They all are really nice, and as I looked at each one, I thought that's the one.

I ended up voting for #3 because I liked that it had some more color to it. All of them blend well with your setting but #3 has something more. It blends and has a bit more interest.

That said though, I could be talked into any of them :)

I also voted for #3. The only one I did not like was #1, despite the fact that I like abstract art, But that one is just a muddle like an out-of-focus image of the rug. You need something with more definition, IMO.

Waterscape for me.

Thank you! I was leaning toward that one too!

I love #3! it seems to pull the rug right in and create the illusion of a long waterway, just beautiful. Let us know which one you go with! You chose some very nice art for your lovely room.

Thank you!!!