Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_910962082

Oversized or standard sink?

5 years ago


We are on the final stretch of our new home build. I am blind and have found the articles and discussions here very helpful. This is my first time to post a question. This is our master vanity. Since it is a single sink we were thinking of doing a larger trough style. The center section is quite wide(39"). However, now we are rethinking and deciding a standard sink will be fine. My concern is that it might look strange and shrunken mounted above those big doors. If we do opt for the standard rectangular would it improve things to offset it to the left and center it above the left door? The cabinets are ash wood stained Verathane Carbon Gray and the countertops will be MSI Calcutta Ultra either size sink will be undermounted. Thanks for your thoughts!

Comments (18)

  • 5 years ago

    I think a smaller sink would look fine. I'd keep it centered. Some of the trough-style sinks don't seem to drain very well if they have flat bottoms, so I like smaller sinks.

    Sheila G. thanked petula67
  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Factor in the fact that most likely only two people will experience your decision.

    Sheila G. thanked Mark Bischak, Architect
  • 5 years ago

    Counter space is far more important than an odd, counter swallowing, sink, that still isn’t big enough for 2 people to share.

    Sheila G. thanked User
  • 5 years ago

    I vote for a single large stainless steel sink. Is it for show, or do you cook? Today pots and pans are large, and real cooks, do dishes.


  • 5 years ago

    Most people don’t cook in their bathrooms. Though a coffee bar isn’t unheard of.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    As is you have 18-20" of counter space remaining on each side with a 20" lav . The space in front of the towers must be clear.

    Sheila G. thanked Jeffrey R. Grenz, General Contractor
  • 5 years ago

    Y'all! I wonder if my daughter accidentally put in the coffee bar portion of the drawings instead of the master vanity I requested....sorry for the confusion. Good thoughts here and Lyn , I do cook for our family of five and have a double bowl sink planned for the kitchen. :-)

  • 5 years ago

    I would want counter space over a large bathroom sink.

  • 5 years ago

    Can you just envision which would work best for you? This house had a 7' vanity with 32" elongated oval sink in the middle of it so 2' each side when we bought it. There are two masters in this house and DH prefers the shower in the smaller second master so uses that bathroom - we don't share the one in our bedroom ;0) We've never appeared at the sink at the same time to want two so it works for us. Now if we had three teens in the house with everyone wanting out the door at the same time it could be different, but I appreciate some room each side of the sink so things don't feel crowded. I don't find the elongated sink to be either helpful or space hogging. I'm not sure I would have purchased it but I don't either like or dislike it.

    Sheila G. thanked morz8 - Washington Coast
  • 5 years ago

    Yes, Mark Bischak I meant it literally and found your account hilarious. I'll have to get my husband to cooperate with me in a similar manner. My eyes look normal and from years of experience I can fool new acquaintances for a while that I am looking into their faces. Back to my question-my biggest worry was that it was going to look odd having a standard sink with the wide area underneath but y'all have assured me that isn't much of an issue. I get stuck on overthinking visions in my head sometimes.;-) Thanks to all you helpful houzzers. This experience will probably have me posting again.

  • 5 years ago

    I think a smaller sink would be a good partial choice. The other part of the choice would be a vanity designed for that smaller sink. Not one meant for a larger sink. Reverse the situation. If your vanity center cabinet was a smaller width for a smaller sink you'd have to redesign the size. Why not use a smaller cabinet sink base here? Your drawer bases can be wider, say 30" with a 24" center. Those drawers will be convenient.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    There was also his story of when my client explained at length to a cashier how the Federal Reserve uses different weight paper when they print money so the blind can tell the difference between the different denomination of bills. My client demonstrated by having the cashier hand him different bills and he would feel the bill in his hand and accurately tell the cashier each bill's value. He even turned his head so the bills were impossible to be seen. My client was so convincing the cashier did not notice his friend writing the value of each bill on his back as he felt each bill in his hand.

    Use the sink that functions the best.

  • 5 years ago

    Standard sink. I don't see why oversized would be of any service in a bathroom.

    Sheila G. thanked Mrs Pete
  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    First, do the two of you stand at the sink at the same time to brush your teeth for example?

    Everyone on this thread seems to know what size a "standard sink" is. However in my experience a sink with the word "standard" could be any size. Please clarify what width sink you would have when referring to a "standard sink". While I agree that a 39" width is overkill in a bathroom - that is, if the two of you will not be standing at the sink at the same time - I want to make sure the sink you are referring to will be an adequate width.

    Sheila G. thanked M Miller
  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    M Miller, very true on using the term "standard". My builder made a comment the other day which explained why we went over budget on many things! His idea of standard was definitely not the same as mine!

    Sheila G. thanked chispa
  • 5 years ago

    Dan, I so wish I would have realized the width of the center section sooner. Would totally have done just that . However, our cabinets are scheduled to be delivered tomorrow and they are custom so I am too late. M Miller. the sink which I was calling 'standard' has a rectangular basin of roughly 18X15. After I began thinking of how much extra water it would take for my husband when shaving and also know that the times we would need it simultaineously would be rare I began to have second thoughts about a bigger sink-not to mention the fact that they are pretty pricey. Mark B- I am cracking up over the money story. I need to meet this guy.

    We are looking forward to move day.


  • 5 years ago

    The bowl of my (pedestal) bathroom sink is 18 X 12 X 6. The faucet is arched high enough that I can easily wash my hair in this sink -- my preferred location.

    Sheila G. thanked chisue