someone moves into a house with a functional space is to wait six months to a year to make major changes, i.e. think things through.


    If the cabinets are in great shape, then changing the countertops would give you a whole new look.

    Forest Retreat Kitchen · More Info



    Forest Retreat Kitchen · More Info



    Contemporary Kitchen · More Info


    Are the floors vinyl and that's why you're changing them? If they're tile, they harmonize perfectly with the cabinets. A warm white island would look great if you want an update. Or just change out a couple wood doors to glass.


    Daniels Design Kitchens · More Info


    Repose gray and grayish flooring are all wrong if you decide to keep the cabinets. Go in a warm direction with your wall paint and floor. Here's an article about choosing paints that go with wood:https://www.houzz.com/magazine/11-terrific-paint-color-matches-for-wood-details-stsetivw-vs~9025200

  • 5 years ago

    not really seeing this shade working w/your red brown cabs. This is more yellow toned.

    why LVP? you don't want real hardwood?


    I can see what you mean by beefing up the island. However, if you do that, I don't think you'll have the overhang room for seating. Is it mandatory you have stools?

  • 5 years ago

    @Beth H. : Which color goes with is floor? i am gloored trying to figure thst out. I am choosing LVF instead of hardwood because i have had both and prefer the LVF with our family. plus, its significant cost savings. i would put panels on the island to make it more viaually aplraling and possibly shelving on the end losing one seating space making it seat 4. I think i will have to refinish the cabinets with either paint or other professionally to keep this floor choice. this is what the island may look like




  • 5 years ago

    @housegal200 Thank you for your thorough and thoughtful reply and respurces. The prwsent floor is tile. i find it distasteful IMO. The cabinets are in excellent condition as they are excellent quality and have rode time and wear well. I thought Repose Gray would neutralize the red/orange tones in the wood finish. i find the idea of painting the island a good one. whatever color it is, the rest could end up being painted if i still find the wood intolerable after living with it for some time. i am uncertain on what to paint the kitchen and everyday eating dining now.

  • 5 years ago

    OP, go to a big box store and grab a bunch of samples that are close to the color of your cabs. Bring them home and find the one that matches. Then use that to go back to the big box store and find some counter tops, backsplash, and paint colors that complement the cabs. Once you find the color family that works, you can shop elsewhere for more options.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    ^ This.

    Can't pick from a monitor. you'll want something similar to what you've chosen, less yellow.

    check out coretec. this is Valor Oak and Valor Hayes


    Makkah Oak


    and I like your idea about the island. you can paint it another color after doing the trim work to the panels.

  • 5 years ago

    Nice kitchen as is.

    IF the flooring needs to be changed or you really dislike what is there, then change the flooring first. Then pause and rethink your color options. Then paint. Then pause.

    Live with each change a while before deciding on additional changes.

    Like your cabinets as is and likely would keep them at least for a while ... with the possible exception of the island -- at least its base cabinet and, perhaps, its countertop as well. Changing only that for now could enable you to know if you like living with the choice before putting a larger investment into all the cabinets until you are sure. If you do change your cabinets, and if you cannot reuse them in a garage or basement, then consider donating them to Habitat for Humanity.

    Katie Wassink thanked suezbell
  • 5 years ago

    @Beth H. : Thank you! Good insights and product knowledge. Going to their visualizer now.

  • 5 years ago

    Select your flooring, then the other colors. I’m not sure your selected flooring will work well with Repose Gray. Bring color samples to see in place, not in the showroom. Fluorescent lighting is very different from normal kitchen lighting.

    Katie Wassink thanked felizlady
  • 5 years ago

    I’m not sure i would introduce gray into this all-warm palette. For me, this would set in motion a neverending series of remodeling jobs - new floor, new cabinets, new countertops, new backsplash, new furniture, new window treatments, etc etc.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    I'm not sure I'd use grey in this all-warm colour scheme. This would start a never-ending sequence of renovation projects for me: new flooring, cabinets, countertops, backsplash, furnishings, window treatments, and so on.

  • 5 years ago

    rather than adding another wood or fake wood element …i would consider 12” black and white squares laid in a diamond pattern on the floors…this will give some pop to the kitchen with minimal trouble or expense…painting the walls white will keep it simple and crisp…at this point you can decide if you want an interesting detailed backsplash…

  • 5 years ago

    What about slate floor? Like a stone grey or black slate? Paint the walls white (can’t go wrong) and see how it feels? Not a fan of the wood floors with wood cabinets personally

  • 5 years ago

    I would paint the cabinets and get new hardware, the white against your dark granite with bring it into the 2021. I've recently had a wall unit painted white (I lost sleep over the decision) completely update my bedroom! I've since had my linen clost and bathroom cabinet paint the same DR swiss coffee......new house!

    Katie Wassink thanked kathylawyer