I vote for the longer version

Go big or go home!

Power recliner? Have you accounted for distance the coffee table will need to sit away from sofa to utilize the full (or any) recliner extended positions? A marble topped table seems too heavy to push out of way so the recliner can be used & a nusiance to have to push out of way for use. I have a power reclining sofa in a bonus room across from TV like your arrangement & a love seat with ottoman where your tree is. No coffee table but do have big end table / cabinets with lamps at each end of reclining sofa. Only the end seats on sofa recline. My point being, I don’t have a coffee table due to having reclining sofa. Maybe you want to get a reclining chair instead if you really want coffee table?

KW - That’s a good point. The coffee table isn’t actually true marble but a marbled quartz.

Irene - There’s a version that is 60” but my sofa is only 82.” I believe the “rule” is to have the coffee table no more than 2/3 the width of the sofa?

@bobavaspaniel Have you picked up a small 12” x 12” piece of quartz? It is very heavy! I looked at the table you show from Room & Board - it’s @ 140 lbs per R & B info so not like it can be easily moved. That quartz is much thinner than counter type at 3/4” thickness so @ 10 lbs sq ft. I think that weight is a point to keep in mind for both your current coffee table search & future sofa recliner purchase.