Software
Houzz Logo Print
lola_buonomo17

1930s kitchen slab or shaker?

4 years ago

Hi! I need some help deciding on cabinets for a 1930s home renovation. We did ikea, but now our cabinets paneling (grimslov) is discontinued and after much debate we are faced with two options 1) ringhult slab high gloss cabinets 2) DIY semi handmade shaker style painted BM pale oak

I think shaker may go with the home style, ringhult may go more with our 1960s MCM furniture.

Some photos below are from our kitchen bases, living room for style & BM pale oak trim color. Shaker style is sample similar to semi handmade and slab style is rinhukt.

Please help! It’s my first home reno and I am so nervous about this big of a decision.

ringhult slab high gloss white
DIY shaker semi-handmade BM Pale Oak

Comments (8)

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Lola! It is duplicate post.

  • 4 years ago

    Somehow it posted twice! And now I don’t know how to delete! Haha help me here too if you know and I can delete the duplicate

  • 4 years ago

    Definitely shaker!

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    REally I would not do shaker in a MCM environment I do not think the interior of a home needs to follow the exterior in style. This is my kitchen in a 1905 house IMO you do the interior to suit your style you need to be able to enjoy the style you like in a space you live in


  • 4 years ago

    The most successful and long-lasting (meaning they don't look out of place after 10 to 15 years) are those that follow the lead of the house's origins and style.

  • 4 years ago

    Semi handmade is grossly overpriced for their paint grade shaker doors. Grossly overpriced. Those average $30-$50 from any local cabinet maker.

  • 4 years ago

    people next door bought the 1926 bungalow and she has MCM furnishings all over the place. Point is there is no rule anymore. . spaces can be what you like. I prefer those glossy slab doors above. Work on hardware tiling lighting. for your aesthetic leanings. those cabs will stand the test of time. the kitchen shown w the glossy white slab doors could be in any era of home. Good Luck.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Do what you prefer.

    I live in a high rise built in 1965 and the realtors list it as MCM but really it has no discernible architectural style. The original loby had Saltillo tiles and French Provincial furniture including murals of the French countryside because that is what the builder's wife liked 🤣

    All of the kitchens have been done and most relatively recently - e.g. within the past decade and they run the gamut in styles and reflect either the owners' personal aesthetic vision or a flipper's idea of what will sell - hint that the flipper kitchens are generally white or gray Shaker doors. 🤣

    I recently remodeled and went with what could be best described as inspired by Prairie architecture of Frank Lloyd Wright in terms of cabinets but the rest of my furnishings are a mix of very contemporary, vintage Art Deco, Hollywood Regency and even some authentic MCM stuff inherited from my parents.

    ETA - It appears from the fireplace and flooring that you are already in a traditional style home and the MCM furniture blends well with the house and the aesthete. I think people forget that when people actually furnished homes in the MCM era, many of them were a hodgepodge of different styles that the people liked. For example, my mother decorated at the height of the 1950's and had some MCM very classic walnut furniture with a very MCM sofa but she also had Chinese Deco rugs and a Chinese Deco armoire - a Queen Ann style desk; some Chinoiserie going on; a Neo Baroque chandelier from the 19tyh century that was originally a gas light fixture which was probably in the fancy parlour of a brownstone (my father rewired for electricity). My friend has the classic MCM teak side table now as I could no longer use it.