Software
Houzz Logo Print
case_lofton

Advice for front door & shutter update

5 years ago

I've grown tired of the maroon in my current color scheme. I like the look of wood, but I'm terrible at anticipating how things are going to look if they are changed. So I want to ask you guys for your opinions.


I'm considering replacing the panels in my double doors with glass inserts, stripping and staining it, and getting new shutters that match.


Would this change compliment the brick/facia/roof color scheme or clash with it? What would look best, dark or light stain?




Comments (22)

  • 5 years ago

    Can you take a picture of the entire front of your house from further back, and make it a little bigger than the one you have posted?

  • 5 years ago

    Could you take another picture from farther back so that we can see the whole front of the house as well as its setting (front yard, etc.)? Thanks.

  • 5 years ago

    Lighting isn't ideal at the moment, but hopefully these will work.


    Please forgive the condition of the "flowerbed". Until yesterday, it was FULL of Nandina so thick that it blocked the view of the entire left side of the house as high up as the bottom 1/4 of the windows,


  • 5 years ago

    I think you need to go lighter. The brick is really nice. You have a long, low roof line with a lot of shade. I think lighter will give the house more life. I would even consider a soft white. It looks like the shutters could be a little wider. Make sure each one is half the window's width.

    Black would be a nice, classic choice with the roof and brick, but I still think lighter is good.

    Case Lofton thanked chloebud
  • 5 years ago

    The window inserts may help, but I doubt I can get the Mrs to agree to white.


    I haven't measured them, but I thought the same about the shutters. The idea of getting a nice set of correctly sized shutters is actually what led to me wanting to strip and stain the door. If it happens that way, a couple of stained rocking chairs may follow.

  • PRO
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    That house should not have shutters I have no idea how inserts will be done well enogh in the door so my suggestion is a new garage door and front door in a more MCM style both with glass and then do some landscaping that suits the house this is my fave house color with brick and this is my go to for inspiration for landscaping. Notice the garage door and the front door.



    Case Lofton thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
  • 5 years ago

    Here's your house without shutters. I think I agree that it looks better without them. A front door in a more MCM style with windows would be nice too. The white wall/doors in the carport are a little distracting and I am wondering if a charcoal gray or green as suggested by @Patricia Colwell Consulting would make them recede into the background and not be so obvious. I am also concerned about the lovely little tree at the left. It looks like it is too close to the house. Perhaps a landscaper could advise you as to whether it could be moved, and maybe s/he could also offer suggestions for planting, hardscape, lighting, etc., for your nice front yard area. Maybe some new front door lights. You have a lovely house in a beautiful setting. Lots of potential!


    Case Lofton thanked nester44
  • 5 years ago

    I agree on lighter, but, I suggest a very light teal or turquoise, or a very light green. I love the idea of a couple of rockers, but, I would want them, the same color as the shutters and door, and make sure they have bright colored cushions. Your house needs a bit of color. Flowers in your landscaping would also be nice. Your flower beds appear straight across and narrow, from your pictures, I would bring them out a bit, and put some curves in them, for much better curb appeal.

    Case Lofton thanked cat_ky
  • 5 years ago

    Please, no shutters. New landscaping will add the curb appeal you seek.

    Case Lofton thanked chiflipper
  • 5 years ago

    No shutters? I hadn't even considered that. I'm just so accustomed to seeing them on most houses. I was planning to go the fully functional route. I'm not positive how I feel about this. I think I will take them down for a while to see the difference. I'd also like to know why the house should not have them.


    Eventually, I'd like to close in the carport, but doing it the way I prefer (brick) will require adding footers, matching the brick, and possibly even repouring the garage floor. Yet, somehow I still haven't convinced myself that I won't hate it if I went with siding,


    Replacing the front doors have been near the top of my to do list for a while now. Unfortunately, there are few that I actually like, and the purchase prices alone on those approach (and in a couple of examples, exceed) the estimates I've been given for the garage conversion.


    I stumbled across the glass inserts while looking for doors. I need to do more reading about them, but they appear to be a potential solution.


    The green looks nice, I still can't help but wonder how stain would look. One of the paint companies should make a site to help customers choose paint by uploading a pic of their house for a virtual preview of different paint colors.


  • 5 years ago

    I suspect a lot of paint companies have that sort of thing on their websites but I have personally never used them. Some of the pro designers here should be able to help you.

    Case Lofton thanked nester44
  • 5 years ago

    I had no idea that shutters and stain were out of style.


    Will someone show me an example of a nice MCM style door with windows?


    The carport walls are the same light grey color as the soffit/fascia. I was ok with this color, but will consider the suggestions. Is the recommendation for only the carport walls or for the soffit/fascia as well.


    You guys are good at spotting details. The tree between the windows IS too close to the roof/fascia, but my wife likes it, so it has survived my efforts to tame the jungle that the previous owner planted. The flower beds ARE straight and narrow, and need redesigning. I intend to do as much as I can myself, and I'm still in the process of removing overcrowded beds and remnants of various invasive species. Here's a few before pics:






  • 5 years ago

    Case, shutters and wood are not out of style. It's just that they have to suit the style of the house and windows (including window size). That being said, It's also important what appeals to YOU.

    The gray/green in Patricia's photo would look really nice with your brick. Maybe just a bit lighter since the front door needs to come out of the shadows.

    This link might help with the shutter issue.

    https://www.lifeofanarchitect.com/residential-architecture-101-shutters/

    Case Lofton thanked chloebud
  • 5 years ago

    Thank you for clarifying.


    I suppose that it is evident by now that I have close to zero knowledge regarding housing styles. My plan was to pick the parts that I liked from various homes and to put them all together. It SEEMED like a good plan, but I can already see where it could go wrong quickly.


    I suspect that this may be why my wife picks out what I wear to church. lol


    I'm interested in gaining the knowledge needed to make good choices in the future and welcome any other helpful links that you guys can provide.


    Thanks to everyone that has offered input

  • 5 years ago

    Laura Gaskill has several feature stories on Houzz that are entitled "Your Guide to......." various house and decorating styles. They are very informative. I don't know what the style of your house is inside, but people usually (not always, but usually) have the same design style on the exterior and interior. You don't, for example, typically see a house with a strong MCM exterior that has a cottage-style interior. Your house looks to me to be a ranch-style. You could give it some MCM flair with the right front door and other MCM embellishments (porch lights, house numbers, landscaping), if that jibes with what the interior is like.

  • 5 years ago

    Good riddance to the nandina - I hate it. Don't be surprised if it comes back; keeping it at bay can be a regular job. If you plant something in its place, look for dwarf varieties that will stay below the window sills, and keep after the nandina that will continue to surface. I'd like to see more emphasis on the porch, front doors and lighting. On some houses from a certain era, I don't mind faux, decorative shutters. They were "in" at one time. What I dislike about yours is the louvers; a very 70's style, IMO, and difficult to keep clean. If you decide to use shutters, I'd change them to a better size and a different style. You might consider painting your facia and eaves in a darker color from the brick and then match the doors and any shutters to that creamier white in the brick. That would pull the entry out a bit visually. Add a pair of Adirodack or other comfy chairs you like on the porch. Consider a pop of color with pots of thriller, filler, spiller plantings.

  • 5 years ago

    CRAP!


    I was trying to figure out how to quote or reply to specific comments and accidentally reported chloebud's post as spam. I'm sorry chloebud!


    @chloebud


    Thank you. We love the brick too. They are one of the reasons that we chose this house. I made a thread requesting assistance in identifying them and I'm hoping the right person comes along with some solid information. Here's a link:


    https://www.houzz.com/discussions/6170934/help-identify-brick



    @nester44


    Thank you. I called myself "looking", but didn't find them. I'm not having the best of luck navigating the site.


    I don't know what style my house is inside either!!! LOL I do plan to learn before making changes.



    @decoenthusiaste


    The thing that I hate about nandina is that you can't just move it and be done. The bed that it came from will likely be empty for months because I want to try to make sure that I've got it out of there.


    Believe it or not, I'm actually considering replanting it along the open side of my carport. That area is in the view of my carport doorbell camera. When the camera detects motion, it sends a text notification, makes an announcement inside the house, and records 90 seconds of video,

    The gate for my neighbor's backyard is in between our houses. He uses it about 7 billion times a day, and we get the notifications, announcements, and videos each time.


    I've visited the idea of blocking the view between the houses several times, but haven't found a quick/simple solution that I can accept. Now I suddenly find myself with with all of this nandina, and I think it would do the job until I close in the carport.

  • 5 years ago

    "I was trying to figure out how to quote or reply to specific comments and accidentally reported chloebud's post as spam. I'm sorry chloebud!"

    No problem, Case! Looks like it didn't affect my positng. :-)

  • 5 years ago

    Case - This is a good story to bookmark - and if you scroll down you will find links to her other "Your Guide to..." stories. I hope this helps.


    https://www.houzz.com/magazine/your-guide-to-12-popular-decorating-styles-stsetivw-vs~123846244



    Case Lofton thanked nester44
  • 5 years ago

    Here's a pic after removing the shutters and nandina.



    I experienced a brief moment of decent decision making and opted against replanting it.



    What is the consensus regarding vinyl fascia/soffit and gutters?


    What about security lighting? Motion activated flood lights hung from the soffit maybe?


    Just thought it may be easier to take care of stuff like that while there was minimal plants to trample.

  • 5 years ago

    I personally don't like the typical security flood lights -- I think they make the house look too industrial and fortress-like. But perhaps there are motion-activated lights that are more decorative and would suit the house. And maybe you could find more substantial-looking front porch lights that are the same style as whatever security lights you choose so that you don't have a mish-mash of lights in the front of the house. Designing outdoor lighting is something a landscape designer could help you with. You have to balance many requirements: enough light for security and safety while being mindful of the needs of the birds and animals living in the area that require natural night darkness for their circadian rhythms and normal nocturnal activities.

    Case Lofton thanked nester44
Sponsored
The Steele Group
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars1 Review
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio