Software
Houzz Logo Print
sbm321

Would you paint this mantel?

5 years ago

Some history:


This is the DR fireplace before we moved in. Note the lovely peach hues on wall and wainscoting.



First paint job after we moved in. Mantel was stripped and cleaned but not varnished. Decided to leave as is and decide later whether or not to varnish.



More recent paint job after the green walls became too moody for me. (Hung those strings of brass bells for Christmas 2019; still there.)



As we have been looking at dining room tables and considering some fairly dramatic walnut table tops, I’m wondering if we should paint the mantel/trim white.


OR should we varnish it?


We initially liked the wood because we felt like it related to the vestibule, which I assume is the same wood though the mantel wood doesn’t seem as pretty — maybe it would be with some varnish, though?



Orrrr should we paint?


Thoughts?

Comments (87)

  • 5 years ago

    I’m not quite that whimsical, mtn. ;-/


    I really want an upholstered seat, too.


    And, I’ve got enough random wood finishes already that I really want the chairs to ”match” the table, ie either walnut or black. The more I look, my ideal scenario would be walnut chairs with an upholstered seat in in a subtle print that has my ”theme colors” as my family refers to them.


    I really like this chair. I’m going to be near a Stickley store tomorrow so might pop in to take a look.



  • 5 years ago

    Wait. I think I prefer this chair.



  • 5 years ago

    I like 2 a bit better, though that may just be that I am not much for MCM, too much of it reminds me of lunchrooms.


    Of course I am the proud owner of 10 Kindel sleigh chairs, which should be disqualifying.

  • 5 years ago

    What about lower back support? The second chair looks rather empty in that zone.

  • 5 years ago

    Bunny, why are you bothering me with practical matters? 😜 I forgot we were sitting on them. I like the way they look! Isn’t it nice how the curved lines of the chair echo the table base? Sigh. Will be going on some kind of ”sitting on chairs in stores” odyssey with DH when I can get him to agree to it.


    There’s still the option of keeping the chairs we have, or the same chairs in black leather.




  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    If I went with an all-wood chair...I like this one. It’s matte black stain, which is intetesting.







    Back to tile — I like these — not necessarily this dark, but I like the types of tile.




  • 5 years ago

    I had a revelation today— though I like the idea of a colorful, artsy sort of tile, I think with our detailed wainscoting and the upcoming new furniture, something along these lines is going to be the best bet.




    Does anyone have good photoshop skills to give me a preview?? (I’m thinking a gray tile inside the firebox, what do you guys think?)



  • 5 years ago

    It's lovely and I can see why you like it. FWIW, my 2 cents ...I think you already have a house that is Victorian and DR that is Craftsman-y, and your FPL should be one or the other.

  • 5 years ago

    The nice thing about something plain for the firebox is it won't compete for attention with the carvings then, in fact it will highlight them more . . . Ever consider just painting the bricks white? I'd have to photoshop that myself to know for sure if it looked good. I am all about path of least resistance . . .

  • 5 years ago

    Mtn, that was kind of my point — do you think the marble tile is not Victorian enough?

  • 5 years ago

    Ipink, also agree, and my thought was that the marble would not compete. I could try painting the brick... but I was thinking marble would dress it up a bit.


    I have looked at so many FP pics seem to find a scenario like mine. Most rooms with white wainscoting also have painted fireplaces, apparently.

  • 5 years ago

    I love that tile, but i think the shape is not quite Victorian? and perhaps the sheen? (could be the light)


    I love the INdia green in this link: https://www.victorianfireplacetile.com/collections/tiles Maybe pair it with the creamy herringbone in your photo

  • 5 years ago

    Or maybe just a marble slab, not tile? and not shiny.



  • 5 years ago

    This is too shiny. What if I did a marble slab surround but a tile hearth? Nicer tile than what I have now.




  • 5 years ago

    yes, i think may be what i most commonly see in Victorian homes

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    even marble subways, which are dirt cheap (honed)

  • 5 years ago

    LOVE that olive blend in mtn’s link!

  • 5 years ago

    Update.


    We met with our tile guy finally. We will be covering the brick on the face of the FP with carrera marble (slab, not tile). I have chosen a very simple ceramic tile for the hearth. It is a dark teal/gray color. I am painting the interior brick with a dark gray paint.


    I bought some tung oil (thanks Annie) and applied some in an inconspicuous spot. In doing so, I realized/remembered that our painter had stripped off the old paint but left quite a bit behind. He had been tentative because he was worried about damaging the detail … so now I’m thinking any kind of oil or varnish is going to accentuate the leftover areas of paint, so do I now need to find someone who wants to spend hours removing all the remaining old brown paint, or do I want to paint it white? I am leaning heavily toward painting, but DH is not (yet) convinced.


    Seeing bumble’s pretty FP mantel in her DR pics made me think ”yes” to paint. I think we’ll wait and see how the marble/tile look.

  • 5 years ago

    I love the new wall colors. Personally, I wouldn't paint that mantle. I'd would go with the tung oil approach. Oh, the andirons are lovely!

  • 5 years ago

    This is finally happening.


    Yes, I painted the FP. And I’m glad!


    Marble is being installed on the brick face, and simple gray-blue subway tile (herringbone) is going on the hearth.



  • 5 years ago

    Good for you! Looks great from what I can see, cant wait for the Grand Reveal.

    Sueb20 thanked localeater
  • 5 years ago

    Gorgeous!! I love it. Looking forward to the finished product reveal!

    Sueb20 thanked amykath
  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    What a difference! So fresh and beautiful. Love it, can’t wait to see the tile and marble.

    Sueb20 thanked Jilly
  • 5 years ago

    Oooooh! I like it!

  • 5 years ago

    Sue about a year and a half ago I had someone cover the marble fireplace in our new house with brick, lol. The marble was dark and moody and i wanted the casual homey look of my favorite paint and mortar daubed brick.



    From the RE listing…. and how awful does that shoe molding look painted white against the dark stone?



    Fihished, just before move in.


    it’s so interesting— and such a great reminder that style is adaptable—- to see two projects doing the opposite thing but each resulting in a better look and fit for the current owner and decor.


    I think your painted FP surround and mantel look spectacular, and can’t wait to see the white marble installed!

    Sueb20 thanked User
  • 5 years ago

    Gorgeous!!!

    Sueb20 thanked jojoco
  • 5 years ago

    Progress…



  • 5 years ago

    Beautiful!

    Sueb20 thanked User
  • 5 years ago

    Wow, it looks so beautiful painted (and I liked it before!). Also love the marble and tile.


    Sueb20 thanked teeda
  • 5 years ago

    Gorgeous! Love how it flows with wainscoting.

    Sueb20 thanked lizbeth-gardener
  • 5 years ago

    Great decision, especially with the replacement of the tile and addition of the marble slab. Looks wonderful.

    Sueb20 thanked OutsidePlaying
  • 5 years ago

    oh my!! A stunning difference…. gorgeous!!

    Sueb20 thanked martinca_gw sunset zone 24
  • 5 years ago

    pre grouting (grout is charcoal gray like the interior of the FP)



  • 5 years ago

    Done! so happy!



  • 5 years ago

    Looks terrific

    Sueb20 thanked cran
  • 5 years ago

    It looks great. Good design decisions all around.

    Sueb20 thanked czarinalex
  • 5 years ago

    Nice! I thought the tile might be too dark, but actually it flows nicely with the firebox which is better than creating a third tone. Now your new table can shine without fighting this element.

    Sueb20 thanked mtnrdredux_gw
  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Looks fresh and bright. Your tile guy did a nice job, Sue. Did he adhere the marble directly over the brick? he removed the brick on the hearth? Love the blue herringbone, he laid that tile perfectly.

    Sueb20 thanked Arapaho-Rd
  • 5 years ago

    Look at the transformation! Gorgeous.



    Sueb20 thanked Jilly
  • 5 years ago

    Nice Jinx! Really shows how gorgeous the new FP looks!

    Sue, you did an amazing job and so quickly!! Congrats. This will make deciding on a table and chairs so much easier.

    Sueb20 thanked amykath
  • 5 years ago

    Sue, I love everything about it. Did your tile guy procure the marble slab, or did you get it at a yard? Remnant or?

    Sueb20 thanked Bunny
  • 5 years ago

    Yes, the marble went on over the brick. And he removed the old tile on the hearth.

  • 5 years ago

    Jinx, thank you! Painting the wood was a little scary, but I am super happy I finally did it.


    Bunny, the tile guy got the slab. We have carrera marble slab covers on most of our radiators, and on our kitchen backsplash, so I’ve got a ”theme” going now.

  • 5 years ago

    Sue, it's beautiful. I have honed carrara on my guest bath vanity and I love it despite the mystery etches. It's luscious.

    Sueb20 thanked Bunny
  • 5 years ago

    It is just lovely!! Thanks for sharing!

    Sueb20 thanked Funkyart
  • 5 years ago

    Thanks, everyone! 🥰

  • 5 years ago

    Aggg 3rd attempt to post this. Table and chairs have been ordered, atk.


    With black legs, not brass.



    And this chair — in charcoal velvet. Table top and chair legs are walnut.



  • 5 years ago

    I love it, Sueb!

    Sueb20 thanked texanjana
  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Could not be more perfect!!! Love how your mantle decor & painting connect with the tile! And your table & chairs will be awesome with this look!

    Sueb20 thanked lizzie_grow