Hello! I've been a long-time lurker on Houzz, soaking in knowledge and ideas for home design, and the time has finally come where I have questions someone else hasn't already asked, at least that I can find. Apologies in advance...this post turned out very, very long by the end.
Preface: I am in the VERY rough idea stage for designing our future home. I'm still making my own basic floor plans in Photoshop to get a feel for what I want. We're nowhere close to getting a professional designer yet, but I don't think that's necessary for the question I have. Also, I am very much an amateur myself. Please be kind.
The Goal: to minimize my family crisscrossing through the kitchen and getting underfoot, like they do now, as much as possible. The practicality of the space is key.
The Conundrum: The kitchen would be in a corner of the house, enclosed with no thru-traffic. The two main aisles in from the dining area are alongside the center island's short end, as shown in my pics, with the long ends running into the kitchen. Fridge on one side wall (facing into the room), clean up sink on the other side wall, stove on back wall, prep sink in island, so there is a triangle between fridge - prep sink - cooktop. I can't decide which, between the fridge and prep sink, should be closer to the main aisle, and which one further in.
Important Notes:
1) The pictures provided are fairly to scale, but of course with a personal draft this rough, nothing is really set as far as placement or size. Those sorts of details aren't important to my question, I think.
2) Dimensions: Right now, I'm just planning for general spaciousness which can be shrunk and reworked as needed when designing gets real. The draft room is 15x15 ft. Center island 3.5x9 ft. Prep sink estimated to be ~16"x16". Aisles 42" all the way around. Walking space, counter space, and storage will not be an issue no matter what.
3) It's important to me that most of the island remain uninterrupted workspace. I couldn't abide by a centered prep sink.
4) I'm not sure if it would be a good idea to center the prep sink with the fridge. It would seem better to keep them staggered in case one person needs to open the fridge while another is using the sink. Someone using the countertop for prep can shift around, but someone using the sink has to stay where they are.
5) It's important to me to keep the refrigerator a respectful distance away from the wall ovens, just in case anyone wants to suggest putting them together for any reason. Regardless of any opinions about sufficient insulation, not a problem these days, etc, I don't want to mess with mixing heat and cold.
6) I have tried and dismissed several trial runs at including a corner pantry. Please, please, please don't ask about a corner pantry. Or diagonally placed appliances, like the stove top. I tried to make such ideas work. This general design simply works better for my needs and sensibilities than trying to shift appliances to the kitchen corners.
The Case for Design #1: prep sink closer to aisle, fridge deeper in kitchen
Pro: I very much like the idea of keeping the prep sink close to the main aisle. My family right now spends more time at our sink (G-shaped kitchen, one main sink) than at the fridge. The fridge is usually a quick in-and-out to grab whatever they need. The sink is the place to wash hands, open canned items, rinse fruits and veggies, stand around with rinsed fruit and eat it right there, etc. With this layout, they would only intrude around my island workspace to reach the fridge, then move back towards the main aisle for the rest.
Note: I keep a bowl of fresh fruit on my counter at all times, there for anyone to pick. Most everything gets washed before being cut/eaten, so the fruit/sink dynamic is important, and I'd like the bowl here to stay in the center island. It could easily and conveniently go right behind the prep sink in this design, easy to reach from anywhere.
Pro: I could also place a microwave and toaster oven (the other two main reasons for workspace invasion right now) along the counter/cabinetry next to the fridge, immediately inside the main aisle, again guiding my family back out rather than further in/around me.
Pro: I love the idea of a free-standing fridge, open on one side and unframed. No painstakingly pulling it out each time we need to look in the back. No trouble cleaning underneath and behind. No worrying about it creating an "unsightly" view as it's deeper in, and open on the side which faces away from the entrances and most of the workspaces. Also, fun fridge magnets!
Con?: It does seem like the refrigerator is very far away from the kitchen entrance, doesn't it? As far as I'm aware, fridges are supposed to be easy to reach, closer to the kitchen entrance than not. I could stagger it closer to the middle of the counter...but that would give it the cabinet framing I'd love to avoid. I could live with that if it were the best option, though.
Con?: I've seen many people here say they like having their prep sink close to their range. I wonder if there's a matter of practicality to this that I'm missing. The only reason I can think of why I'd go straight from the cooktop to a prep sink right now is maybe if I needed to strain and rinse off pasta, but I could also easily do that in the clean-up sink. I mean, we manage fine that way right now?
Case for Design #2: fridge closer to aisle, prep sink closer to stove
Pro: The fridge is close to the kitchen entrance, the way God intended. I guess. Does anyone have any horror stories about a refrigerator run requiring an inconvenient trek deep into the kitchen, to enlighten me about this design fundamental? In my experience/family, the fridge is nothing but a pit stop to gather necessary supplies, which are then taken straight to plate/prep/microwave/toaster/blender/etc. Right now that means stopping at the fridge, then trekking deeper in for everything else.
Con: This would mean a framed fridge (see Pro#3 under Design#1 for why I don't like that), since I'm not gauche enough to expose innocent eyes to the harsh realities of an unfinished fridge side when they're trying to eat. I run a classy joint. A tentative "pro" might be that I could build a cabinet to the left of the fridge (as shown) to fit the microwave, toaster, and some trash cans, keeping my family entirely out of the kitchen proper when they want to use those? Then again, the final design may likely see the fridge-side stretch of counter ending in a wall, if we push that wall up to shrink the admittedly massive "breakfast room" I have roughly penciled in there. So those appliances would have to be placed to the right of the fridge instead, further into the kitchen, where everyone will be lingering behind/around me while using them.
Pro?: The prep sink is close to the cooktop, the way God intended. Maybe. Most people seem to think it's very important? I need outside opinions here, because I can't visualize that kind of frequent back-and-forth for myself, not between those two spaces.
Con: On the left side of the island, the dining overhang creates a natural landing space to the left of the sink. Moving it to the other side of the island would mean having to leave a landing space there instead, as well as my family having to maneuver around me and plant themselves directly between my workspace and the stove whenever they want to enjoy their freshly-rinsed grapes.
Conclusion: In case you can't tell...I really like Design #1 better, for all the practical reasons I can think of. It achieves my goal best. But I can't help but feel like there's something I'm missing, given how that layout breaks the design fundamentals of "fridge close to entrance" and "prep sink close to stove." Help, please?
mama goose_gw zn6OH