I think it needs to be way brighter— the chili pepper has too much black in it for under the covered porch. I love a red door and it will look stunning against the earth colors.

Great Choice, it's stunning!

I like the red pepper. Its a pretty color.

When you paint the door, paint the frames around the little windows for a more cohesive look. I think one of these Benjamin Moore colors would look stunning.

Great color and plays well with the sage green/grey trim.

I like your red sample and the Carriage Red posted by houssan. Looks good.

Because I’m not a fan of red anything lol and like complementing a house’s color scheme, I prefer a shade like below, which will enhance the lovely stone.

If you want the door to be centre stage, go bold, but consider a more complementary (and unusual) shade.

Color me concerned about the difference between the two photos -- what looks bright up close may end up nearly invisible from the end of the sidewalk! I like lisedv's suggestion of the white trim, but I also suspect you may need to push the color a bit to get it to show in the porch cave.

I love a front door that references a color in the landscaping. If you don’t want to add color, a bright green to match your shrubbery would make it look very cohesive. If you like the red, you might add coleus to your plantings. Whatever color you choose, add a bit of it to your garden.

The matching the flowerbeds is a very nice idea when you live in an area where flowers grow year round but I would think a purple front door might look out of place in a winter scenery.

That’s a good point, lisedv. In a cold climate, you might want to think about evergreen shrubs as color inspiration for your door so it isn’t hanging out there on its own in the winter. :)

I love the colors in Maureen's photos, especially the first one..

If Maureen’s door was my color choice, I might plant this blue spruce color nearby.