Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_367669309

caulk keeps separating from acrylic shower base

5 years ago

I have a shower with an acrylic base, in a shower with ceramic-tiled walls. The caulking between the top of the shower base and the bottom row of tiles on the wall keeps separating along one wall. I think this is because the acrylic shower base is flexible and moves slightly downward when a person gets in the shower and stands in the center. I have re-caulked it four times with different caulks and thicknesses, but it still separates from the shower base after a couple of weeks. We could replace or reseat the entire shower base, but that would be expensive and beyond my DIY ability. Can anybody suggest another solution? Maybe an extra-flexible caulk or strip or something else? Thanks

Comments (11)

  • 5 years ago

    Hi, This is just a wild idea. I read where they had problems like yours but for tubs. Maybe this would work for showers..

    Cut and clean out the old caulk. Put a stopper over the shower drain put as much water as you can in the shower then caulk. Let it sit for about 24 hours then drain. Before you do this figure out how to stop the water from draining. I was thinking a rubber mat over the drain and a big pot with a flat bottom filled with water to hold and seal the mat down. Fill the shower and wait about 24 hours and see if it held the water, if it did then give it a go.

    Good Luck Woodbutcher

  • 5 years ago

    Your theory sounds plausible. Something additional may be going on, like:

    What type of caulk have you been using?

    If one of the caulks that failed to stick was silicone--well, nothing sticks to silicone caulk. Not even fresh silicone will stick to it.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    "For the best adhesion, we recommend removing the old silicone. New silicone will bond to old silicone, but the bond is not as strong as if it is adhered to a clean surface. If you choose to apply over old silicone, the warranty is void."

    https://gesealants.com/frequently-asked-questions/

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Properly installed bases dont have flex.


    I fear you knew the answer before you came here for moral support, you need to fix the root cause. This will require a full gut and resetting the base PROPERLY and then new waterproofing tied into and OVER the bases integral tile flange properly.


    Lets hope there is no drywall or cement board wicking water currently.


    Lastly dont get bamboozled into a partial fix . It is gonna be expensive to do it again CORRECTLY but you knew that already

  • 5 years ago

    Pros, isn’t there also a problem with trying to apply new silicone caulk over an area that previously had silicone caulk? I think I remember having to wipe the area with some kind of solvent to get the surface completely cleaned from caulk residue. If so, what solvent is that?

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Nancy:


    Please read all the comments before posting. After removing as much as possible, I'd wipe it with acetone.

  • PRO
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Nancy as joe states acetone is in fact the only solvent that will break down silicone residue FULLY.

    Acetone is also the enemy of many acrylic tubs and bases. Do be careful w acetone and certain MFG tubs/pans. I.E. Maxx tubs specifically state not to use acetone.

  • 5 years ago

    Funny, I don’t see anything about acetone in posts above my question, Joe. Thanks for your answer, though!

  • PRO
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    LOL good times Nancy

  • 3 years ago

    My problem is similar but with my acrylic bathtub. The sheer weight of the water and of my body makes the tub detach itself a tiny bit from the caulking. I think there may be a rubberized caulking product on the market where the caulking expands a millimetre or so. You are right. The problem is not with the base but the fact that acrylic is slightly flexible.

  • 3 years ago

    The answer to your problem with your tub is up above. Clean all the old caulk off. Get some good silicone caulk. Fill tub with water, and then caulk it again with good silicone caulk. Let it sit overnight, and then let the water out.