hi patricia! lol

replace it. any leftovers of the counters?

see if a stone place has any remnant black leathered leftovers.

Or how about a piece of wood stained to match your floors?

It reads as an extension/second tier of your counter so that’s what I’d go with.

Yep, I'd replace it with the black granite; as was mentioned, think of it as an extension of your counter.

I love your island color, BTW!

mxk3 this is hilarious. I hate that color!

"mxk3 this is hilarious. I hate that color!"

Why? Does it not go with everything else (can't tell from your pics) or the color too strong for you? But hey that's okay -- it's just paint, don't like it then just paint it. :0)