The door you have echoes the side windows of the bay which to me is good. Are the house numbers difficult to read from the street? Sometimes the vertical arrangement is hard to read. There is also no light by the door. A house number plaque under a light is easier to read at night .The steps would be better as wide as the stoop with at least a rail on one side for safety.

I like the door you have. I would like it painted, so its more noticable, and remove the numbers off it, and put them on the house. Bigger ones would be nice, and yes, to an outside light.

A pair of sconces or wider crooked neck wall light will make your entry safer and add some interest to the look.

Hi Sharon, Great idea! thinking of moving the one spiral tree to frame door, trying to picture how scones or wall light will look.

Yes, I agree with replacing the front door. The colonial style door is just wrong on a four square.

https://thecraftsmanblog.com/american-foursquare-style/

Your house needs a door that is more in the prairie/ craftsman style.