Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_360354177

Frameless or Semi Frameless Shower!?!?

5 years ago

Doing some renovations to our fixer. Probably won’t be our forever home but it hasn’t been updated at all since about 2001 from the original owners. We’re painting the walls and vanity, changing the countertop to quartz, putting in LVP wood tone floors to warm up the space (mid century modern / modern farmhouse vibe). We ran out of budget to tile the shower and tub, currently just 4x4 white tile that just needs a deep clean. Should we go with a frameless or semi frameless shower? If I pay the extra $600 for frameless am putting lipstick on a pig? Attached are pictures of our current shower (gold frame), and frameless and semi frameless options from our glass guy.

Comments (12)

  • 5 years ago

    I despise framed showers so I am probably not the one to ask. I would say leave it be except for the god awful glass.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    We had a similar situation in our vacation home. I would have loved a total gut job, but it wasn't in the budget. We kept the tile in the shower but changed out the glass. Getting a new framed glass enclosure was the least expensive option and it worked out very well. We considered a frameless enclosure but didn't think it was worth the expense.

  • 5 years ago

    A framed enclosure in different color (black? Satin nickel? Shiny chrome? depending on your shower fixtures) will look nice, it is the current gold frame that is dated. The white square field tiles are classic, so you can leave them. Replace the soap dish with a niche. Replace the shower floor pan with a 2” tile.

  • 5 years ago

    A black enclosure would be a nice update. I don’t think the frameless look is worth the money.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    I would not replace the shower pan or the soap dish. Once you start breaking up the components of a shower, you invite problems--leaks and broken pipes, and possibly damage to adjacent rooms. If you want to wait until you can do a gut job, then just do the glass and some cosmetic updates for now.

  • 5 years ago

    I agree, the frameless is not worth it in this case. And definitely don't start replacing things like soap dishes and shower floors! I don't even know how that could be done and still maintain the waterproofing integrity. Just a good scrubbing is all it needs.

  • 5 years ago

    Thanks everyone! I’m leaning towards the semi frameless one too in a different color. Either chrome or black. Fixtures will be chrome (most cost effective). Vanity will be BM Chelsea gray with satin brass pulls (may change the pulls but that’s where we’re headed.) Probably changing the light fixture to something with black and satin brass. I really like the black frame idea but not sure if that’s too many metals going on. Any ideas?

  • 5 years ago

    I prefer the semi-frameless look. We have a semi-frameless shower with clear glass and matching porcelain tile on the walls, shower floor, and bathroom floor. The shower floor is 1” mosaic tiles with sanded grout for a non-slip finish. Include a niche or caddy for your shower and shampoo products, and a securely-attached safety bar or two if anyone has a mobility issue. We squeegee all the glass after every shower and use glass cleaner only occasionally.

  • 5 years ago

    I do think chrome, satin brass, and black would be a bit much. I don't mind mixing metals, but it seems that those 3 a lot for this smaller space. Maybe matte black vanity hardware, black shower door frame and chrome fixtures? Then all other metal choices, like light fixtures and towel bars, etc., can go between black and chrome.

  • 5 years ago

    Agree. If you want to use chrome for fixtures, then put black hardware on the vanity, black towel bars, black robe hooks, etc. And black shower frame. Chrome and black are enough. Don’t add brass. If the vanity comes with brass pulls replace them. There are tons of inexpensive black handles on a bunch of websites. Wayfair sells groups of 10 or more pulls in nice styles.

  • 5 years ago

    We were thinking of going with satin brass since we’re trying to go with warmer tones. But I see what you all are saying. I’ll go with chrome fixtures and play around with the hardware colors once we get everything painted. Fixtures will be chrome though for cost effectiveness. Shower door only takes a week to make so I can make the decision later.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Generally I would say it depends on the room around it - if you have frameless or trimless opening surrounding it then it will suit.