Software
Houzz Logo Print
diggerdee

Question and rose nursery recommendations

Hi everyone,


Years ago I was more active on this forum and also in growing roses. Then I focused on other, more suitable (to my shady yard) plants. I'm feeling the pull of roses again, and have been toying with adding a few.


I used to buy a LOT from Heirloom, but now I see their prices are waaaayyyyyy higher than they used to be! So my question is, is Heirloom worth it? As I recall, their plants were quite small but usually healthy and vigorous. Are they still offering the same little bands just for more money now?


If they are not - or, even if they are, for that matter! - worth it, can you give me a few recommendations for other reputable online nurseries? I prefer own-root roses.


Thank you (I think) for your help. Not sure it's safe to dip my toes back in the rose water or not, but here I go!


:)

Dee

Comments (16)

  • 5 years ago

    Hi! I recognise your username from reading older posts...nice to have you around!

    My favorite nursery to order from is High Country Roses, small bands but they grow fast and reasonable prices. They seem to have the best selection for cold zones, which is important to me but may not be such a priority for you, and the customer service is outstanding.

  • 5 years ago

    Heirloom moved from bands to gallons a number of year ago, and evrything I've gotten from them has been a substantial rose, similar to the size of RU's gallons. I've ordered quite a few with no issues. Although I haven't ordered from Heirloom for almost two years, given my lack of need for new roses, and the fact that their prices have skyrocketed.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Here's an older thread that might help:

    https://www.houzz.com/discussions/6146709/our-rose-photos-from-best-nurseries-to-order-from#n=49

    My favorite own-root nursery is LongAgoRoses in North Carolina, the price is low like High country roses, but the shipping cost is cheap $11 for 4 roses to my Chicagoland. See below link for pics. of own-roots from LongAgoRoses:

    https://www.houzz.com/discussions/1709358/what-about-long-ago-roses#n=48

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    I also recently got back to growing roses and GardenWeb after almost 30 years (I still remember a very active member "RoseNut" from Georgia who posted a lot at that time). I bled a lot of money to Heirloom this year because they have roses available all the time (the others own roots nurseries have been pretty much out of stock since Spring), easy to order online (like shopping in Amazon, other nurseries might require emails and phone calls), gallon size roses instead of band size, and hard to find varieties. But they are expensive, and I have received tiny gallon plant from Heirloom and I sent complaint with photos, and never received a reply. I need to contain myself and only buy the hard to find varieties from Heirloom like others had suggested here. I guess business is too good because people got back to gardening during the pandemia. Last week I saw Amazing Grace was available in Heirloom, immediately called to add order (I had pending to ship orders) but was told orders could not be modified once purchased (I think only David Austin let you change your order once purchased, they have wonderful customer service), so I had to pay full price plus shipping just to get that one rose. An hour later I checked their website out of curiosity, and it was out of stock again. Roses are hot commodities.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Yes, Heirloom roses are now much bigger than the olden days and I have been very happy with them. Straw posted the whole thread up there.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Yes, prices have certainly gone up but so have quality and overall plant sizes. They have frequent sales and shipping is often included when purchasing more than one plant. I purchased Firefighter, Velvet Fragrance and Deep Secret from them earlier this year which were easily the largest own root hybrid teas I have ever received. All have been extremely vigorous and provided dozens and dozens of flowers this summer, easily surpassing my expectations, even when compared to performance from *grafted* hybrid teas.


    I also like Roses Unlimited, Antique Rose Emporium, High Country Roses and A Reverence for Roses.

  • 5 years ago

    Thank you all for your input! I hadn't realized Heirloom now ships in gallons (for the life of me I can't find anything on their website that gives this kind of info!) Of course, that likely means higher shipping costs too.


    I'll have to think a bit. I'm a firm believer in "you get what you pay for" and I know from my own personal experience that Heirloom always had good quality plants. But fifty bucks a rose (give or take) is a bit steep for my budget right now so maybe I'll do like Michael and only buy the hard-to-find roses from them, and in the meantime try some other nurseries. So thank you all for your recommendations (some of which I do remember from my rose-growing years - good to see they are still in business!). I'll be looking into them and trying to restrain myself lol.


    :)

    Dee

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    @Michael 9bNorCal: "Rosenut" was Karl Bapst from Indiana; "Rosebud" was Steve Fenner from Georgia. Sadly, Karl Bapst died in 2014. I was a regular on this forum from about 1998-2010, but I was mostly gone for about 10 years until I retired, and came back a year ago. The biggest difference I see is the ability to post tons of pictures very easily, plus no limit on the length of threads, which can get overwhelming to me. I used to order tons of roses from Heirloom, and if I waited for a (fairly regular) sale, I could usually get them for $30 each, with free shipping. But for the past two years, their prices have skyrocketed. I guess in the overall scheme of things (and a long lived rosebush), $30 isn't that different from $50, but I'm with you in getting them elsewhere unless they had one I couldn't get elsewhere.

  • 5 years ago

    You might want to try Freedom Gardens, they're in Ohio. Peter is very knowledgable (he wrote Right Rose, Right Place)and has great roses.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    @susan9santabarbara: Thanks for refreshing my poor memory. Yes I meant "Rosebud" Steve from Georgia. You have an amazing memory!

  • 5 years ago

    A reverence for roses has been my favorite go-to for rarer roses of late. I check them almost daily. They carry many Austins (currently AUScot), Delbards (Nahema!) and delightful OGRs. I also encourage checking with Pam at Angel Gardens via email as her availability list isn't always accurate. I've gotten roses I've sought for a very long time from those two sources (as well as the kindness of @john_ca, whom I owe a few rose starts of my own!)

  • 5 years ago

    Fresh Garden Living on etsy.com has bands when it is safe to ship, so does Northland Rosarium.


    Be aware that there is a thread on Houzz stating that Heriloom is having security issues and you might want figure out some sort of credit card protection or see if you can send them a money order.

  • 5 years ago

    Thanks for all the further input! It's always helpful to have real-life experience to base one's buying decisions on, and to help know what to expect when buying online.


    Ann, yes, thank you, I did see the thread about Heirloom - while reading it I was somewhat surprised and dismayed because I remember them having good customer service. Unfortunately any company can get hacked, it seems, but the difference lays in how a company deals with it, and I would have thought they would have done better with their communications.


    I will be looking into all the recommendations. Thank you so much!

    :)

    Dee

  • 5 years ago

    Thank you Moses! I remember Chamblees... again, good to see they are still in business!


    :)

    Dee

  • 5 years ago

    Dee,


    Mark Chamblee retired, and the new owners retained the Chamblee name, but are located in Winona, Texas. Same quality 1 gallon roses.


    Moses