Paint post sage green as the trim. Paint the shutters the same sage green but in a gloss finish. Paint the storm door olive. Right now storm door is framing the front door, making it look smaller and less important.

Love you are flying the American flag.

I would go with shutters with the same color as your stripes and black door.

What color is that on window trim? I would consider that for shutters and post.

Use a 3rd green for posts and shutters.

Good ideas by others, I just came to say I love your charming house and colors you’ve chosen. 😍

Reminds me of this beauty (c. 1923) I’ve had saved a while:

Thank you, Actually I had found that picture also, and it was my inspiration.

I have always thought the trim out of the window and the shutters should be the same. One is supposed to assume the shutters have a purpose and can close. They are a whole. Love the darker tone in your inspiration pic.