Software
Houzz Logo Print
shannon_ebron

Just another gutter dilemma

5 years ago

I am in the process of making a few updates to the exterior of my home and have run into a gutter dilemma. Our gutters are getting to the point where they could definitely stand to be replaced but I don't like the current almond/tan (?) color. I am considering replacing them with white. I think the white contrast would look nice against the siding (moss?) and would help brighten everything up a bit.
Of course this means I would also need to replace everything, soffit, fascia, underneath my front porch, etc, etc. so this is an expensive project and I want to make sure I am making the right design decision. Hence my dilemma.
For reference, I included a few pictures of the house, siding color, and current gutter color. The siding color looks tan in the pictures but it definitely has a greenish undertone - not sure the actual color.
We are replacing the front door with a Provia 440 in black with Carrington glass (white trim around door) and replacing the front porch post to a 6x6 white post (both pictured). The shutters will also be painted black.
I am interested in others opinions. Is white the best option?
Thanks for your feedback!

Comments (23)

  • 5 years ago

    @Hallett&Co Thank you so much! I appreciate your input.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    I was trying to find some photos to show you some visuals.

    I think you could do white, black or even a copper color gutter.

    White windows, white posts, white gutters, soffits, window trim and almost white siding, is a lot of white.

    here's your white.


    white, white and white. this is a lot of white.




    (is it possible to do the porch ceiling in a stained wood beadboard? or maybe a black beadboard?)

    trying to find a brick w/black shutters and black gutters so you can see.


    slightly diff model home, but it has the white porch posts, white ceiling, but used black gutters and down spouts. I like it w/your other black elements


    brick, white soffit, black gutter w/dark roof


    you have a dark roof, so doing the black next to it might look better than the white.


    here's a copper color next to the brick and black shutters. the soffit underside is still white.


    The copper color blends into the brick


    Compared to the white. what do you think looks better?


    If you do a copper or even a black gutter, you could still have a white soffit underside. It's perfectly fine to mix two colors

    personally I like the black or the copper better than the white

    if you've ever wondered what a total redo could look like:




  • 5 years ago

    Food for thought. I have a red brick home and white trim and white gutters. When I posted pictures of my house regarding curb appeal (had torn out overgrown bushes and replaced and expanded some of the beds).


    The favorite comment for the thread was:

    'For now, paint the garage door to match the siding, paint the front door a color that stands out, and please paint that downspout to match the brick so it disappears.'


    I did paint the garage door, am painting the front door. Have not gotten around to thinking about the downspouts, but don't find white downspouts to be an eyesore, but the people who responded to my post were pretty unanimous that I should paint the downspouts to match the brick.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    I like gutters and downspouts to visually disappear so match them to what the are next to. Much better look.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Haha! Jennifer and I were posting at same time.

  • 5 years ago

    a portion of the gutter actually runs down the siding, so matching the brick is moot here



    you could do something like theyve done here. diff color gutters.



    ON the portion w/the siding, could you paint them to match the siding color?

    And on the portion w/the brick, do the copper or the black or bronze?

  • 5 years ago

    Hey Flo - yes Groveraxle was the one who first posted on my dilemma, but I believe you were one of the consenting votes.


  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Much of that -- soffit & fascia, even the siding -- if still in good shape -- could be painted white instead of replaced with white.

  • 5 years ago

    Wow! Thank you all for your input, and Beth, thanks so much for all the visuals.

    With the exception of large gutter than runs across the front of the house, all gutters and downspouts are next to siding and stucco (additional picture added to show back of house). I never considered that it could be painted to match. My contractor wants over $7,000 to replace everything so painting could definitely be a option.

    I also didn't realize that the soffit and fascia could be a different color than the gutters and down spouts. I've been riding around my development like a crazy person looking at everyone's gutters and downspouts and for the most part they all match the soffit and fascia. I thought they should match....so that is good to know.

    So maybe I actually have two dilemmas! Maybe it's also the trim of my house that is also throwing things off for me. I am trying to brighten/freshen everything up.

    In my mind, I was thinking white would look similar to the pictures below.

    Thanks again, you guys are amazing!!!!

  • 5 years ago

    Oops forgot additional pic of siding/stucco in the back of the house.

  • 5 years ago

    I think white would be fine. If you do replace them get larger ones with larger leaders that handle heavy rain better.

  • 5 years ago

    I drove my neighborhood and several others when I wanted to update the outside of my last home. Found a house a few streets over that I liked and copied what they had done.


    I had dark brown trim and changed it to white and a caramel color and it made a huge difference.




    exterior · More Info


    exterior · More Info


  • 5 years ago

    "Although 5″ is considered the standard size for residential seamless gutters, many homeowners are upgrading to 6″ over sized gutters. Though a 6″ gutter is only an inch bigger it does handle 40% more water. The over sized downspout installed with these gutters can also handle more debris passing through them."


    When I replaced my gutters, I went up in size to 6" from 5". Good decision in my case!

  • 5 years ago

    @stax That is good information! Thank you.

  • 5 years ago

    @jenniferhogan Yes, I agree, that made a huge difference. In my area, white contrast trim is very popular right now. I actually like it...Of course after all of the great feedback and suggestions I received I am now questioning what I even like - lol....WHY are these decisions so hard.

  • 5 years ago

    My personal opinion is that I wouldn’t want my gutters to stand out or pop because they were a different color. The only exception I could see would be copper gutters naturally aged to a darkish color.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    real copper gutters are extrememly expensive. they have copper color gutters, and that woud be better. (and you could get the bright penny color, or numerous shades darker)

    natural copper rapidly oxidizes and turns an ugly brown. stays that color for over a decade before they get the natural blue/green patina.

    Is you siding paintable?

    what do you think about this dark siding w/your brick? and the black trim around the windows,


    remove the shutters on all windows, and if possible, paint the trim around the white windows the dark color


    then I'd do the stained wood porch ceiling


    and stained cedar wrap posts.




    With your new black door, I think it would look sharp. YOu could choose the black or the copper color gutters

    similar house style. more of a green color w/the black and white.


    what do you think about painting your brick?


    Almost the same as yours. they painted the brick to match the siding color. They also painted the rocking chairs black to match the shutters/door. White trim/posts.


  • 5 years ago

    I'd go black for gutters with black fascia and shutters.

  • 5 years ago

    Beth, girl, if I tell my husband I want to paint the entire house and add a stained porch ceiling, he just might divorce me - haha! He already thinks I've lost my mind replacing the gutters,soffit, etc! I actually like the painted brick idea though. Hadn't thought of that. Uughh! Now I know why people hire professionals to help with these decisions.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    I hear ya. I have the same husband. whenever I say, "hon, I have an idea....", he literally walks out of the room.

    look into Romabio. the classico Limewash is more of a wash, and can be squirted off within the first 72 hours. comes in different shades of white and beige tones.



    The Romabio Masonry Flat, is more opaque.


    These can be tinted any color.


    this used to be red brick. they used the Masonry Flat in Modern White


    These are mineral paints meant for stone and brick. they allow it to 'breathe' and will naturally patina. they don't require much maintenance. quick touchups every 10 years or so, if that.

    The beadboard ceiling isn't that much to do! lol, heck you could stain it yourself. ok, so, if not that, then you could paint what you currently have.

  • 5 years ago

    Don't get lost in the possibilities. We could all spend a fortune redoing the outside of our homes, but for me the goals are to have the inside as nice as I can afford and the outside nice enough that I like it and it doesn't cause stress or embarrassment. My mom always said "You live on the inside, you impress others with the outside."



  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    jennifer, Your mom had a point, but I don't think it's impressing anyone as much as taking pride in your home. Otherwise, our yards would all be dirt and colors wouldn't matter. Nice exteriors make the neighborhood look better, Has nothing to do w/impressing anyone. I couldn't give two figs what anyone thinks. I do it for me.