I’d square off the shower and make the tub even with it (not at an angle).

It kind of sounds like you want a tub and your wife wants a makeup vanity next to the shower. that is the first decision to make.

if you decide on a tub i think an alcove tub is so much easier to clean around than a freestanding tub. Think about cleaning the floor around the freestanding tub. What a hassle.

Thanks Suki. Seems like we have room for both given the current vanity width. I do like alcove tubs but it will close off the room a bit, was my fear

If I am figuring correctly, if the makeup area is between the sinks, each sink would be in a 30” wide cabinet and the makeup area would be 30” wide wide. You would be losing drawer storage space that you currently have and where would the makep be stored?

You have a wonderful space to work with for your bathroom. Sometimes it's more difficult to do a layout that is pleasing and not overwhelming and confusing.

Consider relocating the position of the door to accommodate the design. Here's a layout I would suggest.

The main focus should be the freestanding tub / window / and wall design, as you enter the bath. There are so many ways to treat the wall behind the tub, and that's where you should start the design finishes. Consider adding a contrasting floor tile border around the tub.

Separate the two vanities, with "his" between the toilet and shower, and "hers" in the corner, with storage next to the door and makeup vanity. The makeup vanity should be a furniture piece creating a functional vignette with lighting, storage, mirror, seat.

Other tub inspiration

Thanks for your ideas.

Would love to hear your comments and post what you finally decide!

Spoke to a designer who suggested consistency with the layout I suggested. Although we are waffling on whether a tub is really necessary or just storage and a makeup vanity/jewelry center instead of the tub